An illegal immigrant accused of mowing down an 82-year-old grandmother with his SUV in a grocery store parking lot will not see jail time, after prosecutors dropped the criminal case.
asserted
prosecutors → accuse → case
Carlos Suarez-Contreras, 26, was reversing his Toyota 4Runner outside a Publix in Panama City Beach, Florida, when he struck Deborah Murphy as she strolled back to her car with her groceries on May 17.
uncertain
she → reverse → May
The grandmother was knocked to the ground before the SUV continued backwards, crushing her beneath its wheels, according to a Florida Highway Patrol arrest affidavit.
uncertain
SUV → knock → affidavit
Murphy was rushed to hospital suffering catastrophic blunt force injuries but died less than an hour later.
asserted
Murphy → rush → injuries
Now, after almost six months of investigation, State Attorney Larry Basford has confirmed that Suarez-Contreras will not face criminal prosecution over her death, saying investigators could not establish the evidence needed to secure a conviction.
uncertain
investigators → confirm → conviction
‘I think everyone would agree that what he did was careless and it was negligent,’ Basford told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Basford → think → Digital
‘But not every tragedy amounts to a crime.’
asserted
tragedy → amount → crime
The decision has left Murphy’s daughters, Amy Edge and her twin sister Beth Schulz, reeling and demanding answers from the prosecutors who initially appeared confident they could bring multiple charges against the driver.
uncertain
they → leave → driver
‘We feel incredibly let down by the state of Florida, who vowed to seek justice on her behalf,’ Edge told the Daily Mail.
asserted
Edge → let → Mail
Calling it 'gut-wrenching,' she added ‘It’s like experiencing the loss all over again.’
asserted
It → call → loss
The driver, Carlos Suarez-Contreras, a 26-year-old from Venezuela who was in the United States illegally, will not see jail time, despite driving the vehicle that rammed into Deborah Murphy,82, with a canceled Georgia license
On May 17, Murphy walked back to her car carrying a bag after a brief stop at Publix in Panama City Beach.
uncertain
Murphy → see → Beach
Surveillance video shows her striding through the crosswalk toward her car, when she was struck by Suarez-Contreras's car, moving in reverse
Chilling footage released by Florida Highway Patrol troopers captured the moments leading up to the crash, showing Murphy walking out of the store with grocery bags
Suarez-Contreras was initially arrested and charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death, a third-degree felony.
asserted
Contreras → show → felony
He was driving with a Georgia license that had been canceled just one day before the fatal collision.
asserted
that → drive → collision
He was held without bond because of his immigration status and concerns that he could be a flight risk.
uncertain
he → hold → status
But prosecutors said they faced a significant obstacle in proving he knew his license had been canceled.
asserted
license → say → obstacle
‘Under the law, we have to prove that the individual knew his license was suspended,’ Basford explained.
asserted
Basford → have → law
The Georgia Department of Driver Services confirmed the cancellation but declined to disclose when Suarez-Contreras had been notified.
asserted
Contreras → confirm → cancellation
Prosecutors also considered bringing vehicular homicide and manslaughter charges, but concluded they could not establish the culpable negligence required under Florida law.
uncertain
they → consider → law
Investigators reviewed the supermarket’s surveillance footage and reconstructed the collision to assess how the SUV was being driven.
asserted
SUV → review → collision
They ultimately determined that it was not reversing quickly enough to establish the recklessness necessary for a vehicular homicide prosecution.
asserted
it → determine → prosecution
A Florida law passed in 2023, which invalidates certain out-of-state licenses issued to undocumented immigrants, could not be applied because Georgia was not among the states covered by the legislation.
uncertain
Georgia → pass → legislation
The SUV knocked Murphy to the ground before continuing in reverse and running her over, according to an arrest affidavit
Murphy was rushed to the hospital, where she died from catastrophic injuries a short time later
Murphy’s daughters have challenged the investigation, incredulous as to why Suarez-Contreras was not tested for drugs or alcohol and why investigators did not examine his cellphone records.
They also dispute the conclusions drawn from the crash reconstruction.
uncertain
They → knock → reconstruction
‘We know the man killed her,’ Edge said.
asserted
Edge → know → her
‘He never got out of the car.
asserted
He → get → car
He never ran to her aid.
asserted
He → run → aid
He never stopped.
asserted
He → stop → ?
He wasn’t reversing from a spot.
asserted
He → reverse → spot
He drove backwards.’
asserted
He → drive → ?
The sisters said they had initially been led to believe prosecutors were confident they could secure multiple charges against the driver.
uncertain
they → say → driver
They now question how the case went from an apparently strong prosecution to no criminal trial at all.
asserted
case → question → trial
Murphy had been in excellent health and, her daughters said, had many more years ahead of her.
asserted
daughters → say → her
A devoted mother, grandmother and former early childhood special education teacher, she was remembered as a vibrant woman whose life revolved around her family and faith.
asserted
life → remember → family
She will never watch her grandchildren get married or meet the great-grandchildren who might otherwise have been part of her future.
uncertain
who → watch → future
‘That’s been taken away,’ Edge said.
asserted
Edge → take → ?
Murphy is survived by her husband, retired Air Force Colonel George Murphy, her two daughters, six grandchildren and one great-grandchild, as well as a large extended family.
asserted
Murphy → survive → husband
Her daughters have launched a petition urging Basford to reconsider his decision and are exploring changes to Florida law and the way fatal traffic collisions are investigated.
asserted
collisions → launch → law
The front seat passenger, Luis Sanabria, 29, who is also a illegal immigrant from Venezuela, according to officials, was found to have an expired visa, according to an incident report, and was later released into ICE custody
The SUV’s passenger, Luis Sanabria, 29, was also identified as a Venezuelan national.
uncertain
passenger → accord → national
An incident report stated that his visa had expired and that he initially fled the scene before returning and identifying Suarez-Contreras as the driver in sworn testimony.
asserted
he → state → testimony
Sanabria was subsequently released into the custody of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
asserted
Sanabria → release → Immigration
Suarez-Contreras was transferred into ICE custody on November 15, according to the Bay County Jail.
uncertain
Contreras → transfer → Jail
…and 8 more, not listed.