N.S. premier doubles down on complaint to professor over AI data centre comments
Premier Tim Houston says he's glad his communication adviser sent the critical email
Nova Scotia Premier Tim Houston is doubling down on a complaint his office sent to a university professor in Toronto who commented on a proposed artificial intelligence data centre.
asserted
who → double → centre
A staffer from Houston's office sent the complaint last week, emailing a copy of the message to a CBC News reporter and the chair of the professor's department.
asserted
staffer → send → department
Speaking to reporters Wednesday, Premier Tim Houston said he's glad his communications adviser sent the critical email.
asserted
adviser → speak → email
"I'm happy he sent that message to provide some additional information to somebody who was clearly lacking in information but yet speaking as an expert," Houston said.
asserted
Houston → send → expert
The feedback came after Sibo Chen, an associate professor of communication at Toronto Metropolitan University, gave a media interview to CBC saying that public concerns about the data centre project over water usage and electricity rate hikes were valid.
asserted
concerns → come → usage
William Burns, a communications adviser with the premier's office, said Chen's "slanted comments" were irresponsible and not backed by research on the local community.
asserted
comments → say → community
Sibo Chen, an associate professor in the Toronto Metropolitan University's school of professional communication, is shown in this undated handout photo.
asserted
Chen → show → photo
"Nova Scotians deserve facts, not speculation presented in a way that creates unnecessary anxiety," said Burns' email, which Chen shared with The Canadian Press.
asserted
Chen → deserve → Press
Members of the public and opposition parties in the province have expressed concerns about Everwind Fuels' proposed multi-billion dollar data centre, which would be leased to U.S. AI company Anthropic for 20 years.
asserted
which → express → years
A petition to stop the development of AI data centres in Nova Scotia on Change.org had over 24,000 signatures as of Wednesday afternoon.
asserted
petition → stop → afternoon
'I'm becoming the subject of my own study,' Chen says
Chen suggested that copying the department chair implies the government was trying to intimidate him.
uncertain
government → become → him
"I actually study how scholars get harassed when they go to do knowledge mobilization ...
asserted
they → study → mobilization
I'm becoming the subject of my own study," he said.
asserted
he → become → study
Chen says he has studied environmental controversies in Canada for 10 years and this is the first time he has received a complaint from a premier's office.
asserted
he → say → office
Comments 'should send a chill down peoples' spines, Chender says
"I'm very critical about the oilsands, but I never received a complaint from the premier's office in Alberta," he said in a video interview Wednesday.
asserted
he → send → interview
His comments, he said, were about the general implications of AI data centre development and backed by peer-reviewed research.
asserted
he → say → research
The premier said he doesn't know how often his team reaches out to academics to criticize the comments they make to the media.
asserted
they → say → media
"I'm not sure how often we are communicating with people who are presenting in the media, but I hope it's a lot," Houston said.
asserted
Houston → communicate → media
"If somebody is presenting themselves as an expert and speaking definitively on something that they're wrong on, I think it's incumbent on all of us … [to] say there's some information you're missing," he added.
asserted
he → present → us
Nova Scotia NDP Leader Claudia Chender called Houston's comments disturbing.
"The comments that we heard just now from the premier, that he hopes that his staff are reaching out to people in the media regularly to correct them on their professional point of view, that should actually send a chill down peoples' spines," Chender told reporters Wednesday.
asserted
Chender → call → reporters
Chender said the premier's comments lead her to believe that his staff are "bullying" independent experts who criticize his government's projects.
asserted
who → say → projects
The 18,600-square-metre data centre would draw 95 megawatts of electricity in its first phase and 420 megawatts after an expected expansion in mid-2028.
asserted
centre → draw → mid-2028
Everwind says it will cover the cost of all electricity infrastructure so that project will not increase power rates.
asserted
project → say → rates
Everwind estimates that the facility will use an average of 100,000 litres of water per day in its first phase and 500,000 litres per day after the expansion is completed.
asserted
expansion → estimate → day
EverWind proposes binding agreement with N.S. on data centre rules
Houston says he's willing to sign agreement with data centre on water usage, power rates
asserted
he → propose → usage
In his email to Chen, Burns said the government will not support a project that increases power rates to customers.
asserted
that → say → customers
He also highlighted another CBC interview, where Lois Landry, the warden of Richmond County explained there are provisions in place to protect residents and limit the amount of water the data centre would draw from nearby Lake Landrie.
asserted
centre → highlight → Landrie
Burns also suggested that as a professor from a Toronto university, Chen could not understand the impact of data centre in Nova Scotia.
uncertain
Chen → suggest → Scotia
Chen said the response from Burns suggests the government is sending the message that citizens don't need to be concerned about the project.
uncertain
citizens → say → project
However, he said the province hasn't provided enough information to the public about the proposed data centre and he understands why Nova Scotians are worried.
asserted
Scotians → say → centre
Chen said local university professors may not feel comfortable expressing their concerns about the data centre after seeing the pushback he received from the Nova Scotia government.
uncertain
he → say → government
"I think that's precisely why people don't want to comment on this," he said.
asserted
he → think → this
The Aporia
