Photo via Fox News

Lindsay Clancy's push to probe holdout juror hits snag before pivotal retrial hearing

Read the original at Fox News ↗
Cite

Ruiz, M. (2026, September 29). Lindsay Clancy's push to probe holdout juror hits snag before pivotal retrial hearing. Fox News. https://www.foxnews.com/us/lindsay-clancy-push-probe-holdout-juror-hits-snag-pivotal-retrial-hearing

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Fox News · collected 2026-09-29 · by Michael Ruiz

Quick Summary

In Plymouth, Massachusetts, Lindsay Clancy's defense lawyer Kevin Reddington planned to push for an investigation into the lone juror who held out during her trial. However, due to objections raised by the juror’s attorney, Edward Paltzik, and a lack of access to necessary court materials, both Reddington and the Plymouth County District Attorney’s office agreed temporarily to adjourn this motion. Despite this agreement, Reddington maintains that the investigation remains active pending Judge Sullivan's ruling and criticizes the characterization of the delay as a victory for the juror.
Written by AI on 2026-09-29, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy's defense motion to find her not guilty of murdering her three children, ruling that prosecutors presented sufficient evidence for a jury to determine she was criminally responsible despite suffering from mental illness. The judge noted that it is up to the jury to decide whether expert witnesses' testimony about her lack of criminal responsibility should be accepted or rejected. This decision leaves open the possibility of a retrial following the earlier mistrial due to a deadlocked jury. Clancy's lawyer argued there was insufficient evidence proving she committed the killings, but Sullivan disagreed, stating that any rational trier of fact could find her guilty based on the presented evidence. The case now remains unresolved with ongoing debate about criminal responsibility and mental health considerations in legal proceedings.

Written for “Lindsay Clancy Murder Case Hearing” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 29 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

15 outlets covered “Lindsay Clancy Murder Case Hearing”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Fox NewsThis outlet29 Sep

In Plymouth, Massachusetts, Lindsay Clancy's defense lawyer Kevin Reddington planned to push for an investigation into the lone juror who held out during her trial. However, due to objections raised by the juror’s attorney, Edward Paltzik, and a lack of access to necessary court materials, both Reddington and the Plymouth County District Attorney’s office agreed temporarily to adjourn this motion. Despite this…

Lindsay Clancy's push to probe holdout juror hits snag before pivotal retrial hearing (this article)4 articles from Fox News on this story
CBS News1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan rejected Lindsay Clancy's attorney Kevin Reddington’s request for a not guilty verdict in her murder trial involving her three children who died in 2023. The judge ruled that despite the defense's claims of insufficient evidence, the prosecution had presented enough to warrant a jury decision, based on Clancy being the sole person home at the time of the killings as confirmed by GPS data and…

Judge denies Lindsay Clancy's long-shot bid for a not-guilty finding →6 articles from CBS News on this story
The Independent1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan refused to declare Lindsay Clancy not guilty after her first trial ended in a mistrial with a jury split 11 to 1 in favor of acquittal. During a hearing on Tuesday, Clancy’s attorney Kevin Reddington argued that prosecutors did not provide sufficient evidence to prove Clancy killed her three children, describing the case as speculative. However, Judge Sullivan disagreed, stating there was…

Judge in Lindsay Clancy trial refuses to declare her not guilty after mistrial →4 articles from The Independent on this story
New York Post1 Oct

Judge Timothy Sullivan rejected Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer, David Reddington, when he tried to have the murder charges against her dismissed after she was found not guilty by an impasse jury earlier this month. The judge ruled that there was enough evidence presented during the six-week trial to sustain the charges of Clancy strangling her three young children with exercise bands in Duxbury, Massachusetts, on January…

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer slapped down by judge after trying to get murder charges thrown out →3 articles from New York Post on this story
CBC1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s defense request to declare her not guilty of murdering her three children in Massachusetts in 2023. The judge ruled that prosecutors provided sufficient evidence for a jury to determine if Clancy was responsible, despite defense arguments questioning the adequacy of the prosecution's case and suggesting lack of police investigation. The article details the first trial’s…

Judge denies defence request to declare Lindsay Clancy not guilty →2 articles from CBC on this story
Washington Examiner1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan in Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial rejected the defense's request for a not-guilty verdict based on lack of criminal responsibility due to mental illness. Six forensic experts agreed that Clancy was suffering from serious mental health issues, but disagreed on whether this negates her legal culpability. The judge ruled that despite evidence of severe mental illness, prosecutors presented…

