A Southern California skincare store has closed one of its locations following allegations of high-pressure sales tactics from customers who said they were coerced into spending thousands of dollars on beauty products.
asserted
they → close → products
The Bee & Co. storefront at Westfield Topanga mall in Canoga Park is now covered and appears to be vacant.
asserted
storefront → cover → Park
A lockbox was hung on the door on Sept. 24, and only a faint outline of the store's name is visible.
asserted
outline → hang → name
The closure comes after months of reporting from CBS California Investigates on allegations that Bee & Co. employees targeted vulnerable shoppers and pressured them into purchasing expensive skin care products and devices.
asserted
employees → come → products
Victor Chisholm and Gabe Cota, who both have intellectual disabilities, spoke with CBS California Investigates about their experiences at Bee & Co.
asserted
who → have → Bee
They said they were approached at the Westfield Topanga mall by a woman who offered them samples and compliments before encouraging them to enter the store.
asserted
who → say → store
The men alleged that an employee later took them into a back room for a skin treatment and pressured them to purchase creams and devices.
asserted
employee → allege → creams
Between Chisholm and Cota, their purchases totaled more than $60,000.
asserted
purchases → total → 60,000
"At one point, [the salesperson] said that she won't take no for an answer," Cota said.
asserted
Cota → say → answer
Chisholm said he did not understand how much he would be paying for the products.
asserted
he → say → products
"I didn't know it would actually cost that much," he said, noting that he did not intend to spend over $50,000.
asserted
he → know → 50,000
He also said the store's employees would not let him leave until he agreed to buy the products.
asserted
he → say → products
For months, CBS California Investigates has documented Bee & Co. employees at Southern California malls approaching potential customers, offering samples and encouraging shoppers to enter the stores.
asserted
employees → document → stores
Bee & Co.'s product distributor, Mazal Group, is based in Chatsworth.
asserted
distributor → base → Chatsworth
Mazal supplies skincare products to other stores operating under different names at malls in Southern California and elsewhere in the country, including Introstem, Rachel's Best Soaps and The Soap Tree.
asserted
Mazal → supply → Introstem
A spokesperson for Mazal Group says the company solely "stores and distributes products to retailers.
asserted
company → say → retailers
It does not sell to consumers, and does not hire, train, pay or supervise retail staff.
asserted
It → sell → staff
However, the company's website lists a broad range of services that go well beyond traditional distribution, including new lease and lease renewal services, architectural and design services, accounting services, research and product development, and marketing and advertising services.
asserted
that → list → services
The allegations against Bee & Co. have drawn attention from Sherman Oaks Rep. Brad Sherman, a Democrat whose 32nd congressional district includes Westfield Topanga.
asserted
district → draw → Topanga
"This is not what should be going on in our malls," Sherman said.
asserted
Sherman → go → malls
When asked whether state officials or law enforcement should examine the allegations, Sherman said he planned to bring the matter to the attention of California Attorney General Rob Bonta.
asserted
he → ask → Bonta
The Los Angeles Police Department is investigating the circumstances involving Chisholm's interactions with Bee & Co. employees, according to information obtained by CBS California Investigates.
uncertain
Department → investigate → Investigates
It is unclear whether Westfield removed Bee & Co. from the mall.
uncertain
Westfield → remove → mall
When asked by CBS California Investigates to comment on the store's apparent closure, the shopping center operator said in a statement it is "actively addressing this matter."
asserted
it → ask → matter
Employees at neighboring stores told CBS California Investigates that Bee & Co. workers suddenly covered the store's windows and left the location last week.
asserted
workers → neighbor → location
Chisholm's attorney, Fred Voigtmann, said the closure of the Westfield Topanga location will not end his efforts to pursue additional allegations legally.
asserted
closure → say → allegations
"Based on the amount of people who've reached out to me, this is something that we're going to keep after," Voigtmann said.
asserted
Voigtmann → base → that
He said he has spoken with other people who have described similar experiences.
asserted
who → say → experiences
"There's a lot of shame and pretty much every person I've talked to broke down crying on the phone about what happened to them," Voigtmann said.
asserted
Voigtmann → be → them
Voigtmann characterized the allegations as more serious than ordinary buyers' remorse, calling the conduct "fraud" and saying the people involved were taken advantage of.
asserted
people → characterize → advantage
Bee & Co.'s attorney disputes that characterization.
asserted
attorney → dispute → characterization
A day after a CBS California Investigates interview with Voigtmann, Bee & Co.'s attorney, Neville Johnson, sent a letter calling CBS California Investigates' coverage "a one-sided and misleading account of the Chisholm matter."
asserted
attorney → send → matter
The letter said the coverage excluded information about Chisholm's purchases at other stores throughout the mall and claimed he is "prone to making large purchases at multiple stores."
It also alleged that Chisholm "sexually harassed Bee & Company employees."
asserted
Chisholm → say → employees
Voigtmann responded in a letter of his own, calling the harassment allegation "baseless."
asserted
Voigtmann → respond → allegation
He described the company's claim as an attempt to deflect from what he called "despicable and likely criminal behavior" by Bee & Company and its employees.
uncertain
he → describe → Bee
Chisholm said he was also pressured to send more than $10,000 in tips through Cash App and Zelle, in addition to paying for the products.
asserted
he → say → products
In their letter, Bee & Co.'s attorney attributed those payments to a "rogue employee" who was not authorized to receive independent transactions and is no longer employed by the store.
asserted
who → attribute → store
However, Chisholm's receipts show that he also sent money to the store manager.
asserted
he → show → manager
Previous reporting referred to the Mazal Group as the "parent company" of Bee & Co. and other retailers.
asserted
reporting → refer → Bee
An updated version of this story reflects the Mazal Group's position that it is a distributor and that retailers are independently owned.
asserted
retailers → update → position
The Aporia
