Photo via National Post

J.D. Tuccille: Canada can win at trade by ignoring Trump

Read the original at National Post ↗
Cite

Jerema, C. (2026, August 25). J.D. Tuccille: Canada can win at trade by ignoring Trump. National Post. https://nationalpost.com/opinion/j-d-tuccille-canada-can-win-at-trade-by-ignoring-trump

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

National Post · collected 2026-08-25 · by Carson Jerema analysis

Quick Summary

J.D. Tuccille argues that Canada can succeed in its trade dealings with the US by ignoring Donald Trump's demands and instead adopting a policy of free trade. The US and Canadian leaders have engaged in a war of words over tariffs, but Tuccille believes that governments should get out of the way of people exchanging goods and services. According to economist Milton Friedman, who is cited in the article, protectionist policies like tariffs raise prices for customers and waste resources, while free trade promotes economic growth. The article suggests that Trump's administration is making a mistake by pushing for "reciprocal" trade deals, which are actually a form of protectionism.
Written by AI on 2026-08-25, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Here's a summary of the news story:

Naheed Nenshi, the leader of the Alberta NDP, has urged Premier Danielle Smith to cancel or postpone the upcoming referendum on separating from Canada due to the ongoing trade war with the US. The referendum is scheduled for October 19 and will ask voters whether they want to start the process of holding a future binding vote on separation.

Nenshi's demand was met with skepticism by some, who noted that he had previously opposed the idea of a separation referendum. Premier Smith rejected Nenshi's request, saying that the trade war was an opportunity for Alberta and Canada to stand together against the US.

Meanwhile, other provinces are also considering their stance on the trade war. Alberta and Saskatchewan have rejected suggestions that they impose export levies on natural resources such as oil and potash in retaliation for US tariffs, with Premier Smith saying that such a move would be "disastrous" and would harm not just Albertans but also other provinces.

The federal government has announced its plan to impose countertariffs on hundreds of US exports, including clothing and apparel, appliances, and dairy products. However, it has removed seafood and fish products from the list of counter-tariffs due to concerns about broader economic harms. The US has warned that further Canadian retaliation will not be tolerated.

The trade war is also being used as a rallying cry by some who are opposed to separation. A pro-unity group called Forever Canadian has seen an increase in support and interest in its patriotic lawn signs, with over 11,000 viewers attending an online town hall meeting last weekend.

Written for “Canada US Trade Dispute Escalation” on 2026-11-20, grounded in this article and the 53 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

19 outlets covered “Canada US Trade Dispute Escalation”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

National PostThis outlet25 Aug

J.D. Tuccille argues that Canada can succeed in its trade dealings with the US by ignoring Donald Trump's demands and instead adopting a policy of free trade. The US and Canadian leaders have engaged in a war of words over tariffs, but Tuccille believes that governments should get out of the way of people exchanging goods and services. According to economist Milton Friedman, who is cited in the article…

J.D. Tuccille: Canada can win at trade by ignoring Trump (this article)11 articles from National Post on this story
CBC27 Aug

The article reports on Canada's retaliatory measures against US President Donald Trump's 50% tariffs, specifically targeting imports from certain U.S. states with dollar-for-dollar counter-tariffs. According to the article, this move could have significant implications in key battleground states ahead of the midterm elections. The angle of the article is how Canada's response to Trump's trade war may ultimately harm…

Where Trump’s trade war with Canada could backfire | About That →12 articles from CBC on this story
The Globe and Mail27 Aug

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe expressed strong opposition to imposing export levies on natural resources such as oil and potash in retaliation for U.S. tariffs, with Smith calling it a "disastrous policy decision" that would devastate the Canadian economy. The two premiers spoke out despite Ottawa's plan to impose $7.5 billion worth of support package for workers and businesses…

Alberta, Saskatchewan push back on calls for oil, potash export levies in retaliation for U.S. tariffs →9 articles from The Globe and Mail on this story
The Guardian27 Aug

US President Donald Trump has threatened to impose tariffs on Canadian goods, including hockey sticks and tongue depressors, due to stalled trade talks. The US has already implemented tariffs on $20bn worth of Canadian exports, prompting Canada's prime minister, Mark Carney, to announce retaliatory tariffs on $20bn worth of US goods. Trump responded by calling Canadian negotiators "clowns" and threatening to rename…

