As Kirsty McNeill approaches 100 days as international development minister, her words to charities while serving as Scotland office minister are worth recalling: civil society sees “things we in government just can’t see.”
asserted
we → approach → government
I recently returned from Chad, where we took three members of parliament to see Action Against Hunger’s work, and where the consequences of the war in neighbouring Sudan on fuelling hunger are impossible to ignore.
asserted
consequences → return → hunger
From where Action Against Hunger sits, we can often see hunger coming.
asserted
hunger → sit → ?
Every day, from Sudan to Gaza, communities are being pushed deeper into poverty, displacement and hunger by conflict.
asserted
communities → push → conflict
We see it when food disappears from markets, when families can no longer afford basic meals, when farmers lose access to land and when health workers see more children arriving with acute malnutrition.
asserted
children → see → malnutrition
By the time famine is declared, catastrophe is already under way.
asserted
catastrophe → declare → way
In 2025, 266 million people experienced acute food insecurity.
asserted
people → experience → insecurity
For the first time since records began, famine was confirmed in two places in the same year: in parts of Sudan and Gaza.
asserted
famine → begin → Sudan
Famine and acute hunger are almost always the foreseeable outcome of conflict, political decisions and failures to act.
asserted
Famine → act → conflict
On the ground, we see firsthand that these crises are the result of human decisions.
asserted
crises → see → decisions
The lethality of conflict globally has tripled in the last 20 years.
asserted
lethality → triple → years
Essential infrastructure like hospitals schools, and water systems are systematically targeted, yet conflict parties are widely met with near impunity from foreign powers.
asserted
parties → target → powers
This trend matters because it will define the global fight against poverty.
asserted
it → matter → poverty
The World Bank projects that by 2030, around 60 per cent of people living in extreme poverty will live in fragile and conflict-affected economies.
asserted
cent → project → economies
Tackling conflict cannot be separate to the UK’s approach to global development.
asserted
Tackling → tackle → development
Against this backdrop, it is encouraging to see the UK's new foreign secretary announce sanctions targeting violent extremists in the West Bank, which signals a willingness to use diplomatic tools to defend international law.
asserted
which → see → law
Equally welcome is the government's vocal commitment to delivering its manifesto pledge to return UK aid spending to 0.7 per cent of Gross National Income.
asserted
commitment → deliver → Income
Aid budgets have been falling from nearly all the major donor governments, exacerbating the challenges for organisations like Action Against Hunger, operating in fragile and conflict-affected states.
asserted
budgets → fall → states
It comes on top of daily operational challenges with security, humanitarian access and a lack of basic infrastructure.
asserted
It → come → infrastructure
Walking away is not an option.
asserted
Walking → walk → ?
This reality of worsening conflict-induced poverty exposes a growing gap in current development thinking.
asserted
reality → worsen → thinking
The government's Modern Development Approach, published shortly before the new administration took office, sets out a plan that prioritises high-return investment.
asserted
that → publish → investment
History shows us that this approach is not a match for conflict-affected contexts.
asserted
approach → show → contexts
Investment is high risk where governance systems are weak, security risks are high, sanctions are imposed and markets have collapsed.
asserted
markets → impose → ?
A focus on investment-led growth is liable to leave behind those with the highest needs.
asserted
focus → lead → needs
The UK's development model must evolve.
asserted
model → evolve → ?
Fragile and conflict-affected states cannot be treated as exceptions to mainstream development policy, siloed to the humanitarian budget.
asserted
states → affect → budget
This means prioritising development approaches that are adapted to fragility.
asserted
that → mean → fragility
A different type of diplomacy, one that is values-led and human security focused, should sit at the heart of the government approach to building a safer world.
asserted
that → lead → world
When human decisions drive hunger, human interaction can play a key role in stopping it.
asserted
interaction → drive → it
But values-led or human-centred diplomacy cannot become another buzzword.
asserted
diplomacy → lead → ?
It requires sustained, high-level engagement to influence decision makers and armed actors, with the core aim to first prevent and then to protect civilians in conflict.
asserted
It → require → conflict
It should mean using early-warning triggers for diplomatic action, rather than waiting until famine is declared.
asserted
famine → mean → action
If the UK's international engagement is grounded in human dignity, international law and civilian protection, those values must shape what the government does before people reach the point of starvation, not simply what it says afterwards.
asserted
it → ground → what
The UK’s 2027 G20 presidency provides an opportunity to take this approach internationally.
asserted
presidency → provide → approach
The G20 cannot resolve every conflict.
asserted
G20 → resolve → conflict
But it can influence many of the conditions that determine whether shocks become catastrophes, addressing debt, development finance, climate resilience, food systems and investment in prevention.
asserted
shocks → influence → prevention
Britain should use its presidency to make the case that preventing conflict and hunger is central to a safer and more resilient world.
asserted
preventing → use → world
It must connect food and human security with climate, health and economic security.
asserted
It → connect → climate
One hundred days in, my message to McNeill’s is simple:
Civil society can often see hunger before it becomes famine.
asserted
it → see → hunger
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
