A large California school district has thumbed its nose at Attorney General Rob Bonta by approving a sweeping policy barring transgender students from girls’ sports teams and restricting their access to bathrooms and locker rooms.
asserted
district → thumb → bathrooms
Chino Valley Unified School District’s board voted 4-1 Thursday to adopt the policy, refusing to heed a letter from the California Department of Justice urging trustees to reject the proposal or delay the vote over concerns that it conflicts with state protections.
asserted
it → vote → protections
The vote came during the final board meeting for outgoing president and former superintendent candidate Sonja Shaw, who spearheaded the proposal and has made restricting transgender participation in girls’ athletics a centerpiece of her conservative education agenda.
asserted
restricting → come → agenda
The Nov. 18 letter, signed by Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent, specifically warned the district’s proposed rules conflict with California Education Code Section 221.5(f), which guarantees students the right to participate in sex-segregated school programs.
asserted
which → sign → programs
But Shaw wasn’t having it.
asserted
Shaw → have → it
“How about no,” Shaw wrote in a post on X directed at Bonta.
asserted
Shaw → write → Bonta
Aren’t you a lawyer or do you just play one on X?
asserted
you → play → X
I will never back down from protecting our daughters.
asserted
I → back → daughters
You picked the wrong fight with this mom.
asserted
You → pick → mom
I will fight until Title IX is followed and our daughters are protected.”
asserted
daughters → fight → ?
Shaw also dramatically ripped up the attorney general’s office letter during Thursday’s meeting, according to reports.
uncertain
Shaw → rip → reports
The newly adopted Board Policy 5145.72, titled Fairness in Girls’ Athletics and Privacy in Sex-Based Facilities, defines sex as a person’s biological sex — male or female — determined by reproductive biology and genetics at birth.
asserted
Policy → adopt → birth
Under the measure, only female students will be eligible for girls’ interscholastic, intramural and club sports teams, regardless of hormone levels, puberty blockers or other medical treatments.
Advertisement
The policy also requires multi-occupancy restrooms, locker rooms, changing areas and showers on district property to be designated exclusively for males or females.
asserted
restrooms → require → males
Students must use facilities corresponding to their sex, while overnight school trips must assign sleeping quarters according to the same classification.
uncertain
trips → use → classification
The restrictions extend beyond athletics, making the district one of the latest California school systems to challenge the state’s protections for transgender students.
asserted
district → extend → students
Advertisement
Shaw defended the restrictions as basic protections for female students, arguing that the measures were necessary to safeguard their privacy and safety.
asserted
measures → defend → privacy
“These are common-sense measures: no boys in girls’ sports, no boys sharing girls’ locker rooms or using their showers, and no boys and girls sharing hotel rooms on school trips.
asserted
These → share → trips
They protect girls’ privacy and safety in the most basic ways,” she said.
asserted
she → protect → ways
The policy does provide alternatives for students seeking additional privacy.
asserted
policy → provide → privacy
Any student can request a single-user restroom, separate changing time or another reasonable accommodation without having to provide a reason.
asserted
student → request → reason
It also allows students who are ineligible for girls’ teams to try out for open or coed teams, where available.
asserted
who → allow → teams
Advertisement
The district says students will not be required to undergo additional medical examinations or inspections to establish their eligibility.
asserted
students → say → eligibility
The proposal further protects students and staff from punishment for declining to compete against or share a multi-occupancy facility with someone of the opposite sex.
asserted
proposal → protect → sex
The board’s lone dissenting vote came from Trustee Andrew Cruz, who had attempted to postpone consideration of the measure so incoming board members could weigh in before it was adopted.
uncertain
it → dissent → measure
Advertisement
Shaw criticized Cruz’s opposition, calling his actions “cowardly.”
The dispute centers on competing interpretations of federal and state law, with the district relying heavily on a recent Supreme Court decision to justify its restrictions.
asserted
district → criticize → restrictions
In its letter, the California DOJ took issue with the district’s interpretation of the high court’s June 30 ruling in West Virginia v. B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox.
asserted
DOJ → take → Hecox
The Supreme Court held that Title IX permits states and schools to restrict girls’ and women’s sports teams to biological females without violating federal law or the Equal Protection Clause.
asserted
IX → hold → law
Advertisement
But the court did not rule that every school district must adopt such restrictions, nor did it decide whether Title IX requires schools to exclude transgender students from girls’ teams.
asserted
IX → rule → teams
Nugent cited that distinction in arguing that the ruling does not invalidate California’s existing protections.
asserted
ruling → cite → protections
He also pointed to the Ninth Circuit’s 2020 decision in Parents for Privacy v. Barr, which found that Title IX permits schools to maintain sex-segregated bathrooms and locker rooms but does not require them to exclude transgender students from facilities consistent with their gender identity.
asserted
IX → point → identity
The DOJ warned that nothing in the Supreme Court’s decision authorized local school boards to disregard those state requirements.
The department urged the district to reject the proposal or, at minimum, postpone the vote to discuss how the new rules could comply with California law.
uncertain
rules → warn → law
The board moved forward anyway.
asserted
board → move → ?
The vote marked the culmination of a yearslong campaign by Shaw, a conservative Republican whose tenure at Chino Valley Unified has been marked by battles over transgender student rights, parental notification policies and restrictions on school library books.
asserted
tenure → mark → books
Advertisement
Shaw was elected to the school board in 2022 and became one of California’s most prominent conservative education activists, building a statewide profile through her opposition to transgender participation in girls’ sports and policies protecting LGBTQ+ students.
She also championed a controversial policy requiring school employees to notify parents when their children expressed a gender identity different from their sex assigned at birth, as well as rules allowing parents to challenge library books they considered sexually explicit.
asserted
they → elect → books
Shaw took that agenda statewide this year, running for California superintendent of public instruction on a platform emphasizing parental rights, traditional academic standards and protecting girls’ sports.
asserted
Shaw → take → sports
In her campaign, she argued that California schools needed to restore academic performance while protecting female athletes and pushing back against what she characterized as political interference in classrooms.
asserted
she → argue → classrooms
She secured the Republican Party’s endorsement and finished first in the June primary with 22.6% of the vote, narrowly ahead of Democrat Richard Barrera, who received 20.3%.
asserted
who → secure → %
But Barrera defeated Shaw in the November general election, winning the superintendent’s race and leaving Shaw without either the statewide office she sought or another term on the Chino Valley school board.
asserted
she → defeat → board
Thursday’s meeting was her final one as board president and her last as an elected district official.
asserted
meeting → elect → official
Despite the defeat, Shaw signaled that her fight over transgender student participation was far from over.
asserted
fight → signal → participation
…and 2 more, not listed.