An inquiry committee formed to probe the deadly fire at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (Pims) has found “systemic and institutional failure” and determined that an electrical failure was the most likely cause of the blaze, it emerged on Tuesday.
asserted
it → form → Tuesday
The August 26 fire at a nursery in Pims’ Mother and Child Hospital claimed the lives of 14 newborns.
asserted
fire → claim → newborns
The incident raised concerns over fire safety measures and sparked calls for accountability, with criminal action being ordered against eight officials.
asserted
action → raise → officials
Headed by former interior secretary Shahid Khan, the committee was formed on Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s directives on the day the fire occurred.
asserted
fire → head → day
It has presented its findings and recommendations in a 43-page report available with Dawn.
asserted
It → present → Dawn
The committee concluded that “systemic and institutional failure is established, while individual responsibility varies with the strength of the evidence”.
asserted
responsibility → conclude → evidence
It added that Pims and its “senior management bear the principal institutional responsibility for failing to convert known risks, prior warnings and assigned duties into an effective safety system”.
asserted
Pims → add → system
“Administrative, disciplinary, contractual and criminal responsibility must attach only where the relevant duty, omission and causal consequence are proved,” the report said.
asserted
report → attach → ?
“The electrical spark explains how the fire began; the institutional system explains why it became a catastrophe.
asserted
it → explain → ?
“Fourteen newborns were lost not because one safeguard failed, but because too many safeguards were absent, weak, delayed or never verified to be working,” the report declared.
asserted
report → lose → ?
It explained: “The causal chain is coherent.
asserted
chain → explain → ?
A localised electrical failure most probably started the fire; combustible and oxygen-supported conditions accelerated it; inadequate detection and protection failed to contain it; overcrowding, limited evacuation capacity and the absence of a rehearsed neonatal emergency system constrained rescue; delayed institutional activation weakened response; and longstanding governance, maintenance and regulatory failures allowed these vulnerabilities to coexist.”
The report pointed out a “history of known but incompletely closed risks”, citing prior warnings.
asserted
report → start → warnings
These included earlier correspondence by the Capital Development Authority (CDA), the Federal Ombudsman’s 2015 findings, Pims’ own 2025 acknowledgement of ageing fire safety infrastructure, and especially the July 6, 2026 Nursing Hostel fire, which had already highlighted deficiencies in detection, alarms, electrical inspection, evacuation, firefighting equipment, drills and emergency planning.
asserted
which → include → detection
“Yet those warnings had not been converted into a comprehensive, time-bound and independently verified corrective programme before the Nursery fire,” the report regretted.
asserted
report → convert → fire
“The specific AC 2 defect may not have been foreseeable; the need for stronger fire preparedness plainly was,” it said, referring to the likely fault in the connected electric cable.
uncertain
it → say → cable
“The strongest technical evidence, from the National Forensics Agency, identifies the АС Unit No. 2 electrical supply cable near/over AC Unit No. 1 as the most probable point of ignition,” the report said about the cause of the fire.
asserted
report → identify → fire
It explained that abnormal localised electrical heating — possibly from excessive current, a high-resistance connection or another localised defect — most probably caused insulation failure and ignition of nearby combustible material.
uncertain
heating → explain → material
The evidence does not establish arson, multiple ignition points, an external fault of the Islamabad Electric Supply Company (Iesco), a pre-fire oxygen leak, or an incubator or warmer as the source, the committee determined.
“The fire was therefore most probably electrical in origin, although the precise defect and the person or entity responsible for preventing it require separate determination,” the report read.
asserted
report → establish → determination
It further said that the record did not establish deliberate locking in of the neonates, conspiracy, sabotage, political protection, manipulation or concealment of casualties, wholesale frontline abandonment, or a prolonged delay by Capital Emergency Services (CES) after confirmed notification.
asserted
record → say → notification
The committee said its conclusions were based on a structured 52-task investigation drawing upon forensic evidence, CCTV, call records, engineering and maintenance documents, clinical and casualty records, duty and attendance material, witness statements, contracts, regulatory records, and earlier inquiries.