How to lose Trump’s trade war: test Canada’s resolve with threats to hockey sticks →3 articles from The Guardian on this story
The Independent25 Aug

President Donald Trump has launched a personal attack on Ontario Premier Doug Ford, calling him "less intelligent" than his late brother Rob Ford. The attack was made on Truth Social on Monday amid tensions over tariffs with Canada. Rob Ford, a former Toronto mayor, was known for his right-wing populist style and charismatic personality, which drew comparisons to Trump. Canadian journalists have responded to the…

Trump lashes out at Ontario Premier Doug Ford calling him ‘less intelligent’ than late brother Rob →2 articles from The Independent on this story
ABC News (US)28 Aug

President Donald Trump has signed a proclamation temporarily lifting tariffs on some foreign imports of lean beef trimmings used for ground beef, effective September 1, to encourage a 25% discount on imported beef. This action applies to 300,000 metric tons of additional imports beyond what was already allowed at low tariffs, but does not specify which countries are affected. The move has sparked backlash from…

Trump signs proclamation to pause some beef tariffs despite backlash from base →2 articles from ABC News (US) on this story
Show 12 more outlets
Semafor27 Aug

A US official within the Trump administration is considering potential bans on Canadian imports in response to possible further retaliation from Canada against US tariffs. According to this source, if Canada takes additional steps, the US could impose tariffs or prohibit imports under Section 338 of the trade law. The US has already set a tariff hike for certain Canadian goods to 50% starting January 1. The Trump…

US eyes potential bans on Canadian imports →2 articles from Semafor on this story
Toronto Star26 Aug

Ontario Premier Doug Ford publicly insulted US President Donald Trump on Monday, saying "kiss my ass" in response to Trump's trade policies against Canada. The comment was made during a press conference where Ford also hinted at reinstating tariffs on Ontario electricity shipments to the US if necessary. This is not typical Canadian diplomacy or international discourse, but some are framing it as a long-overdue…

‘Kiss my ass’? Doug Ford finds the perfect words for Donald Trump →2 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Reason.com24 Aug

Yesterday, Donald Trump imposed 50% tariffs on numerous Canadian imports through the use of Section 338, a provision from the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 that has been superseded by new legislation. The article argues that this move is an illegal usurpation of congressional authority and will likely face legal challenges, citing previous court cases where similar tariff attempts were struck down. According to…

Trump Imposes Harmful and Illegal Section 338 Tariffs Against Many Canadian Imports →
The Bulwark24 Aug

Andrew Egger and Catherine Rampell discuss the collapse of trade negotiations between the US and Canada, which has escalated into a full-blown trade war once again. The key issue is Trump's latest tariffs, but the article doesn't specify what numbers are involved. This analysis piece from The Bulwark examines the potential economic consequences for US businesses and consumers as well as the political risks for…

Trump Blows Up His Own Trade Deal with Canada →
UPI24 Aug

US President Donald Trump accused Canada of wanting to reap benefits without being a US state on social media, claiming they had charged American farmers massive amounts of tariffs for years. The statement comes after Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announced Ottawa's plan to impose retaliatory tariffs next month in response to the 50% tariffs imposed by the US. These retaliatory tariffs will target various…

Trump says Canada wants 'benefits of being' a U.S. state in trade war →
Letters from an American25 Aug

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has instructed negotiators to walk away from talks with US officials over new 50% tariffs on $28 billion of Canadian products imposed by the Trump administration. The tariffs were announced in July, and Trump cited Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 as justification, which had never been invoked before by a president. This move has led to criticism from Carney, who called the…

August 24, 2026 →
BBC26 Aug

Canadian Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne announced retaliatory tariffs as high as 50% on $20 billion worth of US goods in response to US tariffs imposed last weekend. The list includes steel, furniture, fresh tuna, and cotton T-shirts, among other products, and will take effect on September 8. Canada's move is seen as a proportionate and strategic response to the US tariffs, which Champagne said would…

Canada announces 'dollar-for-dollar' retaliatory tariffs on US as high as 50% →
Mother Jones26 Aug

