Montreal police say a 16-member patrol unit rocked by a racism scandal remained armed and active for nearly a full day after investigators secured enough evidence to take action about allegations some officers engaged in criminal misconduct.
asserted
officers → say → misconduct
Police chief Fady Dagher announced at a late Friday evening news conference in mid-June that he was dismantling the unit, explaining the force was moving as fast as possible to protect the public.
But police confirmed they took a day to prepare their move when asked about internal documents showing that investigators reached a threshold justifying “decisive management actions” on June 11, one day before they intervened.
asserted
they → announce → June
Police say the officers were on duty from 9 p.m. on June 11 until approximately 6:30 a.m. the following morning, during which they were assigned to respond to emergency calls.
asserted
they → say → calls
A few hours later, police say they dismantled the unit, between 8:30 p.m. and 9 p.m. on June 12.
asserted
they → say → June
“Several logistical issues had to be resolved, including replacing the entire team to avoid any interruption of services to the public,” police told The Canadian Press in an emailed statement.
asserted
police → have → statement
The police force declined to address questions about whether any members had direct contact with the public between June 11 and June 12.
asserted
members → decline → June
The internal documents were part of a briefing package prepared for Dagher, prior to an appearance at municipal hearings in August.
asserted
documents → prepare → August
The Canadian Press obtained the documents through access to information legislation.
asserted
Press → obtain → legislation
Ericka Alneus, Montreal’s official Opposition leader, said Dagher needs to be more transparent about what happened, warning that public trust in the force is low.
“This new information raises questions and concerns, at a time when trust with citizens is already fragile,” Alneus told The Canadian Press in a statement.
asserted
Alneus → say → statement
“It is urgent that Mr. Dagher provide an explanation and work to rebuild the relationship with Montrealers.”
asserted
Dagher → provide → Montrealers
The unit operated in Montréal-Nord, a multicultural borough in the city’s northeast with a history of tensions between residents and police, including allegations of police brutality.
asserted
unit → operate → brutality
Police began investigating the team in March after receiving internal complaints about alleged racism and criminal misconduct, including reports that officers cut the hair of racialized citizens and kept it as trophies.
asserted
officers → begin → trophies
All 16 members of the unit were removed from their regular duties, with two initially suspended, three assigned administrative duties and 11 reassigned.
asserted
11 → remove → duties
By August, four officers had been suspended.
asserted
officers → suspend → August
Police also referred evidence involving four officers to public prosecutors, who have not yet announced whether criminal charges will be laid.
asserted
charges → refer → prosecutors
Ted Rutland, a Concordia University geography professor who researches policing and racial profiling in Montreal, questioned whether the police acted fast enough.
“Could they not have predicted these logistical challenges and, you know, prepared a better plan of action so that they could act more quickly
uncertain
they → research → action
?” he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
Rutland said the need to maintain emergency services was understandable but questioned whether the officers could have been temporarily removed from patrol duties while replacements were arranged.
uncertain
replacements → say → duties
Canada welcomes EU leaders to Montreal for talks on next steps in relationship
-
asserted
Canada → welcome → relationship
Fire at New Brunswick military base not threat to public: defence officials
- ‘Local Governance 101’ Okanagan community’s first-ever council trains ahead of inaugural meeting
- Family of soldier badly burned at CFB Wainwright speaks about his injuries
asserted
Family → train → injuries
Alain Babineau, a former RCMP staff sergeant who now works on racial profiling issues with the Red Coalition, a Montreal-based anti-racism organization, also noted how it took police three months to dismantle the patrol unit after they started the investigation.
asserted
they → work → investigation
“Your number 1 duty is to protect the public, and they failed, in my opinion,” he said.
asserted
he → protect → opinion
Babineau argued that officers facing serious allegations could have been suspended with pay while the investigation continued.
uncertain
investigation → argue → pay
He also questioned whether supervisors had ignored warning signs of misconduct.
asserted
supervisors → question → misconduct
“How many commanders over the last 10 years have either turned a blind eye to this kind of misbehaviour or been complicit?” he asked.
asserted
he → turn → misbehaviour
Police would only inform the public about what had happened at a news conference that began at 10:30 p.m. on June 12, about an hour after they notified journalists.
asserted
they → inform → journalists
Stéphane Prud’homme, a lecturer in strategic communications and public relations at Université de Montréal who specializes in reputation management, said the unusual timing and short notice limited journalists’ ability to prepare questions, verify information and seek outside perspectives.
asserted
timing → specialize → perspectives
Prud’homme said the documents suggest the force intended to be transparent but do not explain why the news conference was held so late or whether its timing had been planned.
asserted
timing → say → ?
He said genuine transparency also requires giving journalists an actual opportunity to scrutinize information and properly inform the public.
asserted
transparency → say → public
Jennifer Magnus, a former Calgary police officer who now teaches public safety at Wilfrid Laurier University in Ontario and studies organizational culture in policing, said dismantling an entire patrol team quickly and discreetly can be necessary to protect an investigation.
asserted
dismantling → teach → investigation
But Magnus said a late Friday news conference with little notice can create the perception that police are trying to limit public scrutiny, particularly in communities where trust in law enforcement is already strained.
asserted
trust → say → enforcement
The Aporia
