A cabinet split has emerged over whether to approve drilling at the Rosebank oilfield, with the chancellor, John Healey, in favour of the controversial North Sea project.
asserted
chancellor → emerge → project
The energy secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh, is ultimately in charge of the decision and the Guardian reported last week that she was leaning towards rejecting it after granting permission for the smaller Jackdaw gasfield.
asserted
she → report → gasfield
It is understood, however, that Healey backs approving the licence, which is on hold over concerns about the project’s environmental impact.
asserted
which → understand → impact
The chancellor hinted at his support last week when he told ITV he expected oil and gas revenues to contribute to a new energy wealth fund, suggesting he was anticipating income from Rosebank.
asserted
he → hint → Rosebank
The prime minister would be expected to make the final call if there is conflict on the decision.
asserted
minister → expect → decision
No 10 declined to comment on Sunday after the Mail on Sunday reported that both Andy Burnham and Healey had agreed to try to push the project through, saying it was a matter for the energy secretary.
asserted
it → decline → secretary
Fahnbulleh is responsible, but the views of Burnham and Healey will hold weight in the choice over whether or not to go ahead.
asserted
views → hold → choice
She told the Guardian that the rationale behind Jackdaw did not apply to Rosebank, saying the UK would rely on gas as it made the transition to net zero and that it would be better to take it from relatively low-carbon sources in the North Sea than importing it.
asserted
it → tell → it
“One is a gasfield that caters for the domestic market, while the other is an oilfield that is mainly for export,” she said.
asserted
she → cater → export
“It is right that we judge each application in its own right, and it is absolutely critical that the decision is consistent with our climate obligations, our carbon budgets and the end destination we need to get to with the energy transition.
asserted
we → judge → transition
If the Rosebank field is rejected, it would be a blow for the North Sea energy industry and a major victory for climate campaigners.
asserted
it → reject → campaigners
A final decision is expected before the end of the year.
asserted
decision → expect → year
Labour MPs said on Wednesday that there would be a major pushback in the party if Rosebank was approved, though most are prepared to accept the arguments that Jackdaw was a necessary part of the transition to net zero.
asserted
Jackdaw → say → net
MPs are understood to have discussed ways of forcing or encouraging a parliamentary vote on Rosebank should it be approved as a way of expressing dissent.
asserted
it → understand → dissent
Officials say Fahnbulleh has not yet made her decision.
asserted
Fahnbulleh → say → decision
Rosebank would produce emissions about seven times greater than Jackdaw, and Fahnbulleh is understood to believe that it would do less for UK energy security, given that most of the oil would be exported.
asserted
most → produce → oil
A spokesperson for the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero said: “We do not comment on speculation.
asserted
We → say → speculation
The North Sea remains a vital national asset, and oil and gas will continue to play an important role in our energy system for decades to come – alongside transitioning to clean power to protect jobs and tackle the climate crisis.
asserted
oil → remain → crisis
“Any decision will take into account all relevant evidence, including environmental assessments and public representations received during the consultation process.”
asserted
decision → take → process
Fahnbulleh has promised that future revenues from the North Sea will be spent on green energy projects through an energy wealth fund.
asserted
revenues → promise → fund
She said last week that the fund would be given £2bn in the budget.
asserted
fund → say → budget
“When we have tax revenues that are coming from the oil and gas industry, it is right that we invest that in the transition we need to make in energy,” she said, adding that the money would be spent on renewables, nuclear and other clean energy schemes.
asserted
money → have → renewables
She could not, however, say exactly which tax revenues would be given to the fund, or how much that might generate.
uncertain
that → say → much
“The chancellor will make those details clear in the budget,” she said.
asserted
she → make → budget
The Aporia
