Photo via National Post

Chris Selley: Revoking the Stanley Cup from the NHL is a trade-war bargaining chip worth trying

Read the original at National Post ↗
Cite

Selley, C. (2026, September 13). Chris Selley: Revoking the Stanley Cup from the NHL is a trade-war bargaining chip worth trying. National Post. https://nationalpost.com/opinion/chris-selley-revoking-the-stanley-cup-from-the-nhl-is-a-trade-war-bargaining-chip-worth-trying

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

National Post · collected 2026-09-13 · by Chris Selley analysis

Quick Summary

Chris Selley suggests using the Stanley Cup as a bargaining chip in U.S.-Canada trade tensions. He notes that travel restrictions due to political disputes are hurting the Buffalo economy, given that about 15% of season-ticket holders for the Bills and Sabres come from Canada. While promoting cross-border harmony through sports like singing national anthems at games is positive, Selley proposes a more dramatic gesture: revoking Canadian access to the Stanley Cup if tensions worsen, potentially uniting Canadians around a shared cultural icon.
Written by AI on 2026-09-13, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

In September 2026, the Buffalo Bills, an NFL team near the U.S.-Canada border, played their home opener at the newly built $2.1 billion Highmark Stadium. To honor their significant Canadian fan base—estimated to be 10-15% of season ticket holders—the game featured both national anthems: "O Canada" performed by the Toronto band Barenaked Ladies and "The Star-Spangled Banner" sung by actress Auliʻi Cravalho. This gesture occurred amid an escalating trade war between the U.S. and Canada, with President Donald Trump signing a memorandum aimed at removing Canadian-origin goods from federal procurement. Despite the diplomatic tension, the event drew strong support from Canadian fans, some of whom drove across the border to attend. However, opinions were divided; while many saw it as a sign of goodwill toward Canadians, others viewed it as an oddity given there was no Canadian team involved in the game. The move highlighted both the cultural ties and political tensions between the two nations.

Written for “Canadian Anthem Controversy Nfl” on 2026-11-20, grounded in this article and the 7 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

7 outlets covered “Canadian Anthem Controversy Nfl”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

National PostThis outlet13 Sep

Chris Selley suggests using the Stanley Cup as a bargaining chip in U.S.-Canada trade tensions. He notes that travel restrictions due to political disputes are hurting the Buffalo economy, given that about 15% of season-ticket holders for the Bills and Sabres come from Canada. While promoting cross-border harmony through sports like singing national anthems at games is positive, Selley proposes a more dramatic…

Chris Selley: Revoking the Stanley Cup from the NHL is a trade-war bargaining chip worth trying (this article)2 articles from National Post on this story
CBC17 Sep

The Buffalo Bills will hold their 2026 home opener against the Detroit Lions tonight at 8 p.m. ET, celebrating their Canadian fanbase by having Barenaked Ladies perform "O Canada." This event follows U.S. President Donald Trump's signing of a memorandum to identify and potentially remove Canadian-origin goods from federal procurement in the escalating trade war between the two countries. The Bills are participating…

Barenaked Ladies set to sing O Canada at Buffalo Bills home opener tonight →
The Globe and Mail18 Sep

On September 18, 2026, during the Buffalo Bills' home opener against the Detroit Lions at Highmark Stadium, Canadian rock band Barenaked Ladies performed "O Canada" before the game. The stadium, which cost US $2.2 billion and opened in June 2026, celebrated both American and Canadian anthems as part of its inaugural event. This move aimed to acknowledge the large Canadian fan base and players on the team, with…

Buffalo Bills lean into their Canadian audience with Barenaked Ladies’ performance of ‘O Canada’ →
Global News18 Sep

The Buffalo Bills played their first regular-season game in their new $2.1 billion Highmark Stadium against the Detroit Lions on Thursday night, featuring an opening ceremony with performances of both the U.S. and Canadian anthems by Barenaked Ladies and Auli’i Cravalho respectively. The stadium, which has a capacity slightly over 60,000, showcased improved grass quality and innovative fan experiences like light-up…

Barenaked Ladies perform ‘O Canada’ for packed house at Bills’ new stadium →
Toronto Star18 Sep

Barenaked Ladies performed "O Canada" at the Buffalo Bills' season home opener in Highmark Stadium, drawing cheers from the audience but mixed reactions online. The performance included a line in French and occurred during heightened trade tensions between the U.S. and Canada. The Bills, known for their substantial Canadian fan base, honored this connection with a cross-border football pass challenge featuring…

Barenaked Ladies' 'O Canada' rendition at Buffalo Bills home opener draws mixed responses →
BBC18 Sep

At a recent American football game between the Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions in New York, the Canadian national anthem was played before kickoff, an unusual gesture given the tense trade relations between Canada and the U.S. under President Trump's administration. The article highlights how this moment resonated emotionally with many of the Canadian fans present, who felt welcomed despite recent diplomatic…

Why an American football game played the Canadian national anthem →
Show 1 more outlets
Fox News18 Sep

