A dispute between four brothers over a jointly operated family farm in New York has ended with an appeals court refusing to grant three of them a separate route through land assigned to their sibling.
asserted
court → operate → sibling
The brothers had sought permission to cross part of the property to reach a gravel pit and timber areas.
asserted
brothers → seek → pit
However, the court found that they had not shown why their existing access from public roads was insufficient.
asserted
access → find → roads
The
ruling also settled a separate disagreement over an old Chevrolet vehicle included in the family's property settlement.
asserted
ruling → The → settlement
The court upheld the decision to give the 1988 Chevrolet Suburban to Leo D. Starowitz Jr., rejecting his three brothers' challenge.
asserted
court → uphold → challenge
The case arose after the brothers' shared farming business fell apart following disagreements.
asserted
business → arise → disagreements
Leo, along with Andrew M. Starowitz, Frank L. Starowitz and John F. Starowitz, had jointly operated the family farm through three business entities: Star Growers Farm LLC, Star Growers Land LLC and Star Growers Inc.
asserted
Leo → operate → entities
Each brother owned an equal 25% share in the three entities.
asserted
brother → own → entities
Their land and farming equipment were previously held and used collectively for the business.
asserted
land → hold → business
The properties included an area known as Chapel Farm.
asserted
properties → include → Farm
The breakdown in their relationship eventually led Leo to seek the dissolution of the three companies through court proceedings.
asserted
breakdown → lead → proceedings
The brothers reached a settlement in November 2023, but disagreements over the distribution and use of property continued.
asserted
disagreements → reach → property
These included a dispute over access to certain parts of Chapel Farm and the allocation of vehicles.
asserted
These → include → vehicles
Why three brothers wanted another route
Andrew, Frank and John wanted a legal right to cross land allocated to Leo.
asserted
Andrew → want → Leo
Their proposed route followed an old hedgerow running through the middle of his designated farmland.
asserted
route → propose → farmland
They said this would make it easier to reach parts of their own non-tillable land, which included a gravel pit and areas used for timber.
asserted
which → say → timber
The brothers argued that the route they proposed was more practical than the alternative available to them.
asserted
they → argue → them
Their land already had a narrow strip touching the junction of two public roads.
asserted
land → have → roads
However, reaching the gravel pit and timber sections from this point would involve crossing wetlands.
asserted
reaching → reach → wetlands
The brothers considered that option difficult to use, particularly for moving heavy machinery.
asserted
option → consider → machinery
They therefore wanted the court to allow them to use the route across Leo's property instead.
asserted
them → want → property
The request was based on a legal provision known as an easement by necessity.
asserted
request → base → necessity
It allows a landowner to seek access across neighbouring property when such access is essential for the reasonable use of their own land.
asserted
access → allow → land
But the existence of a more convenient route does not automatically create this legal right.
asserted
existence → create → right
The person seeking an easement must demonstrate that the alternative access is genuinely inadequate and that crossing the neighbouring property is necessary.
asserted
crossing → seek → property
Court finds brothers failed to establish necessity
The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Fourth Department, examined whether the brothers had established that they could not reasonably reach their land without crossing Leo's property.
uncertain
they → find → property
The judges considered the fact that the brothers had access to two public roads.
asserted
brothers → consider → roads
They also examined whether the wetlands made that access unusable.
asserted
access → examine → ?
The brothers had approached the issue of obtaining permission from the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) to take heavy equipment across the wetlands.
asserted
brothers → approach → wetlands
However, their submissions did not establish that the department would definitely refuse such permission.
asserted
department → establish → permission
The appeals court also noted that the department's assessment appeared to have considered the possibility of using the alternative route through Leo's land.
asserted
assessment → note → land
This left an important question unanswered: could the brothers use their existing road-facing land to reach the productive sections of their property?
uncertain
brothers → leave → property
The court found that they had not provided convincing evidence to rule out that possibility.
asserted
they → find → possibility
They had not established that crossing the wetlands was impossible or that permission for such access could not be obtained.
uncertain
permission → establish → access
The judges consequently found that the route through Leo's land was a more convenient option, rather than an essential one.
asserted
route → find → one
The court also considered the legal requirement that the need for an easement must be assessed based on the circumstances when the common property was divided.
asserted
property → consider → circumstances
Even assuming that the brothers had established the earlier common ownership and subsequent separation of the land, the evidence did not prove that the additional access was indispensable.
asserted
access → assume → land
Their request for an easement by necessity was therefore rejected.
asserted
request → reject → necessity
Disagreement over old Chevrolet vehicle
The brothers also challenged the lower court's decision to award Leo a 1988 Chevrolet Suburban.
asserted
brothers → challenge → Suburban
They argued that there was insufficient evidence to establish that he was entitled to that particular vehicle.
asserted
he → argue → vehicle
…and 7 more, not listed.