A senior criminal lawyer has revealed how Aussies using Waze to warn other drivers about police or speed cameras could risk breaking the law.
uncertain
Aussies → reveal → law
The navigation app allows motorists to receive warnings about police and speed cameras, with research finding that drivers were more likely to slow down after an enforcement alert appeared.
asserted
alert → allow → police
Shantel Norus, principal solicitor at Norus Criminal Defence Lawyers, said most Australian jurisdictions did not specifically prohibit motorists from reporting police locations.
asserted
jurisdictions → say → locations
However, she said interacting with a mobile phone while driving could itself attract a fine.
uncertain
interacting → say → fine
'The primary legal risk arises from how motorists use the application while driving, rather than the act of sharing police locations itself,' Ms Norus told Daily Mail.
asserted
Norus → arise → Mail
Across Australia, illegal mobile phone use while driving can attract fines of hundreds of dollars and multiple demerit points, although penalties vary between jurisdictions.
asserted
penalties → drive → jurisdictions
Ms Norus said a driver was unlikely to be fined simply for reporting the location of police or a speed camera, although it remained theoretically possible.
asserted
it → say → police
'For example, if a motorist observes a mobile speed camera or an unmarked highway patrol vehicle and reports its location through Waze, simply sharing that information with other drivers does not, in itself, constitute an offence under NSW law,' she said.
asserted
she → observe → law
Credit @shantelnoruslawyer/Instagram
Norus has revealed the exceptional circumstances in which motorists could potentially be fined for tipping off other drivers about police locations and speed cameras on Waze
'
uncertain
motorists → reveal → Waze
While obstruction offences could theoretically apply in exceptional circumstances, merely reporting a police location would be unlikely to satisfy the elements of the offence.
uncertain
reporting → apply → offence
'Case law requires more than merely sharing information and there must be conduct amounting to interference with police performing their duties.
asserted
police → require → duties
For example, if a motorist reports a speed camera on Waze and other drivers subsequently slow down, this would not ordinarily constitute hindering police as officers can continue carrying out their enforcement duties.'
asserted
officers → report → duties
Australian jurisdictions have offences covering conduct that hinders, resists or obstructs police officers carrying out their lawful duties.
asserted
that → have → duties
Queensland, South Australia, Western Australia, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory have broadly similar provisions, although penalties vary between jurisdictions.
However, Victoria is more explicit, with official legal guidance warning that tipping off drivers about speed cameras may amount to hindering police.
uncertain
tipping → have → police
According to Victoria Legal Aid, conduct that may fall under hindering police includes warning others that police are approaching and tipping off drivers about speed cameras.
uncertain
police → accord → cameras
In Victoria, the offence carries a maximum fine of $5,227.50 or six months’ imprisonment, although any penalty would depend on the circumstances of the case.
asserted
penalty → carry → case
Last week, Queensland Police Senior Sergeant Shane Panoho issued a blunt warning to motorists using Waze alerts to evade speed enforcement
Maximum penalties include fines of almost $7,000 or six months' imprisonment in Queensland, 18 months' imprisonment and fines of about $18,000 in WA, and a fine of up to $2,500, six months' imprisonment, or both, in South Australia.
asserted
penalties → issue → Australia
In Tasmania, offenders face a maximum penalty of about $20,000 or three years' imprisonment.
asserted
offenders → face → 20,000
The maximum penalty in the ACT is about $32,000, two years' imprisonment, or both, while the Northern Territory carries a maximum penalty of almost $40,000, two years' imprisonment, or both.
asserted
Territory → carry → 40,000
Last week, Queensland Police Senior Sergeant Shane Panoho issued a blunt warning to motorists using Waze alerts to evade speed enforcement.
asserted
Panoho → issue → enforcement
'Stop driving like a bloody muppet and actually do the right thing,' he said.
asserted
he → stop → thing
'If you don't, we will do our best to impede you and fine you and take away your driving privileges.'
asserted
we → do → privileges
The Aporia
