The words of negotiators and other leaders at the U.N. climate talks illustrate why the meeting failed to reach a final agreement.
asserted
meeting → illustrate → agreement
Each year the annual meeting seeks to hammer out a document known as a cover decision that gives direction on how countries around the world should fight climate change.
asserted
countries → seek → change
But at the meetings in Turkey this time, negotiators could not overcome impasses on whether the final document should mention fossil fuels.
uncertain
document → overcome → fuels
The burning of fuels such as coal, oil and gas is what causes global warming.
asserted
what → cause → warming
After reviewing a draft of the agreement released by co-host Turkey, a number of countries spoke up during the final meeting Sunday to say they couldn’t accept a deal that failed to include wording on fossil fuels.
asserted
that → review → fuels
Others spoke to reporters on the sidelines of the plenary sessions.
asserted
Others → speak → sessions
The co-hosts Turkey and Australia also offered their thoughts.
asserted
hosts → offer → thoughts
Darragh O’Brien, Irish climate minister speaking on behalf of the European Union’s 27 countries:
“I want to clearly state that the European Union and its member states object to this cover decision in both its iterations, and that we’re saying that on behalf of our citizens, our member states, because these decisions go nowhere near the level of action or ambition that are required for us to tackle climate change, it is unconscionable that we would have a climate act that makes no reference to fossil fuel.”
asserted
that → speak → fuel
Ana Aguilar, Panama’s chief climate negotiator and a senior leader in the Climate Change Directorate at Panama’s Ministry of Environment
“Our responsibility is not to negotiate the minimum threshold, our responsibility is to do what is right.
asserted
what → negotiate → threshold
Our responsibility is to protect the planet. ...
asserted
responsibility → protect → planet
President, please allow us to explain briefly why Panama cannot support this decision.
asserted
Panama → allow → decision
One, because it repeats previously agreed to commitments without closing the gap between reality and what science demands.
asserted
science → repeat → what
Two, because it (relies) too much upon technologies such as, CCS capture storage of carbon, instead of calling for deep changes.
asserted
it → rely → changes
And, three, because it weakens language agreed in previous decisions.
asserted
it → weaken → decisions
The Marshall Islands delegation
“We came here expecting the world to deliver a comprehensive and urgent response on reducing emissions, on protecting our people and on providing the finance.
asserted
world → come → finance
To do this, we have been let down on all sides.
asserted
we → do → sides
We were presented with the worst possible response to overshoot.
asserted
We → present → response
A response that will enhance oil and gas.
asserted
that → enhance → oil
We will not be forced to accept false solutions.
asserted
We → force → solutions
We will not compromise our future to benefit fossil fuel interests.
asserted
We → compromise → interests
We will not accept an outcome that undermines our security and threatens our future.”
asserted
that → accept → future
The United Kingdom government
“The United Kingdom does not believe the cover decision proposed by the Presidencies meets the moment.
asserted
decision → believe → moment
We believe it moves us backward on the science when we must accelerate implementation.
asserted
we → believe → implementation
It has compromised where it should have presented bold collective ambition on climate action.”
asserted
it → compromise → action
Steven Victor, Palau’s minister of agriculture, fisheries and environment
“Palau will support this text, not perfect as it is.
asserted
it → support → text
We support this because there’s clean electrification, there’s ocean, there is finance.
asserted
We → support → this
The only thing that we had issues with, and we were willing to engage in trying to improve it, is carbon capture.
asserted
we → have → it
But unfortunately, others all forget about all these other good things and focus on one aspect of the negotiation.”
asserted
others → forget → negotiation
“Although there’s no cover decision, there are these other work programs that got approved today and the last couple of days.
asserted
that → ’ → days
So it’s not a failure.”
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Chris Bowen, COP31’s president of negotiations and minister of climate change and energy for co-host Australia
“Unfortunately, we were unable to reach agreement on a cover decision.
asserted
we → reach → decision
And that’s disappointing, very disappointing.
asserted
that → ’ → ?
Ultimately, looking back, many parties were people of good faith who had very strong red lines on a couple of key issues ...
asserted
who → look → issues
An obvious issue is the transition away from fossil fuels where some parties insisted that it must be mentioned. ...
asserted
it → insist → fuels
It’s happening, it’s happening at speed, and it’s irreversible.”
asserted
it → happen → speed