When the UK government launched its “Protect and Survive” public information campaign in 1980 on how to stay alive after a nuclear attack, it was met with a combination of scepticism, disbelief and derision.
asserted
it → launch → scepticism
The advice included how to build a “fallout room” at home, how to whitewash windows to protect from a blast, and how to store a dead body for up to five days.
asserted
advice → include → days
You might expect this would have prompted widespread panic, but in fact it led to a political backlash, and was later lampooned on TV and in music.
uncertain
it → expect → music
It shows the risks governments take when launching such campaigns, and the fine balance that must be struck between hammering home a practical message without causing panic – or other unintended reactions.
asserted
that → show → panic
The government’s new Be Ready campaign is advising the public to stock up on three day’s worth of supplies for use during severe weather or cyber-attacks, so help can be directed to the most vulnerable first.
asserted
help → advise → vulnerable
In a concise, two-page document, it suggests people stock bottled water and non-perishable food for three days, a torch with spare batteries, a wind-up FM radio, a first aid kit and a copy of their passport.
uncertain
people → suggest → passport
To stave off panic buying, it advises people to check their cupboards first and build up items gradually on regular shopping trips.
asserted
it → stave → trips
While there is no evidence the advice has triggered mass panic, the public is clearly responding.
asserted
public → be → panic
Jack Brown, who co-owns Sgt Prepper Shop, which stocks emergency food and survival tools
asserted
which → co → food
said he received a month’s worth of orders in the first 24 hours of the Be Ready campaign.
asserted
he → say → campaign
“I thought my phone was glitching or being hacked with the number of orders coming in,” he said.
asserted
he → think → orders
Brown said the advice seemed sensible and proportionate.
asserted
advice → say → ?
Three days was the “sweet spot”, he said, with most everyday emergencies like power cuts, a burst water main or flooding sorted within that timeframe.
asserted
emergencies → say → timeframe
It is also “realistic, affordable and fits in a cupboard”, he said, adding that asking people to stock up on a month’s worth of supplies would feel overwhelming and most people would do nothing at all.
asserted
people → fit → nothing
A wind-up radio was also a sensible suggestion, and ones with a built-in torch and phone-charging USB port make them “one of the most useful bits of kit you can own”, he said.
asserted
he → wind → kit
Dr Sarita Robinson, associate dean for the school of psychology and humanities at the University of Lancashire, said there was little evidence to suggest these kinds of messaging campaigns cause panic.
asserted
kinds → say → panic
“There’s this perception that if we tell people the truth we’re somehow going to panic them and it isn’t the case,” she said.
asserted
she → ’ → them
“When we use accurate messaging about emergency situations, the public will engage with that proactively.
asserted
public → use → that
It’s when we start to hide information and there’s a void of information, that’s when things can go wrong for government.”
asserted
things → ’ → government
She said Be Ready was “realistic, quite low level, and should be reassuring because it’s basically treating the public like the grownups they are”.
asserted
they → say → grownups
Dan Goss, who runs Start Prepping UK, said traffic to his website was up 700% since news of the campaign emerged in August.
asserted
news → run → August
He said he was glad to see the subject finally being taken seriously and spoken about in “plain language” by the government, and felt the risk of panic was low.
asserted
risk → say → panic
“The level of uptake required for that would be huge – you would need to have an enormous number of people all take the government’s advice very seriously and all jump on it as a priority,” he said.
asserted
he → require → priority
“We’re definitely in a phase now where we’re seeing lots of more disruption to people’s lives – not necessarily apocalyptic disasters, but things that have a big impact on small areas, so this advice is very much needed.”
asserted
advice → ’re → areas
Robinson said the campaign showed how the perception of “prepping” has shifted, especially since the Covid-19 pandemic when most people will remember seeing empty supermarket shelves.
“We did a study during Covid that showed people who did mild levels of prepping, such as having food, masks and hand gel in the house a few weeks before the pandemic, had lower anxiety and depression, and less stress,” she said.
asserted
she → say → anxiety
“The government really needs to portray that this is just normal, everyday, very common in other countries, and isn’t wearing a tinfoil hat and building a nuclear bunker in your back garden.”
asserted
this → need → garden
The Aporia