Canadian officials announced a $7.5 billion support package to help businesses and workers affected by US tariffs, with measures including non-repayable loans and interest-free loans for small businesses. The package is part of Canada's reciprocal tariff plan, which includes dollar-for-dollar counter-tariffs on US imports valued at roughly $20 billion. According to the article, this approach exceeds any support…

Canada Is Spending Billions to Help Its Workers Survive Our Tariffs →
Los Angeles Times26 Aug

Canada has retaliated against the US by imposing tariffs on $20 billion worth of American goods, including steel, dairy products, and seafood, after President Trump announced 50% tariffs on Canadian goods. The new duties are set to hit a variety of products with tariffs as high as 50%, targeting items commonly found on shopping lists. Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne stated that Canada was forced to take…

Canada retaliates in rapidly escalating U.S. trade war →
The Dispatch26 Aug

The article argues that Trump's trade war with Canada is not about Canada itself, but rather a consequence of the US's geopolitical focus on other countries, particularly Iran. The author suggests that the current situation in Canada is a result of its increased attention from the US. No specific numbers or facts are provided to support this claim, and the article appears to be an opinion piece offering analysis…

Trump’s Trade War With Canada Is Not About Canada →
Al Jazeera27 Aug

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is holding firm in a trade dispute with the US, despite talks breaking down between Washington and Ottawa. No specific numbers are mentioned, but Canada is one of only two countries, along with China, that have retaliated against US tariffs. The article focuses on the potential risks and costs of this standoff for Canada, questioning whether it can afford to push back against the…

How far will the US-Canada trade war go? →
Global News27 Aug

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith rejected calls from the Opposition NDP and former premier Jason Kenney to tax oil exports to the US as a bargaining chip in the trade war between Canada and the US. She warned that such a move would lead to significant job losses and economic harm not just for Alberta, but also for neighboring provinces like Ontario and Quebec. According to provincial statistics, Alberta's oil exports…

Danielle Smith rejects taxing oil exports, pushes increased diplomacy efforts with U.S. →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • Canada is considering retaliatory measures against U.S. goods to counteract the tariffs imposed by President Trump.45
Quoted from the coverage (2)

U.S. President Donald Trump says Canada "wants the benefits" of being a U.S. state "without being one."

5 outlets

Carney said earlier Monday that Canada may need to move away from matching U.S. tariffs dollar for dollar and instead use more targeted retaliation aimed at protecting Canadian workers and businesses.

4 outlets

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The Independent focuses on the personal attack by a Canadian premier against Trump and his predicted electoral defeat, while CBC highlights Trump's accusation that Canada wants U.S. benefits without joining.12
  • ABC News emphasizes the feud between Trump and Ontario Premier Doug Ford over trade issues, whereas The Los Angeles Times frames the event as a rapid escalation in the U.S.-Canada trade war.34
Stated as fact2
The headlines (2)

Vance tells audience at private event that Carney tried to 'out-tough' Trump on trade CBC · stated as fact

Canadian premier brands Trump ‘weak’ and predicts he’ll get ‘slaughtered’ in midterms The Independent · stated as fact

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 54 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly right and hedges 3% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
CBC News
Hedges 4 of 39 claims Outlet record 60/100
CBC News
Hedges 1 of 4 claims Outlet record 72/100
Reason
Leans strongly left further left than this Hedges 0 of 19 claims Outlet record 94/100
The Bulwark
Leans left further left than this Hedges 1 of 6 claims
National Post
Hedges 1 of 48 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Guardian
Leans strongly right Hedges 3 of 28 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBC News
Leans strongly right Hedges 3 of 42 claims Outlet record 72/100
ABC News (US)
Leans strongly right Hedges 1 of 27 claims Outlet record 67/100
August 24, 2026 Same event
Letters from an American
Leans left further left than this Hedges 4 of 73 claims
NBC News
Outlet record 78/100

Story

Canada US Trade Dispute Escalation
Politics · 54 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
39
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
3%
1 of 39 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly right
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
60/100
National Post's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
54
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-08-25 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