Judge in Lindsay Clancy murder trial rejects defense’s not-guilty bid →2 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
Show 8 more outlets
Toronto Star29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy will appear in court Tuesday for a hearing that could determine whether she faces another trial after a mistrial was declared due to a 11-to-1 deadlock favoring acquittal on murder charges related to the deaths of her three children. Clancy’s defense team has filed motions requesting dismissal of the case and questioning the conduct of one juror who favored conviction, while prosecutors may decide…

Lindsay Clancy set to return to court for first time since murder trial ended with deadlocked jury →
Sydney Morning Herald29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer is now arguing there isn’t enough evidence to prove she killed her three children, shifting from the previous focus on her mental state during a trial where the jury was split 11 to 1 in her favor. The defense claims Clancy lacked memory and awareness due to postpartum psychosis at the time of the incident, while prosecutors maintain strong evidence against her, including testimony that she…

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer now questions whether she killed her three children →
NPR29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer, Kevin Reddington, now argues that there isn't enough evidence to prove she killed her three children in 2023. At a recent hearing following a deadlocked jury at her first trial, Reddington pointed out inconsistencies and lack of direct admission from Clancy, questioning the prosecution’s case. Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham counters this by citing numerous pieces of evidence presented during…

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer now questions whether she killed her 3 children →
BBC29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court recently for her murder trial that ended in a mistrial due to a hung jury. Her lawyer, Kevin Reddington, argued that the case should be dismissed, citing insufficient evidence and claiming the prosecution failed to meet its burden of proof. Prosecutors countered by saying they presented ample evidence showing Clancy was mentally sound at the time she killed her three children and…

Lindsay Clancy appears in court as her lawyer pushes for murder case to be dismissed →
ABC News (US)1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan rejected Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss her triple-murder case, ruling there was sufficient evidence presented by prosecutors to support a guilty verdict. The denial means Clancy’s case could proceed to a retrial if necessary.

Lindsay Clancy judge denies motion to force not guilty finding →
ABC News (AU)1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s defense motion to find her not guilty of murdering her three children in Massachusetts in 2023. During a hearing, Clancy's lawyer Kevin Reddington argued there was insufficient evidence linking her to the killings. However, Judge Sullivan ruled that the physical and circumstantial evidence presented allows for a jury to conclude beyond reasonable doubt that she…

Judge denies Lindsay Clancy defence motion to find her not guilty →
The Straits Times1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan in Boston denied Lindsay Clancy’s lawyers’ request to declare her not guilty after a mistrial due to a hung jury in her murder trial. The judge ruled that prosecutors had presented enough evidence to support a conviction, despite defense arguments that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings. The incident occurred on January 24, 2023, when Clancy strangled her…

US judge denies request to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty after mistrial →
Daily Mail2 Oct

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s motion to have her found not guilty of murdering her three children, ruling that the evidence presented by the prosecution was sufficient beyond reasonable doubt. This decision follows a mistrial declared earlier this month when jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict; one juror refused to find Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity due to severe postpartum…

Lindsay Clancy loses daring bid to have her found not guilty of murdering her three children after mistrial →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • The mistrial was declared due to the jury being split 11 to 1 in favor of acquitting Clancy.63
  • Clancy's attorney argued that there was insufficient evidence presented at trial for a rational jury to find her guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.23
Quoted from the coverage (4)

“This entire case is based on speculation,” attorney Kevin Reddington said in a striking turn after a lengthy trial that focused more on her mental state than on whether she took their lives.

6 outlets

There is, Reddington contended, not enough evidence “that this woman killed those children.”

6 outlets

Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham called his argument “laughable,” pointing to various evidence raised during the trial.

6 outlets

Clancy’s lawyer said she should not be held criminally responsible because of her postpartum psychosis, a rare mental illness linked to the stress, sleep deprivation and hormonal changes that follow childbirth.

5 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • CBS News states that Reddington argued there was no evidence Clancy killed her children, whereas other sources indicate he did not dispute the fact of the killings but rather the criminal responsibility and burden of proof.27

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The New York Post emphasizes the pivotal nature of the hearing in deciding the future of Clancy’s case, whereas CBS News highlights Reddington's argument about insufficient evidence.82
Stated as fact4
The headlines (4)

Lindsay Clancy's push to investigate holdout juror could be paused as defense, prosecutors agree to adjourn Fox News · stated as fact

Lindsay Clancy set to return to court for first time since murder trial ended with deadlocked jury Toronto Star · stated as fact

Judge could dismiss Lindsay Clancy murder case in court hearing today The Independent · stated as fact

Pivotal Lindsay Clancy hearing could decide fate of her triple murder case after mistrial New York Post · stated as fact

Words to watch (2)

Judge in Lindsay Clancy trial refuses to declare her not guilty after mistrial The Independent

Attorney says there's "no evidence" Lindsay Clancy admitted killing her kids CBS News

