The chaos inside Hegseth’s defense department that left Trump ‘concerned’ by scale of purge

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has fired the Pentagon’s top military planner, Army Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, at a time when President Donald Trump is openly musing about the prospect of further strikes on Iran after the midterms. asserted

Sylvia was removed on October 28 as head of strategy, plans and policy on the Joint Chiefs of Staff, with no replacement named and no official reason given for his departure. asserted

He is the second person to be ousted from the all-important role: his predecessor, Lt. Gen. Joseph McGee, was forced into retirement a year earlier. asserted

A spokesperson for the Joint Staff said: “The Chairman, the Joint Staff, and the Joint Force extend our deepest gratitude to Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia and his family for their 32 years of distinguished service to our nation.” asserted

They added that they “wish him and his family the best.” asserted

Sylvia is the latest casualty in what critics describe as an unprecedented purge of military leadership on Hegseth’s watch, which even Trump has reportedly expressed “concern” about in private. uncertain

The defense secretary addressed the broader issue of cuts during an ideology-heavy speech at Marine Corps Base Quantico in September. asserted

He announced additional 10 percent cuts to positions reserved for generals and admirals, having already made 10 percent cuts to those roles in 2025. asserted

“The media calls that a purge,” Hegseth said. asserted

“I call it accountability and long overdue. asserted

Below, we look at some of the high profile Pentagon departures during his tenure so far. asserted

The first casualty of Hegseth’s tenure was the 40-year Air Force veteran Gen. Charles Q Brown Jr, who was replaced by Lieutenant General Dan “Razin’” Caine as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff in February 2025. asserted

Brown, who had made history as the Air Force’s first African American chief of staff, had been in the post for 16 months and had expected to continue his term until the fall of 2027. asserted

Trump said in a statement announcing Caine’s nomination that he had been “overlooked” by his predecessor Joe Biden, an apparent slight on Brown, who was nevertheless praised as “a fine gentleman and an outstanding leader.” Adm. Lisa Franchetti Hegseth also fired Franchetti – the first woman to serve as chief of naval operations and the first female member of the Joint Chiefs – that same month without explanation. asserted

Biden had nominated her over the preference of his own defense secretary, Lloyd Austin, convinced by her vast experience in command and executive decision making. asserted

Hegseth’s opposition invited concern from other women in the service, who feared they too could be blocked from advancing. uncertain

Gen. Tim Haugh Next to go was the director of the U.S. National Security Agency, who was fired along with his deputy Wendy Noble in April last year. Haugh and Noble’s departures reportedly came after consultation with MAGA influencer Laura Loomer, who beamed on X that they had been dismissed because they had been “disloyal to President Trump” and “handpicked” by former chairman of the Joint Chiefs, Gen. Mark Milley. uncertain

Loomer’s apparent role in the firings led to expressions of concern on Capitol Hill. Vice Adm. Shoshana Chatfield Four days after Haugh’s axing, the former Navy helicopter pilot and combat veteran was fired from her role as U.S. representative to the NATO Military Committee. That came after she reportedly appeared on a “woke” list drawn up by the Trump administration, which took exception to her past advocacy for diversity in the Armed Forces. uncertain

According to the Associated Press, Chatfield was informed by Admiral Christopher Grady, the then-acting chairman of the Joint Chiefs, that the administration wanted to go in a different direction. uncertain

The following August, the Air Force chief of staff was dismissed with the same message as Chatfield, prompting him to retire two years into his four-year term. Allvin was thanked for his “transformational” efforts in the role but an insider told The Washington Post his early retirement was “certainly not his choice.” The general nevertheless issued a statement in which he said: “More than anything, I’m proud to have been part of the team of airmen who live out our core values of integrity, service and excellence every day as we prepare to defend this great nation.” Lt. Gen. Jeffrey Kruse There were to be more departures that month, including that of Kruse as head of the Defense Intelligence Agency, which had determined that the administration’s Operation Midnight Hammer airstrikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities were less effective than Trump and Hegseth had claimed. While the president and his secretary had repeatedly insisted Iran’s capabilities had been “obliterated,” the DIA put out a report suggesting they had only been set back by a matter of months, infuriating Trump. asserted

Also leaving their posts at this time were Vice Adm. Nancy Lacore and Rear Adm. Milton Sands, departing as chiefs of the Navy Reserve and Naval Special Warfare Command respectively. Gen. Randy George asserted

After a period of relative calm – other than the loss of the aforementioned three-star Lt. Gen. McGee from the Pentagon’s Joint Staff in October – Hegseth dismissed the Army’s chief of staff in April this year, perhaps his most controversial call coming a little over a month into the Iran conflict. asserted

The decorated veteran’s firing reportedly came after another clash with Hegseth and was met with solemn scenes when he broke the news to colleagues and indignation in Congress, where the Senate Armed Forces Committee pressed the secretary for an explanation. uncertain

The Army’s top uniformed officer has since been replaced on an acting basis by Gen. Christopher LaNeve, who has yet to be confirmed by the Senate. asserted

Three weeks after George was let go, Hegseth ousted the head of the Navy, replacing him with then-undersecretary Hung Cao on an acting basis, shortly after Iran’s move to shut off the Strait of Hormuz caused a spike in global oil prices. asserted

“President Trump and Secretary Hegseth agreed new leadership at the Navy is needed,” a senior administration official told The Independent at the time. asserted

The plight of sailors aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, diverted to the Gulf because of the war and starved of necessities, has since come to light, drawing attention to the strain being placed on U.S. military resources by the war. Gen. Christopher Donahue asserted

After Phelan, the next to leave the military’s hierarchy was the commander of U.S. Army forces in Europe and Africa. asserted

Donahue was famously the last American soldier to leave Afghanistan in 2021 and enjoyed a distinguished career leading Delta Force units in Iraq and Afghanistan before commanding the 82nd Airborne Division. asserted

Maj. Gen. Christopher Norrie, Donahue’s deputy, has since stepped in as his interim replacement. asserted

Army Secretary Dan Driscoll then resigned on September 1 amid reports of tensions with Hegseth. asserted

As with Sylvia, no official reason was offered for his departure after 18 months in the role but CNN and Reuters reported he had been butting heads with Hegseth for several months. asserted

The Atlantic reported he had raised concerns about the state of the military with Trump in the Oval Office, who was said to have been left “surprised and concerned” by what he heard. asserted

Driscoll is an Iraq War veteran, tech investor and former adviser to Vice President JD Vance, whom he befriended while they were contemporaries at Yale Law School. asserted

When nominating him in 2024, Trump hailed Driscoll as “a disruptor and change agent.” asserted

He went on to make good on that reputation by championing the development of drone warfare technology – only for Hegseth to shut down a European unit focused on that field in August and order it to return to its “core” mission of airborne infantry. asserted

He subsequently gave an interview to Rolling Stone in which he acknowledged differences of opinion with Hegseth, while adding: “If you polled us, we probably agreed on more than 50 percent of things. asserted

What’s been reported is all the things we disagree on.” asserted

Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia Sylvia, who previously commanded the storied 101st Airborne Division at Fort Campbell, Kentucky, was ousted after a year of serving as the Pentagon’s top military planner, having replaced the retired Lt. Gen. McGee. His departure was controversial as it came with less than a week to go before the midterm elections, for which Trump had been touring the country and telling rally crowds he could launch further airstrikes against Iran aimed at ending the unpopular war he started the previous February. uncertain

The conflict remains mired in deadlock, having cost American lives and driven up domestic gas prices. asserted