Landmark online safety measures have failed to limit the proportion of children suffering harm from social media, the UK’s online regulator has admitted, in an assessment branded “staggering” by campaigners.
asserted
regulator → fail → campaigners
The proportion of children being fed unsafe content that often left them frightened, confused and upset, was almost unchanged, according to an Ofcom review of the first nine months of supposedly strict requirements on social media platforms such as TikTok and Instagram.
uncertain
that → feed → TikTok
Under the Online Safety Act, the tech giants had to protect children from harmful content including pornography, serious violence, suicide material, racism, misogyny and bullying, with a series of specific duties introduced in summer 2025.
asserted
giants → have → summer
But Ofcom found that “at a total level there was no significant change in the proportion of children encountering harmful content over the first nine months after the children’s safety duties came into force in July 2025”.
asserted
duties → find → July
It called the finding “concerning” and said there was no evidence indicating a change in the severity of harm since the flagship regulations, under the Online Safety Act, took effect.
asserted
regulations → call → effect
Examples of harms included children being shown the murder of Charlie Kirk, graphic pornography and weapon-related content making them feel unsafe in their schools and neighbourhoods.
asserted
them → include → schools
Personalised recommendation feeds powered by “for you” algorithms were repeatedly found by Ofcom to be at the root of the continuing tide of harmful material.
asserted
feeds → power → material
The findings come a week after a coroner concluded that access to the suicide-related material on TikTok may have played a significant part in the decision of Adriana Retyte, a 14-year-old pupil at Langley school in Norfolk, to take her own life in May.
uncertain
access → come → May
They come a day after Clavicular, 20, a popular social media influencer who promotes surgery and drugs as part of extreme male beauty regimes and has appeared with Andrew Tate, pleaded not guilty to rape in a US court, raising fresh concerns about the influence of “manosphere” content creators.
asserted
who → come → creators
Ofcom’s research included tracking the exposure of UK children aged eight to 17 to harmful content on user-to-user services, its impact and their use of safety tools and an analysis of children’s wellbeing after exposure to harmful content.
asserted
research → include → content
The assessment has been shared with Lisa Nandy, the secretary of state for digital, culture, media and sport.
asserted
assessment → share → digital
NSPCC, a child protection charity, said the findings showed that children were being exposed to harmful content at an “alarming rate”, which it said was echoed in the flow of calls for help to Childline, its online and telephone support service.
asserted
it → say → Childline
Rani Govender, the head of child safety online, said “progress is not happening nearly fast enough”.
asserted
progress → say → safety
“Tech companies have had months to act, yet too many platforms are still built to keep children hooked with their algorithms continuing to push harmful content to their young users,” she said.
asserted
she → have → users
“We urgently need stronger action from tech companies to rein in features that drive harm to children and stop putting business interests over their safety obligations.”
asserted
that → need → obligations
Dame Melanie Dawes, the watchdog’s chief executive, this week told MPs: “We do not see a safety culture from these large social media companies.”
asserted
We → tell → companies
The regulator is already facing a wave of legal actions from tech companies challenging its powers including the Instagram operator Meta, as well as TikTok and X, owned by Elon Musk’s SpaceX group.
asserted
regulator → face → group
It has warned it risks being “absolutely clobbered legally by deep-pocketed individuals and firms”.
asserted
it → warn → individuals
Children most commonly reported encountering pornographic content via personalised feeds, and girls, in particular, reported feeling confused or upset after seeing such content, Ofcom found.
asserted
Ofcom → report → content
Suicide and eating disorder content was also driven mostly through personal feeds, with girls most likely to encounter both types of harmful material.
asserted
girls → drive → material
The Ofcom review also found that “young men and boys consuming motivational and self-improvement content can rapidly become exposed to more extreme content which includes the promotion of misogyny and racism”.
asserted
which → find → misogyny
Misspelled hashtags and coded language are often used to bypass content moderation systems that would otherwise block harmful misogynistic content.
asserted
that → misspell → content
Ian Russell, the father of Molly Russell, who took her life aged 14 in 2017 after viewing suicide material on social media, told the Guardian the lack of progress was “staggering but sadly not surprising”.
asserted
lack → take → progress
He blamed “timidity and lack of action” from the regulator and said: “It is time that Ofcom stood up for children and investigated the major flaws in TikTok and Instagram’s design features, not just small technicalities that have been their focus so far.”
asserted
that → blame → features
An Ofcom spokesperson said: “This is an industry that’s been unregulated and unaccountable for more than 20 years.
asserted
that → say → years
And so while significant progress is being made – including the introduction of widespread age checks, stronger protections against grooming, and tougher safeguards against child sexual exploitation and abuse – we’re under no illusion that there is much for the industry still to do.
asserted
industry → make → illusion
We’ve shown that tech firms that don’t comply with their duties can expect enforcement action.
asserted
that → show → action
It said the data did not cover the period from this spring when it said it stepped up pressure on Facebook, YouTube, Snap, Roblox and TikTok over child safety issues.
asserted
it → say → issues
It also said it recorded some reductions in harmful content on platforms including the games Minecraft and Call of Duty and YouTube, Pinterest and Facebook.
asserted
it → say → Duty
In July it launched an investigation into TikTok over child safety concerns, including how it checks users are adults or children.
asserted
users → launch → concerns
The continuing risks to children come before a planned Australia-style social media ban in the UK for under-16s which is due, from next spring, to cover platforms such as Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, Snapchat, Facebook and X, but not messaging services such as WhatsApp and Signal.
asserted
which → continue → WhatsApp
However campaigners have warned that must not overshadow the need to enforce protections under the Online Safety Act.
asserted
that → warn → Act
“Children will continue to face risks on services covered by the act but not the proposed ban, including gaming and messaging platforms,” said Mitali Sud, a senior policy manager at Internet Matters, a child online safety campaign.
asserted
Sud → continue → Matters
“Sixteen- and 17-year-olds will still use social media.
asserted
olds → use → media
A social media ban cannot replace the need to make online services safer for children.”
asserted
services → replace → children
A government spokesperson said platforms needed to do more to protect children from harmful content.
asserted
platforms → say → content
“That’s why we are taking bold action to strengthen protections for children from risks of harm online – banning social media from offering their services to under-16s and protecting kids from harmful functionalities like livestreaming and stranger communications on a wide range of services, including gaming services,” they said.
asserted
they → ’ → services
“When it comes to children’s safety, we are not and never will be bystanders.
asserted
we → come → safety
Platforms have both a moral and legal duty to protect children and we expect them to work with us to set a new normal for future generations.”
asserted
them → have → generations
TikTok, Meta, X and Google were contacted for comment.
asserted
TikTok → contact → comment
The Aporia