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 30 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 20% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
Toronto Star
Hedges 5 of 21 claims Outlet record 65/100
The Independent
Hedges 2 of 13 claims Outlet record 59/100
Fox News
Hedges 4 of 24 claims Outlet record 66/100
“Article A mentions a lawyer challenging claims about breaking the law regarding the juror, while Article B discusses court proceedings and arguments related to Clancy's case and the status of investigating the holdout juror.”
New York Post
Hedges 4 of 24 claims Outlet record 66/100
Fox News
Hedges 2 of 29 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles refer to different aspects of the Lindsay Clancy case; one focuses on a court hearing and motion, while the other is a general news roundup that mentions the juror's silence.”
The Independent
Hedges 5 of 28 claims Outlet record 59/100
Washington Examiner
Hedges 2 of 19 claims Outlet record 67/100
BBC News
Hedges 2 of 21 claims Outlet record 65/100
CBS News
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 66/100

Story

Lindsay Clancy Murder Case Hearing
Crime & Law · 30 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
46
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
20%
9 of 46 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
66/100
Fox News's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
30
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-29 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Fox News · 8414 article(s) · 16 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 16 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Michael Ruiz
52 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The Governor’s assurance that the perpetrators will never be released is obviously cruelly false.
Years before New York City's socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdani ordered the dismantling of a specialized police task force, he'd been detained by its members, resurfaced video the mayor himself tweeted in 2021 appears to show.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards hold a news conference outlining a five-year delay and revised strategy to shut down the notorious jail complex.
Charles "Weldon" Boyd and Kenneth "Bradley" Williams had originally invoked the state's "stand your ground" law and argued they were defending themselves from an irrational driver.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is dissolving the NYPD's Strategic Response Group — an elite tactical unit criticized for its handling of some left-wing protests while also responding to critical threats including a mass shooting at an office building last year and an attempted bombing attack on dueling demonstrations outside the city's mayoral residence.
Judge William Sullivan repeatedly told the parties to pick a date in March or April.
On March 22, 1978, the Airman saw Marrone's body near the Camp Hero radar tower that decades later would inspire Netflix's "Stranger Things."
The state's Supreme Court is expected to review hundreds of cases before clemency would be official.
"Everyone has the right to free speech, and violence will not be tolerated at this university," Philley said.
The Massachusetts judge overseeing the murder case against Lindsay Clancy has denied her motion to dismiss the case on double jeopardy claims, clearing the way for a retrial in the strangling deaths of her three young children that some experts believe could have a better chance at a guilty verdict.
Also by Michael Ruiz
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 52 articles by Michael Ruiz →

Topics

Fox News' Mass. Massachusetts PLYMOUTH Plymouth County

Subjects

Reddington PERSON · 8× Clancy PERSON · 4× Desronvil PERSON · 3× Massachusetts GPE · 3× Erskine PERSON · 2× Plymouth County GPE · 2× Sullivan ORG · 2× Lindsay Clancy PERSON · 1× Mass. GPE · 1× PLYMOUTH GPE · 1×

Narrative

Erskine said the motion is a long-shot but Reddington is likely laying the foundation for an appeal in the future. "The big issue, in my opinion, is whether outside information came into the jury room and whether a judge can find that any 'hypothetical juror' would let it influence his decision," she told Fox News Digital.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-29
A Massachusetts judge overseeing the Lindsay Clancy case is expected to hear arguments on her double jeopardy motion Tuesday, while another push to investigate the lone holdout juror in her mistrial may be on hold — for now.

Claims (46 extracted, 9 hedged)

