Smaller airlines ask Transport Canada for pilots' shifts to last up to 14 hours
Union warns longer duty hours will worsen pilot fatigue and jeopardize flight safety
At least 18 carriers are asking the federal government to extend their pilots' maximum flight duty period by an hour a day, saying the current rules prevent them from managing the frequent delays that disrupt air travel in the North.
asserted
that → ask → North
Their request faces staunch opposition from the country's main pilot union, which says it could lead to further exemptions and push pilot fatigue to dangerous levels.
uncertain
it → face → levels
The maximum daily flight duty period — the time from arrival at work until the last engine shutdown — would go from 13 to 14 hours, while the weekly limit would climb from 60 to 70 hours, according to exemption requests filed earlier this year with Transport Canada.
uncertain
limit → go → Canada
Overall, pilots could work up to 210 hours over a 28-day period, instead of the 192 hours currently allowed.
uncertain
pilots → work → hours
They say the regulations governing air travel since 2020 aren't suited for the unpredictable weather and underfunded airport facilities in the North.
asserted
regulations → say → North
They are seeking the changes to be part of draft regulations underway by Transport Canada to provide greater flexibility to air carriers.
asserted
changes → seek → carriers
"It was a one-size-fits-all for everyone, and that can't be the way it works," said Bernard Gervais, executive director of the Northern Air Transportation Association.
asserted
Gervais → fit → Association
"What we're asking is for the rules to be applied according to the size of the operator and the operations they carry out."
Sleep experts say a high level of fatigue is comparable to a state of impairment from alcohol, which is especially concerning when it comes to piloting a plane.
Symptoms include short-term memory lapses, slower reaction times and reduced ability to prioritize tasks or assess risk.
uncertain
Symptoms → ask → risk
The maximum number of work hours that can still be considered safe is at the heart of the debate between carriers and pilots.
asserted
that → consider → carriers
He says longer pilot hours come with serious risks.
asserted
hours → say → risks
"You need to hear us when we say what's being contemplated is potentially very unsafe," said Tim Perry, president of ALPA Canada, a union that represents more than 10,000 pilots in the country.
asserted
that → need → country
"This seems to us in our professional assessment to be about profits."
asserted
This → seem → profits
The Canadian regulations are complicated and vary according to several criteria, including departure and arrival times, the number of segments being flown and the number of days off that are spent at home.
uncertain
that → complicate → home
A fatigue risk-management system already exists to allow carriers some flexibility, but the process is complex and costly, especially for smaller air carriers.
asserted
process → exist → carriers
ALPA Canada represents pilots at some of the carriers making the exemption requests, but other regional operations are non-unionized.
asserted
operations → represent → requests
"If one carrier gets an exemption, it will be seen as a competitive advantage," Perry said.
asserted
Perry → get → advantage
"It would pave the way for further exemptions to be issued, and it would be difficult to know where to draw the line."
asserted
it → pave → line
The National Airlines Council of Canada, which represents several major carriers (Air Canada, WestJet, Air Transat and Jazz), declined to comment on the proposed changes.
asserted
which → represent → changes
When Canada adopted stricter measures in 2020 to regulate pilots' schedules and bring the country’s rules in line with international standards, many carriers criticized them from the onset.
asserted
carriers → adopt → onset
They argued the rules forced them to hire more pilots and hindered their ability to adapt to unpredictable circumstances such as fog, flat tires or runway closures.
asserted
rules → argue → fog
"In the case of remote communities, if those interruptions turn into flight cancellations rather than delays, there is a real impact," said Joe Sparling, president of Yukon-based Air North.
asserted
Sparling → turn → North
"If you have a medical travel passenger that's going south for an appointment and the plane doesn't get in and misses by a day, then their appointment has to be rescheduled.
asserted
appointment → have → day
A mechanic walks up to a Nolinor Aviation aircraft in Mirabel, Que., last year.
asserted
mechanic → walk → Mirabel
The airline says the realities of flying in the North require different regulations.
asserted
realities → say → regulations
Nolinor, which specializes in charter flights, says it needs to station pilots in Val d'Or, Que., just in case delays up north prevent the regular crew from flying back south.
asserted
delays → specialize → crew
"The regulations weren't designed to reflect the realities of the Arctic," said Nolinor's vice-president of operations, Yves Bergeron.
asserted
vice → design → operations
According to several people involved in the matter, Transport Canada's draft regulations have been stalled — and what comes next depends on federal Transport Minister Steven MacKinnon.
uncertain
comes → accord → MacKinnon
The minister will decide," said Gervais from the industry association of northern carriers.
asserted
Gervais → decide → carriers
The pilots' union wants the minister to block the requested changes to maximum flight duty hours.
asserted
minister → want → hours
MacKinnon's office said officials at Transport Canada are still working on the file.
asserted
officials → say → file
"The safety of civil aviation operations remains the department's top priority, and it is committed to maintaining rigorous and effective oversight of the entire system," said spokesperson Philippe-Alexandre Langlois.
asserted
Langlois → remain → system
: experts
Matthew van Wollen, a Canadian fatigue specialist who works at Pulsar Informatics in the United States, says there are ways to safely lengthen Canadian pilots' shifts with "simpler and more unique operating profiles."
He has worked with Transport Canada and several Canadian carriers, but says his comments are based on scientific evidence.
asserted
comments → work → evidence
He laid out three factors that influence a state of fatigue: whether the work period extends into the middle of the night, overall shift length and any accumulated sleep deficit.
asserted
period → lay → night
Van Wollen said many pilots might be happy to work longer hours over a number of days, in order to then benefit from more days off.
uncertain
pilots → say → days
He said the priority for carriers should be managing the risk of fatigue on a daily basis.
asserted
priority → say → basis
"Just because you're following the rules doesn't mean you're safe.
asserted
you → follow → rules
It doesn't mean you have no fatigue," he said.
asserted
he → mean → fatigue
Another expert in the field of sleep, Clinton Marquardt, said it would be helpful to set parameters for each carrier in collaboration with their pilots.
asserted
it → say → pilots
"That's the only way it's going to be solved in a satisfactory fashion," said Marquardt, a former official at the Transportation Safety Board.
asserted
Marquardt → go → Board
While he said "operational needs and workforce desires" can't be ignored, they are not "the foundation of the system."
asserted
they → say → system
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