During the Buffalo Bills' first regular season home game at the new Highmark Stadium against the Detroit Lions, the team honored Canada by singing its national anthem before the match. This decision was met with criticism from some fans and commentators who felt it was inappropriate since no Canadian teams were involved in the game. Fox News contributor Joey Jones criticized the move, arguing that playing the U.S…

Singing the Canadian National Anthem at the Buffalo Bills Home Opener was a mistake →

Where they agree and split

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 8 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans left and hedges 7% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Globe and Mail
Hedges 2 of 19 claims Outlet record 51/100
Global News
Hedges 0 of 22 claims Outlet record 63/100
Toronto Star
Leans left Hedges 0 of 16 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBC News
Leans left Hedges 0 of 9 claims Outlet record 72/100
“Article A mentions a general sentiment about Canadian anthem singing at sporting events, while Article B describes a specific event with Barenaked Ladies performing the Canadian national anthem at the Buffalo Bills' home opener.”
National Post
Leans right further right than this Hedges 4 of 34 claims Outlet record 60/100
“Article A mentions an announcement about the Barenaked Ladies singing the Canadian national anthem at a future event, while Article B discusses the actual occurrence of this event and uses it to contrast American reactions with Canadian ones.”
The Independent
Hedges 0 of 21 claims Outlet record 59/100
“Article A describes the Buffalo Bills' decision to perform both national anthems as a gesture amid U.S.-Canada border tensions, while Article B discusses this event in the context of broader trade disputes and mentions it alongside another instance where Sabres fans sang O Canada.”

Story

Canadian Anthem Controversy Nfl
Politics · 8 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
42
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
3 of 42 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
60/100
National Post's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
8
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-13 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

National Post · 1242 article(s) · 2 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 2 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Chris Selley
12 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
You may have read about Quebec Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon’s “new strategy” for sovereignty, and you might have thought, “Hang on, this sounds a lot like the old strategy” — namely, pick fights with Ottawa and pitch the slightest federal-government resistance as an intolerable affront to all Quebecers.
2026-10-30 · assertive framing · Chris Selley: Does PSPP realize how unpopular he is?
In pursuit of cheaper groceries, she said she would offer tax breaks to independent and “mom-and-pop” stores opening shop in priority neighbourhoods.
Say what you will about his government’s performance, you can’t say Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew hasn’t cut an interesting figure.
But to say the Canadian government effectively cannot ban the distribution for profit of certain substances and be in Charter compliance is … well, something I would expect a group called the Drug User Liberation Front to argue.
We learned this week that Corrections Canada has approved a “safe snorting” program in federal prisons for inmates to reduce “the risk of internal nose cuts that could occur from homemade or plastic straws and reduce infections from diseases such as hepatitis B and C,” which doesn’t sound entirely implausible.
David Eby, the NDP premier of British Columbia, says he’s willing to support privatizing Vancouver airport so long as the revenues are invested in improving smaller airports in the province.
It seems like it could only make people more dubious.
No doubt the Journal asked the PMO to comment on this, which is when the PMO could have poured cold water on the idea right out of the gate.
The U.S.-Canada kerfuffle took an interesting tangent this week when the Buffalo Bills announced the Barenaked Ladies would sing the Canadian national anthem on Sept. 17 at the Bills’ new and lavishly taxpayer-funded US$2.1-billion stadium.
Finally we might (as some pundits hoped) “grow up,” “move out of our parents’ basement,” and install a resident head of state.
Also by Chris Selley
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 12 articles by Chris Selley →

Topics

Bills Canada Canadian Canadians Sabres

Subjects

NHL ORG · 7× Bills ORG · 5× Canadian NORP · 5× Canadians NORP · 5× Canada GPE · 4× U.S. GPE · 4× Sabres ORG · 3× Buffalo GPE · 2× Globe ORG · 2× the Barenaked Ladies ORG · 2×

Narrative

“The dispute over ownership of the Stanley Cup turns on a unique blend of ancient doctrines and modern rules about property rights in both physical and intangible assets,” University of Ottawa law professor Jeremy de Beer wrote about the controversy in a 2008 paper.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-13
The U.S.-Canada kerfuffle took an interesting tangent this week when the Buffalo Bills announced the Barenaked Ladies would sing the Canadian national anthem on Sept. 17 at the Bills’ new and lavishly taxpayer-funded US$2.1-billion stadium.

Claims (42 extracted, 3 hedged)

