There’s the mega deduction, the super deduction, the bet-on-Canada proposal, and a slew of lobbying for delaying taxes on capital gains — an eclectic array of measures that proponents say would give investment a boost.
asserted
proponents → ’ → boost
They have one key thing in common.
asserted
They → have → thing
The central mechanism is a tax deferral — allowing money-makers to act now but pay tax later.
asserted
makers → allow → tax
Do tax deferrals actually work?
asserted
deferrals → work → ?
They cost our society billions of dollars in forgone tax revenue.
asserted
They → cost → revenue
And so they’d better work — really well.
asserted
they → work → ?
The Canadian Tax Observatory has set up a system to analyze when taxpayers are allowed to hit snooze on the tax bill, under what conditions, and what happens to the economy as a result.
asserted
what → set → result
The goal is to figure out whether the stack of deferrals on display is pushing our economy in a more productive direction that serves the Canadian public — or not.
asserted
that → figure → public
Because some deferrals make passive investment more lucrative, and that’s the last thing we need right now.
asserted
we → make → ?
Inside Ottawa’s $36-billion mega deduction
The newest example of a deferral is the Productivity Mega Deduction, which is indeed quite “mega” because it fundamentally changes the way many sectors and companies pay tax on capital investments, like new machinery and equipment.
asserted
sectors → change → machinery
Companies will be able to write off their purchases immediately and count them against their tax bill, instead of writing them off gradually over the life of the investment.
asserted
Companies → write → investment
It’s meant to boost the buying of machinery, equipment and other investments right now — part of the federal government’s plan to improve productivity and diversify the Canadian economy.
asserted
It → mean → economy
It sounds like a good idea in principle because the writeoff is contingent on capital investment, something that can push the economy in a direction that could lead to more jobs, more growth and perhaps even less dependence on the United States.
But it’s going to cost $36 billion over five years in terms of forgone tax revenue.
uncertain
it → sound → revenue
In her new fiscal projection, Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan points out that the mega deduction is the single biggest reason Prime Minister Mark Carney has already spent any windfall coming from higher oil prices, and then some.
asserted
Carney → point → prices
Perhaps, if it does indeed drive productivity-enhancing growth that benefits many Canadians.
asserted
that → drive → Canadians
But we’ll need a lot more data and modelling from Finance Canada to even begin to answer that question.
asserted
we → need → question
It may well turn out that big, established companies involved in natural resource extraction and manufacturing are able to use the new writeoff system the most, while companies without regular profits — such as technology-oriented startups — may not benefit as much.
uncertain
companies → turn → much
What Canadian startups want from tax policy
asserted
want → want → policy
The other new idea in the lucrative world of deferrals comes from a large group of mainly high-growth startup companies.
asserted
idea → come → companies
Earlier this month, they lobbied for two separate tax measures in the name of sparking more investment and better access to venture capital.
asserted
they → lobby → capital
They want lower capital gains tax for startups, allowing up to $15 million to be exempt from tax each time they engage in a sale.
asserted
they → want → sale
And they want to broaden the existing capital gains rollover so more entrepreneurs and investors, including corporations or funds, can defer capital gains tax when they sell a stake in a startup and reinvest in another Canada-based company.
asserted
they → want → company
If we were to run those proposals through our “hitting snooze” framework, we would be left with some big questions.
asserted
we → run → questions
The questions these proposals can’t answer
Would the $15-million cap be available every time a startup sold off a piece of equity, enabling founders or others to claim it repeatedly, and maintain an effective low tax rate indefinitely?
uncertain
startup → answer → rate
Would the deferral of capital gains tax be contingent on reinvesting in a productive company that is growing and hiring and expanding Canada’s GDP?
asserted
that → reinveste → GDP
Or would the deferral encourage any type of investment in Canada?
asserted
deferral → encourage → Canada
Would the big investment funds and corporations profit more for doing what they would have done anyway?
asserted
they → profit → what
Not all investment is created equal, and simply assuming there’s a trickle-down effect through the economy stemming from tax breaks has proven to be folly in the past.
asserted
assuming → create → past
Corporate tax revenue is the second-largest source of funds for the federal government, accounting for 19 per cent of the budget — money that funds social programs, defence and services our debt.
asserted
that → account → programs
Before the mega deduction came on the scene, the Parliamentary Budget Office projected that amount would rise by $4.6 billion a year on average, reflecting bigger corporate profits and high oil prices.
asserted
amount → come → profits
That completely disappears, and then some, with the mega deduction alone.
asserted
That → disappear → deduction
To date, very few have projected a business investment bonanza as a result of these measures.
asserted
few → project → measures
The mega deduction is expected to boost economic growth by about 0.3 per cent a year for the first few years, which certainly isn’t nothing.
asserted
which → expect → years
But we don’t know what it means for business investment and productivity per se, and that’s the perpetual weak spot in Canada’s economy.
asserted
that → know → economy
Former prime minister Justin Trudeau withstood years of ridicule for arguing that the budget balances itself — presumably trying to say that deficits would be modest and social programs sustained if the government used its balance sheet to spur economic growth.
asserted
government → withstand → growth
Then, as now, it would be better to have some guarantees.
asserted
it → have → guarantees
The Aporia
