A New York Times editor acknowledged during an interview on Thursday that the paper applied political labels to analysts and professors inconsistently after a law professor challenged the newspaper's decision to identify him as a conservative.
asserted
professor → acknowledge → conservative
Patrick Healy, the assistant managing editor for Standards and Trust at the Times, said during the "Sound Off" podcast that law professor Josh Blackman reached out after he was labeled a "conservative" in Times reporting twice within 24 hours.
"
asserted
he → manage → hours
Josh, you reached out after the Times twice described you as a, quote, conservative, end quote, law professor.
asserted
Times → reach → professor
And you said the conservative label was accurate, but that The Times applies labels like conservative and liberal inconsistently to law professors and analysts, and that a scholar’s view should speak for itself," Healy said.
asserted
Healy → say → itself
Blackman described the issue as a longstanding grievance with all major media outlets and said he was quoted twice as a "conservative law professor" in New York Times articles in February.
asserted
he → describe → February
"I just thought that was strange.
asserted
that → think → ?
So I went through the Westlaw archives and just sort of searched for 'liberal' law professors and 'conservative' law professors in the New York Times database, and it was far more likely that you’re identifying a conservative than a liberal.
asserted
you → go → liberal
And those numbers are stacked because liberals are quoted even more often.
asserted
liberals → stack → ?
So the numbers even have a greater disparity," he said during the conversation with Healy.
asserted
he → have → Healy
"And this sort of reinforces, I think, a perception that both the academy and, frankly, the media views a liberal position as a neutral position.
asserted
academy → reinforce → position
And that’s why you have to have this sort of nomenclature, this sort of adjective to describe it," Blackman said.
asserted
Blackman → ’ → it
He said he wrote a letter to the editor in February and the Times didn't publish it, but added that he appreciated Healy reaching out to him about it.
asserted
Healy → say → it
Healy went on to acknowledge the validity of Blackman's critique: "I think there’s real truth to your critique and it’s something we need to do a better job on."
"It can come off like The Times treats liberals as normal and conservatives as unique and worthy of labeling," Healy said.
asserted
Healy → go → labeling
"In the legal academy, there are a lot of liberals, but that doesn’t justify it.
asserted
that → be → it
I think we need to be more discerning about it."
asserted
we → think → it
Fox News Digital reached out to the New York Times for comment.
asserted
Digital → reach → comment
Blackman argued that the label should reflect a professor's involvement in an issue rather than their political affiliation.
asserted
label → argue → issue
He said, "And some of your reporters have said, well, 'Professor Blackman has filed briefs in support of the Trump administration', or 'has filed a brief in opposition to the Obama administration on health care,' or, you know, 'has filed a brief in support of the Texas attorney general' — whatever it happens to be.
asserted
it → say → general
That's actually a data point that's useful because it shows a person has sort of a dog in the fight."
asserted
person → show → fight
He said broad labels, such as conservative and liberal, don't tell the reader much.
asserted
labels → say → much
"So it presumes that, well, because he’s conservative, you know, you should discount his views supporting Trump, or conversely, because the person’s liberal, you should perhaps discount their views supporting President Obama or President Biden, whoever it happens to be.
asserted
it → presume → Obama
I would — if you’re trying to build up trust and standards, I would focus on the potential reason for a conflict or bias, and not just how the person identifies politically," Blackman said.
asserted
Blackman → try → conflict
Curtis Houck, a managing editor at NewsBusters, told Fox News Digital in a statement, "It seems like Healy is aiming to go to Halloween parties this weekend as Captain Obvious.
asserted
Healy → manage → Obvious
It's one thing to recognize you have a problem, but as most people are aware, that's only step one, and it can often be used to punt or not actually follow through on changes."
asserted
it → recognize → changes
Houck added, "Healy, if pressed on camera, would probably try to back off or memory hole this conversation instead of making any concrete commitment to The Times doing any better.
asserted
Times → add → commitment
He's probably more upset that someone reached out to catch the paper red-handed instead of the fact that he — through his own journalism career — and his colleagues have spent more than a lifetime burying and/or smearing conservatives."
asserted
he → reach → conservatives
The Wall Street Journal's assistant editor to the editorial page, James Freeman, praised the NYT in a piece on Monday, and credited them for acknowledging a source's criticism.
asserted
editor → praise → criticism
The Aporia