asserted
conclusions → say → evidence
With Khan as its head, the committee comprised Major General (retired) Dr Khurshid Uttra, Establishment Division Secretary Dr Barrister Nabeel Awan, Islamabad Deputy Commissioner Irfan Nawaz Memon, and Dr Rashid A. Chotani (co-opted member).
asserted
committee → comprise → Uttra
As a recommendation, the panel said the health ministry, upon acceptance of the report, should prepare a “consolidated corrective action plan assigning every recommendation to a responsible institution and designated officer, with deadlines, resources, interim safeguards, verification authority and closure status”.
asserted
ministry → say → deadlines
According to the report, the record “does not presently establish criminal guilt against any named person”.
uncertain
record → accord → person
However, it supported focused investigation into four possible lines: culpable electrical installation or maintenance failure relating to AC 2; culpable obstruction of a mandatory emergency route; culpable failure to act despite specific prior warning; and any proved culpable delay in summoning external assistance.
asserted
it → support → assistance
“Criminal responsibility must rest on the duty owed, knowledge or foreseeability of risk, authority to act, the act or omission, degree of negligence, failed safeguard, causal contribution and applicable offence,” the report said.
asserted
report → rest → negligence
According to the inquiry panel, the maintenance record showed that the nursery ACs had been serviced, but it did not “demonstrate a sufficiently systematic and traceable electrical safety regime covering cables, terminations, insulation, earthing, breaker protection and thermal hotspots”.
uncertain
it → accord → cables
The evidence reveals a wider institutional gap between keeping equipment running and ensuring that it was safe,” the committee pointed out.
asserted
committee → reveal → equipment
Frontline response and institutional failure
Citing CCTV footage, which established “an exceptionally rapid emergency”, the report said the evidence “rejects any generalised allegation that frontline personnel abandoned the newborns”.
asserted
personnel → cite → newborns
Noting that Charge Nurse Nasreen Akhtar, Security Guard Maria Saleem and Staff Nurse Razia Noreen responded within moments, the report said that “several acted promptly and courageously in circumstances that became untenable within minutes”.
asserted
that → note → minutes
The report also highlighted the “vulnerability” of the nursery, with 15 “medically fragile, non-self-evacuating neonates were housed in a 10-bed unit, several dependent on oxygen or respiratory support”.
asserted
several → highlight → oxygen
Only two doctors and two nurses were immediately available, and protected evacuation resources were limited.
asserted
resources → limit → ?
“No adequately documented, approved, trained and rehearsed nursery-specific fire and neonatal evacuation SOP (standard operating procedure) was demonstrated, nor was a functional automatic smoke detection, alarm or sprinkler system shown to be serving the affected area
asserted
system → document → area
,” the report read.
asserted
report → read → ?
It observed that combustible materials and the “oxygen-supported environment further intensified fire and smoke after ignition”.
asserted
materials → observe → ignition
It emphasised that frontline responders whose rescue conduct had been “objectively established should not be blamed merely because the outcome was catastrophic”.
asserted
outcome → emphasise → ?
The committee also called for the response to be distinguished between individual reaction and institutional activation.
asserted
response → call → reaction
It noted that the frontline staff acted within seconds at 6:38am, external notification was at 6:54am, and operational arrival was at 7:01am.
asserted
arrival → note → 7:01am
“Pims had not demonstrated a tested incident command system capable of immediately converting detection into alarm, external notification, evacuation, hazard isolation, access management and coordinated rescue.”
asserted
Pims → demonstrate → alarm
Although the particular adjoining door visible in the CCTV footage was not established as causative of the fatalities, “CES separately reported locked or obstructed routes, establishing a serious institutional egress concern”, the report stated.
asserted
report → establish → concern
It further said that Pims’ security SOPs expressly assigned responsibilities concerning fire safety, exits, firefighting equipment, training, access control, keys and emergency reporting, providing “one of the clearest documentary duty chains in the inquiry”.
asserted
SOPs → say → inquiry
…and 23 more, not listed.
The Aporia