National Post · 1242 article(s) · 2 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 2 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Carson Jerema
61 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
If California’s proposed wealth tax is defeated next week — polling now finds Prop. 40 underwater with voters — it will represent less a failure of economic arguments than of political activism given academic gloss.
B.C. Conservative leader Lorne Doerkson will become the 38th premier after leading the party to a triumph in the provincial election.
One can see what they wish in the results, which will not be final until Friday afternoon, when all votes will be tallied.
She told the court she went off social media in the wake of the allegations so that she could focus on her publishing requirements, but that it was “difficult to miss what was going on.”
Indeed, the scale and magnitude of Eby’s misreading of the B.C. electorate in calling his early snap election cannot be understated and it may well be the greatest political blunder in Canadian history.
The Conservatives are projected to win 62 seats to the NDP’s 29 as of 9 p.m. local time.
The destruction we are now seeing in Europe will inevitably become more pervasive until it, too, manifests into violence by way of terrorism, if not armed insurrection.
2026-10-23 · assertive framing · Avi Benlolo: Why Toronto’s mayoralty race matters
The empty chair said more than any speech could.
Sharma refused to issue a ban, which she said would violate the open courtroom principle and was an “extreme measure,” but noted that media present in the courtroom could observe the woman’s request.
Given the riots’ aesthetic and demographic makeup, politicians on the right may feel increasingly emboldened to issue statements of this kind — which reflect the existential tenor with which the unrest has been received among right-wing populists the world over; as well as the enormous stakes voters of all hues will feel going into the presidential elections in April.
Also by Carson Jerema
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 61 articles by Carson Jerema →

Topics

America Canada Canadians Politico U.S.

Subjects

Carney PERSON · 4× U.S. GPE · 4× Canada GPE · 3× Trump PERSON · 3× Canadians NORP · 2× Donald Trump PERSON · 2× Friedman PERSON · 2× America GPE · 1× Mark Carney PERSON · 1× Politico ORG · 1×

Narrative

Or, as the late British economist Joan Robinson wrote, “The popular view that free trade is all very well so long as all nations are free-traders, but that when other nations erect tariffs we must erect tariffs too, is countered by the argument that it would be just as sensible to drop rocks into our harbours because other nations have rocky coasts.”
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-08-25
The next massive blackout may happen because trade barriers raised the cost of preventing it beyond the industry’s ability to afford resilience.
2026-08-25 · National Post
J.D. Tuccille: Canada can win at trade by ignoring Trump · assertive framing

Claims (39 extracted, 1 hedged)

