Standing next to United States President Donald Trump, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi delivered praise after praise.
asserted
Modi → stand → praise
“Every time [we meet], he has been the same: warm, friendly, accessible, energetic, and full of wit,” he said of Trump, as they addressed a joint rally in a Houston, Texas, stadium packed with more than 50,000 Indian Americans.
asserted
they → meet → Americans
That was in 2019, ahead of the 2020 US presidential vote, when Trump was facing a major electoral test – seeking re-election to a second term.
asserted
Trump → face → term
Modi was, in effect, galvanising support for him among the Indian-American community, the wealthiest diaspora in the US.
asserted
Modi → galvanise → US
Modi even borrowed a line from his own successful election campaigns, saying: “Abki baar, Trump sarkaar!”, Hindi for “This time, a Trump government.”
But Trump lost.
asserted
Trump → borrow → government
Seven years later, as Trump prepares for difficult midterm elections that could see him lose significant numbers in the US Congress, potentially crippling his legislative agenda, New Delhi’s equation with Washington could not be more different.
uncertain
equation → prepare → Washington
Far from endorsing Trump, Indian officials have in recent weeks been more direct than ever in their criticism of his administration, amid a series of setbacks to bilateral ties.
asserted
officials → endorse → ties
And many analysts believe the Modi government may now actually prefer a Trump chastened by midterm losses.
uncertain
government → believe → losses
Striking a nerve
asserted
Striking → strike → nerve
India has long enjoyed bipartisan support in Washington.
asserted
India → enjoy → Washington
Yet traditionally, New Delhi’s strategic community has often felt more comfortable with Republican presidents in power.
asserted
community → feel → power
It was under Ronald Reagan, as the Cold War wound down, that India and the US reset ties after decades of mistrust amid New Delhi’s strong relationship with Moscow.
asserted
India → wind → Moscow
Then, between 2006 and 2008, under George W Bush, India and the US struck a landmark civil nuclear deal.
asserted
India → strike → deal
India was allowed access to global nuclear technology and fuel despite not being a signatory to the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).
asserted
India → allow → Treaty
Under Bush, India and the US also signed major military pacts, including allowing US ships and planes refuelling and logistical access to Indian bases.
asserted
ships → sign → bases
By contrast, New Delhi has often seen US Democratic administrations as more critical of India’s human rights record.
asserted
Delhi → see → record
The tradition of friendly ties with US Republican presidents appeared set to continue under Trump, amid visible bonhomie between the US leader and Modi.
asserted
tradition → appear → leader
The Indian prime minister even called Trump “India’s best friend in the White House”.
asserted
minister → call → House
So different that New Delhi has chosen to break with a long-held practice.
asserted
Delhi → choose → practice
India usually addresses divisive issues with friendly nations quietly, behind the scenes.
asserted
India → address → scenes
But months of tensions on a string of issues have pushed India to adopt a more openly critical tone towards the White House.
asserted
months → push → House
Last month, speaking at an event in New York, India’s foreign minister, Minister of External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, shared a pointed, blunt assessment of the Trump administration: It has been an insensitive partner to India’s concerns over “terrorism”; has warmed to its archrival Pakistan; and has pursued “self-centred” trade policies that have disproportionately hurt the Global South.
asserted
that → speak → South
“Countries should not be so self-centred that you’re in your own world and take your decision, and say, ‘Well, it was not my intention to make your life difficult’,” he said.
asserted
he → ’re → decision
One of the biggest sticking points between both capitals is an elusive trade deal that could bring relief to India, among the worst-hit countries under Trump’s tariff regime.
uncertain
that → bring → regime
Earlier this month, India’s finance minister, Minister of Corporate Affairs Nirmala Sitharaman, said that the negotiations had reached a “plateau beyond which giving or taking might be very difficult”.
uncertain
giving → say → which
Trump’s Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement has also often targeted Indians and Indian Americans, using racist tropes, accusing them of “stealing” jobs in the United States via programmes like the H-1B visa schemes.
asserted
movement → make → schemes
And early in his second term, Trump sent many undocumented Indian immigrants back home shackled in chains – a visual that stirred outrage in India.
asserted
that → send → India
Milan Vaishnav, director of the South Asia programme at the Washington, DC-based Carnegie Endowment for International Peace think tank, said the Indian government “can tolerate genuine policy differences with a US administration”.
asserted
government → base → administration
However, “the attacks on India and Indian Americans coming from this administration, and many of their allies in the media and on social media, have struck a nerve,” he said.
asserted
he → come → nerve
Vaishnav, like other analysts, told Al Jazeera that despite recent criticism coming from New Delhi, “the Modi government has shown admirable restraint in its response”.
asserted
government → tell → response
‘Brought back distrust’
Since Trump returned to office in 2025, the US-India relationship has been beset by a seemingly never-ending series of crises.
asserted
relationship → bring → crises
Some of the irritants are: punitive US tariffs and stalled trade negotiations; Washington’s pressure on India to stop buying Russian oil; Trump’s repeated claims that he mediated an India-Pakistan ceasefire in 2025, which New Delhi rejects; closer US ties with Pakistan despite India’s concerns over “terrorism”; higher H-1B specialised worker visa fees in the US, and Trump’s wider immigration crackdown affecting Indian workers.
uncertain
Delhi → stall → workers
At one point, India was among the countries facing the worst Trump-imposed tariff rates.
asserted
India → face → rates
After the US Supreme Court in February struck down Trump’s sweeping tariffs on numerous nations, his administration swiftly turned to other tools, including a new 10 percent global tariff.
asserted
administration → strike → tariff
Last month, Trump signed a law under which the US can impose up to 100 percent tariffs on countries like India that buy Russian oil.
asserted
that → sign → oil
However, he paused it to avoid driving up energy prices in the US ahead of November’s midterm elections, while keeping negotiations with Russia over Moscow’s war in Ukraine on track.
asserted
he → pause → track
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who visited India’s financial hub Mumbai this week, but skipped the capital, said in an interview with The Indian Express that “none of these tariffs are meant to punish or harm India”.
asserted
none → visit → India
Rubio argued that Washington’s “broader foreign policy, unfortunately, involves a war going on between Russia and Ukraine” — and added that “one of the reasons why [Trump paused the tariff] is because he understands that it would have a very detrimental impact on a very important relationship with India”.
But Rubio did not rule out that similar measures would return in a matter of time.
asserted
measures → argue → time
“I think the president is trying very hard to balance that… but it will be a challenge”, he remarked.
asserted
he → think → that
Praveen Donthi, a senior analyst at the Brussels-based International Crisis Group, told Al Jazeera: “Under Trump 2.0, the bipartisan consensus on India seems to have ended in Washington.
“The sentiment [in Washington] seems too strong to be attributed solely to President Trump; it points to the broader American establishment,” Donthi said.
asserted
Donthi → base → establishment
…and 16 more, not listed.
The Aporia