The U.S.-Canada kerfuffle took an interesting tangent this week when the Buffalo Bills announced the Barenaked Ladies would sing the Canadian national anthem on Sept. 17 at the Bills’ new and lavishly taxpayer-funded US$2.1-billion stadium. asserted
Ladies → take → stadium
(Even that kind of money doesn’t even get you a roof, nowadays!) asserted
kind → get → roof
Everyone seemed to treat it as a good news story, which it was. asserted
it → seem → story
Just like it was a good news story when Buffalo Sabres fans belted out O Canada when the anthem singer’s mic cut out at a game in April. asserted
mic → belt → April
(The Sabres play both anthems before all home games.) asserted
Sabres → play → games
This is the sort of relationship Canadians and Americans had, still have and, should sanity prevail, will have more of and better in the future. asserted
sanity → have → future
We can’t quit each other, in the long term, and we shouldn’t want to. asserted
we → quit → term
By some estimates, roughly 15 per cent of Bills’ and Sabres’ season-ticket holders commute from Canada. asserted
cent → commute → Canada
But fewer Canadians crossed Niagara River bridges in June 2026 than in any non-pandemic June this century. asserted
Canadians → cross → June
That’s leaving a mark on the Buffalo economy. asserted
That → leave → economy
There’s no doubt travel is one of the few levers Canada has to deploy, even if certain jurisdictions — Buffalo, for example, where three-quarters of voters went for Kamala Harris in 2024 — don’t make much sense as strategic targets. asserted
quarters → ’ → targets
So, hang on … should Canadians be travelling to Bills games at all? asserted
Canadians → hang → games
For that matter, should the Barenaked Ladies be playing for billionaire Bills (and Sabres) owner Terry Pegula, a Republican fracking tycoon? asserted
Ladies → play → Pegula
Canadian artists who’ve cancelled U.S. tours “because of Trump” have gotten good press. asserted
who → cancel → press
And Canadians love to judge each other’s civic spirit. asserted
Canadians → love → spirit
You mustn’t travel to the U.S., even if it’s for “a reunion with your dearest friend,” a Globe and Mail columnist informed us last year. asserted
columnist → travel → us
“Canadians should not visit the U.S. unless necessary. asserted
Canadians → visit → U.S.
I am not going again unless I have to for work,” a Toronto Star sports columnist wrote on X … as if “work trumps friends and family” is a concept we must all accept. asserted
we → go → friends
Back in the Globe, Labour Day having come and gone, snowbirds were enjoined this week: “By all means, venture abroad … asserted
snowbirds → come → means
Prime Minister Mark Carney seems to be of like mind. asserted
Carney → seem → mind
“The most powerful actions have (been) buying Canadian and travelling in Canada,” he said in a video posted this week, having not long ago returned from vacation in deepest Tuscany. asserted
he → buy → Tuscany
I’m glad the Bills are doing O Canada. asserted
Bills → ’m → Canada
Cross-border harmony is good, wherever we can find it. asserted
we → find → it
But I do think Canada can leverage sport in a funny sort of way that might really unite people from coast to coast: Instead of judging each other’s travel and consumer preferences, let’s take back the Stanley Cup. The NHL intends to expand, again. uncertain
NHL → think → Cup
Leading candidates reportedly include twice-failed NHL market Atlanta (whose previous franchises now play, ahem, in Calgary and Winnipeg); Phoenix, the most legendary failed hockey market this side of sub-Saharan Africa (the Coyotes now play in Salt Lake City); and Houston and Austin, which have at least never lost an NHL team before. uncertain
which → lead → team
There’s nothing wrong with U.S. expansion, including in the sun belt: Four of the Original Six NHL teams were American, after all. asserted
Four → ’ → teams
But meanwhile, a 10-year-old arena in Quebec City and a newly refurbished one in Hamilton are just sitting there waiting for the NHL. asserted
arena → refurbish → NHL
If there’s no one willing to invest in a team there, I think a league that cared even a tiny bit about its product would be quite concerned that no one thinks they can sell the game to people who actually play it. asserted
who → ’ → it
“The Stanley Cup belongs to the NHL,” Brian O’Neill, who was then one of the Cup’s two Canadian trustees (by terms stipulated by Lord Stanley himself) told the Globe in 2005. asserted
who → belong → 2005
This was after a group of beer-league players challenged the NHL’s right to simply not award the Cup when a lockout shut down the season. asserted
lockout → challenge → season
(Annoyingly, they settled with the league under confidential terms. asserted
they → settle → terms
The Cup has “belonged” to the NHL, in effect, since 1947. asserted
Cup → belong → 1947
But legally, it’s not that simple. asserted
it → ’ → ?
“The dispute over ownership of the Stanley Cup turns on a unique blend of ancient doctrines and modern rules about property rights in both physical and intangible assets,” University of Ottawa law professor Jeremy de Beer wrote about the controversy in a 2008 paper. asserted
Beer → turn → paper
But since Lord Stanley created the Stanley Cup trust as Canada’s governor general — i.e., as a representative of the Crown — de Beer said it was arguably never within anyone’s rights to cede de-facto control of. asserted
it → create → control
I’m not suggesting we just lock the Cup in a basement. asserted
we → suggest → basement
The NHL could still award it, though perhaps a repatriated and revamped Stanley Cup trusteeship might advocate for Canadian teams’ best interests in what is an inherently unbalanced league: Canadian teams generally don’t enjoy the same outrageous taxpayer subsidies as many American ones do for new arenas, and the tax burden does not work at all in Canadian teams’ favour when attracting players relative to Florida, Nevada or Texas. uncertain
burden → award → Florida
The NHL knows the Stanley Cup is one of its greatest brand assets, if not its greatest. asserted
Cup → know → assets
I can’t imagine any other country tolerating their national sport being abused to the extent Canada tolerates it from the NHL. asserted
Canada → imagine → NHL
The only argument I can see against at least trying to renegotiate or litigate the Stanley Cup agreement is that it’s silly and impractical. asserted
it → see → agreement
…and 2 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support