The Albanese government spent $682,000 on rooms at a five-star hotel in Sydney to host a series of pre-COP meetings in September, with questions over the contract leading to a fiery exchange in the Senate.
asserted
questions → spend → Senate
The grilling of bureaucrats in Senate estimates also revealed that Australia’s financial contribution to hosting October’s pre-COP event in Fiji could reach $34.6 million, higher than the $20 million previously reported.
uncertain
contribution → reveal → million
Liberal senator Sarah Henderson said expenditure by the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water was “simply out of control” and asked why the government was spending almost $700,000 on meeting rooms and accommodation when “you could almost buy a hotel for that amount of money”.
uncertain
you → say → money
Dr Sally Box, head of the international climate negotiations division in the department, confirmed the contract with Sofitel Sydney Darling Harbour was part of the $150 million budgeted for pre-COP.
asserted
contract → confirm → COP
Box said the contract supported at least five separate events over several weeks, but she did not have a breakdown of how many meeting rooms were involved over how many days and whether it also included accommodation, or why the venue needed to be five-star.
asserted
venue → say → accommodation
“These are either mandated events under the UNFCCC that we were hosting in Australia, or they were workshops to support the facilitation of conversations between delegations on negotiations-related issues,” Box said.
asserted
Box → mandate → issues
Henderson’s comment about being able to buy a hotel for nearly $700,000 prompted the intervention of Labor senator Tim Ayres who said this was not true.
asserted
this → buy → Ayres
He pointed out that during the G20 in 2014, the Abbott government booked out 7000 hotel rooms across Brisbane including luxury five-star resorts at a cost of $20 million.
asserted
government → point → million
The squabble occurred when Senate estimates resumed after a short break to pay tribute to independent MP Helen Haines who was seriously injured in an alleged attack last week.
asserted
who → occur → attack
Henderson and Ayres spoke over the top of each other repeatedly, as Henderson accused Ayres of “running interference” while she tried to question a public servant, and Ayres argued this was “the same Coalition that made jokes about water lapping at Pacific leaders’ doors”, a reference to an infamous 2015 hot mic incident involving then-immigration minister Peter Dutton and then-prime minister Tony Abbott.
asserted
water → speak → Dutton
More recent examples included one of the Coalition senators referring to Pacific leaders as “the local blokes” earlier in the estimates hearing, Ayres said, and Nationals senator Matt Canavan’s recent comments about the prime minister and a minister looking “silly” in Hawaiian shirts at a pre-COP events in the Pacific.
asserted
Ayres → include → Pacific
“Your questions about a much smaller amount of money really do underline the lack of seriousness with which the Coalition views this set of issues in the Pacific,” Ayres said.
asserted
Ayres → underline → Pacific
Henderson interjected: “$150 million is not a small amount of money.”
asserted
million → interject → money
Ayres said: “I did not interrupt you.
asserted
I → say → you
I did not interrupt you.”
asserted
I → interrupt → you
“You’re interrupting the whole ...” Henderson said.
asserted
Henderson → interrupt → whole
“Badgering me or badgering the officials does not assist,” Ayres said.
asserted
Ayres → badger → officials
“I’m not badgering,” Henderson said, and called a point of order on relevance, but committee chair, Labor senator Varun Ghosh, ruled that Ayres’ answer was relevant because Henderson’s question had included “rhetorical preamble” to which Ayres could respond.
uncertain
Ayres → badger → which
Ayres concluded by saying that the pre-COP expenditure was “fully funded by the $500 million Coalition-era strategic international partnership that [now Opposition Leader] Angus Taylor ... put together to bribe his way out of the naughty corner when the previous government became so isolated on these questions in the region and around the world”.
Ayres withdrew the attack on Taylor at Henderson’s request.
Earlier in Monday’s Senate estimates hearing, the department’s head of division, international climate & energy, David Higgins, said the pre-COP event in Fiji had included contracted commitments of $34.6 million, but this was an “outer bound”, with the government expected to recoup some costs from attending nations over the next month.
asserted
government → conclude → month
The breakdown included an $8.4 million bill for accommodation and venues, which also included most of the catering, about $20 million for the event management company including the fit-out of venues, audiovisual hardware and simultaneous translation, $2 million to put on host broadcaster services to make sure the proceedings could be publicly screened, and additional costs associated with procurement support, commercial and probity advice.
uncertain
proceedings → include → support
Department secretary Mike Kaiser said he had approved the travel of 51 department officials to manage the operational side and 48 staff for negotiation and engagement.
asserted
he → say → negotiation
The event attracted criticism because the only world leaders in attendance were from the Pacific region, plus Timor-Leste and Mauritius.
asserted
leaders → attract → Leste
Kaiser said the event achieved its goals to put Pacific priorities at the heart of the international climate discussion and help shape the agenda for COP31 in Turkey, and to strengthen relationships with Pacific neighbours.
asserted
event → say → neighbours
Get to the heart of what’s happening with climate change and the environment.
asserted
what → get → change
The Aporia