A Massachusetts judge overseeing the Lindsay Clancy case is expected to hear arguments on her double jeopardy motion Tuesday, while another push to investigate the lone holdout juror in her mistrial may be on hold — for now. uncertain
push → oversee → hold
Clancy is expected in court in person for the first time since her trial ended in a deadlocked jury and the judge declared a mistrial on Sept. 4. asserted
judge → expect → Sept.
In the weeks since her mistrial, Clancy's case has remained a topic of national interest, with fellow jurors and Clancy's defense attorney attacking the lone holdout. asserted
jurors → remain → holdout
Here's a roundup of what to expect as she returns to court: asserted
she → expect → court
Defense calls to investigate the holdout juror Clancy's defense lawyer Kevin Reddington had called for an inquiry into the lone holdout juror, Michael Desronvil, whom he has dubbed "the obstructionist juror." asserted
he → investigate → whom
Desronvil opposed 11 others on the panel and was the only one who wanted to find her guilty until the end. asserted
her → oppose → end
However, according to Desronvil's attorney, Edward Paltzik, both Reddington and Plymouth County prosecutors agreed to adjourn that motion after counsel for the holdout raised an objection because they didn't yet have access to impounded materials necessary to file a response. uncertain
they → accord → response
"The DA and Reddington consent to adjourn the motion to investigate Michael," Paltzik told Fox News' Kayleigh McEnany Monday. asserted
Paltzik → consent → McEnany
"If Judge Sullivan signs an order today, much of it could be adjourned," he said. uncertain
he → sign → it
Reddington pushed back, forcefully, while conceding that he and the district attorney's office had agreed to continue the motion out of professional courtesy to local counsel now representing the juror. asserted
he → push → juror
"Earlier today, both the government and I were contacted by a professional local attorney who represents Juror Doe," he said, not using the juror's name due to an impoundment order from the court. asserted
he → contact → court
"That attorney requested — as any qualified counsel would — adequate time to review our motion and reply." asserted
counsel → request → motion
He added, "As is professional courtesy, both the government and I agreed to continue this specific motion to a later date at their request. asserted
government → add → request
The motion remains active, fully alive, and is currently pending a ruling from Judge Sullivan. asserted
motion → remain → Sullivan
We will not allow a publicity-seeking opportunist to twist simple courtroom courtesy into a victory that does not exist. asserted
that → allow → victory
" The terms adjourned and continued are similar but have distinct meanings. asserted
terms → adjourn → meanings
"Adjournment generally signifies that something like a hearing is off indefinitely especially because no date is specified," explained retired Massachusetts Judge Carol Erskine. asserted
Erskine → signify → hearing
"A continuance is a simple request by a party or two parties to get a new date. asserted
continuance → get → date
[Reddington] objects because adjournment is a misrepresentation of what is happening. asserted
what → object → ?
" If Reddington ultimately prevails, the court could hold a Fidler hearing, where the judge would question Desronvil. uncertain
judge → prevail → Desronvil
"There are three phases to a hearing like that," said Erskine, who is also a child welfare advocate and has been closely following the case. asserted
who → be → case
"This is something that could result in a strong manifest necessity claim but hard to tell until it happens. uncertain
it → result → claim
Manifest necessity is the legal standard required to hold a second trial. asserted
necessity → require → trial
Erskine said the motion is a long-shot but Reddington is likely laying the foundation for an appeal in the future. "The big issue, in my opinion, is whether outside information came into the jury room and whether a judge can find that any 'hypothetical juror' would let it influence his decision," she told Fox News Digital. asserted
she → say → Digital
"It’s definitely more complicated than that, but there is case law about it. asserted
It → ’ → it
" Could the holdout sue Reddington? uncertain
holdout → sue → Reddington
"This is a strange new world in which disagreeing jurors and their surrogates conduct a public debate after the trial in the media and social media," said Jack Lu, another retired Massachusetts judge. asserted
Lu → disagree → media
Reddington's request for an inquiry into Desronvil is largely based on allegations from other jurors who accused him of having reasonable doubt about the case and ignoring it. asserted
who → base → it
He is seeking phone records, his confidential juror questionnaire and police records. asserted
He → seek → records
However, he's also called him an "obstructionist" outside the courtroom and accused him of having an "agenda." asserted
he → call → agenda
"[The other jurors] know that they were robbed — by one man — for whatever his agenda was, who stole seven weeks of the life of these other jurors that were so attentive, so beautiful, so wonderful and listened to this evidence," he told reporters after leaving the courthouse on Sept. 4, the day the mistrial was declared. asserted
mistrial → know → Sept.
Still, he downplayed speculation from legal analysts about a potential defamation lawsuit from the holdout against Clancy's team. asserted
he → downplay → team
"Defamation law is textbook complex," he told Fox News Digital. asserted
he → tell → Digital
"Statements made in court proceedings are privileged. asserted
Statements → make → proceedings
" Statements made out of court that could appear to be "false statements of fact" may end up being considered opinions, he added. uncertain
he → make → fact
"If a person says X happened, and we all know that person was not present, then it may be deemed to be an opinion," he said. uncertain
he → say → ?
"This might apply to any alleged statements about what happened in the jury room. uncertain
what → apply → room
"I don’t think any of the legal maneuvering, double jeopardy, all that stuff, a hearing in the trial court with the juror, I don't think it’s going anywhere," said Mark Bederow, a New York-based criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor who is following the case. asserted
who → think → case
"If you get down to brass tacks, once you get through all this, now you have to look at the DA and say, what are you doing?" he added. asserted
he → get → what
Most prosecutors would not seek a second trial in a case where only one juror agreed with them, he said, but that appears unlikely in this case. asserted
that → seek → case
…and 6 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support