Prime Minister Mark Carney insists Canada is “at war” with the U.S. after trade talks between the two countries fell apart over the weekend. asserted
talks → insist → weekend
But the exchange of talking points instead of bullets is foolish and destructive enough, and evidence of the futility of managing trade rather than simply getting governments out of the way of people freely exchanging goods and services. asserted
people → manage → goods
For his part, U.S. President Donald Trump responded that “Canada wants the benefits of being a State, without being one.” asserted
Canada → respond → benefits
He complained that Canadians have “charged our great farmers, for many years, massive amounts of Tariffs. asserted
Canadians → complain → Tariffs
Amidst recriminations as to who caused the breakdown — Politico reports the talks “ultimately buckled under a combination of last-minute demands and political constraints on both sides” — the two national leaders are threatening new trade barriers in addition to preexisting tariffs. asserted
leaders → cause → tariffs
Pundits and policy experts are digging through such details as have leaked to figure out just where the deal went off the rails. asserted
deal → dig → rails
Strictly speaking, Carney is the more credible figure in the dispute since he’s right that “America has changed” and the U.S. government is trying to “put a series of tariffs on its closest allies and use economic integration as a weapon.” asserted
government → speak → weapon
Trump has been notably belligerent in the process of reshaping trade — as he is in all things — making Carney’s “war” talk somewhat believable. asserted
talk → reshape → things
But the parsing of trade demands and personalities misses a larger point. asserted
parsing → miss → point
While Donald Trump can be a bully and Carney retains his calm while sniffily complaining about insults to the sovereignty of his country, both of them, and their flunkies, have engaged in the presumptuous business of trying to negotiate the rules of exchange between millions of buyers and sellers in two countries. asserted
both → retain → countries
We’d all be far better off if even just one of them stepped aside and let matters work themselves out. asserted
matters → step → themselves
Decades ago, economist Milton Friedman noted that protectionists constantly hand-wave away arguments in favour of free trade as “fine in theory” while insisting that trade must be “reciprocal” — precisely the argument the Trump administration makes as it reworks already rule-burdened trade deals. asserted
it → note → deals
At a time when Japan was the feared economic behemoth that was supposedly going to eat the world, Friedman warned that tariffs “raise prices to customers and waste our resources.” asserted
tariffs → fear → resources
He argued that when the governments of other countries shield their markets from competition, instead of benefiting their economies they hurt their people and businesses. asserted
they → argue → people
“The wise course for us is precisely the opposite — to move unilaterally toward free trade. asserted
course → move → trade
If they still choose to impose restrictions, that is too bad but at least we have not added insult to injury.” asserted
we → choose → injury
Evidence for Friedman’s position is found in a recent New York Times article about the vulnerability of electricity grids, largely because of their dependence on expensive, hand-crafted power transformers that are difficult to replace. asserted
that → find → transformers
While U.S. companies are building manufacturing facilities and developing alternative transformer technologies, they’re hampered by tariffs on copper and aluminum. asserted
they → build → copper
“Costs are up almost 20 percent,” an industry executive told the Times. asserted
executive → tell → Times
“We need relief on all of the metals.” asserted
We → need → metals
The next massive blackout may happen because trade barriers raised the cost of preventing it beyond the industry’s ability to afford resilience. uncertain
barriers → happen → resilience
Just because Trump is an economic ignoramus who thinks economic activity can be successfully managed by government, despite a long history of evidence to the contrary, doesn’t mean that Carney should follow his example and contribute to the conflict. asserted
Carney → think → conflict
Quebec-born Vincent Geloso, an economics professor at Virginia’s George Mason University, argues that “Canada’s response to American tariffs should be incredibly simple: slash our own tariffs and trade barriers. asserted
response → bear → tariffs
He makes the same argument offered by Friedman, that tariffs hurt consumers and businesses in the countries that impose them. asserted
that → make → them
“How exactly does making Canadians poorer punish Donald Trump? asserted
Canadians → make → Trump
If the Trump admin wants to shoot itself in the foot, the Carney government is under no obligation to shoot Canadians in the face with a twelve gauge shotgun for the sake of ‘reciprocity.’” asserted
government → want → reciprocity
Or, as the late British economist Joan Robinson wrote, “The popular view that free trade is all very well so long as all nations are free-traders, but that when other nations erect tariffs we must erect tariffs too, is countered by the argument that it would be just as sensible to drop rocks into our harbours because other nations have rocky coasts.” asserted
nations → write → coasts
In a 2025 paper, Geloso pointed out that Britain benefited from repealing “Corn Law” tariffs on imported grain. asserted
Britain → point → grain
“The Corn Laws had the effect of keeping food prices in the UK 9% higher relative to world markets. asserted
Laws → have → markets
He added that most 19th century trade liberalization was unilateral, with no expectation that other nations would necessarily reciprocate. asserted
nations → add → expectation
Liberalizing nations quickly prospered. asserted
Liberalizing → liberalize → nations
Yes, it’s better when all governments get out of the way and let people and businesses exercise their right to engage in voluntary exchange without regard to borders. asserted
people → ’ → borders
But holding trade hostage to the intelligence, decency, and economic wisdom of political leaders in multiple countries is a sucker’s bet. asserted
holding → hold → countries
Inevitably, populists with neo-mercantilist ideas arise and burden their own people with tariffs while claiming to help them. asserted
populists → arise → them
In the days to come, people will spend much time digging for and through the details of the failed U.S.-Canada trade talks. asserted
people → come → talks
But that’s a waste of time. asserted
that → ’ → time
The only definition of “fair” that matters is what people voluntarily agree to in their own dealings. asserted
people → matter → dealings
If, under current management, the U.S. won’t embrace free trade policies that make everybody wealthier, Canada should do so on its own. asserted
Canada → embrace → own
Canadians would be freer and more prosperous by avoiding the American mistake of burdening commerce with tariffs and conditions. asserted
Canadians → avoid → tariffs
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support