A former interim police chief in Oregon has been awarded $935,000 after a federal jury found that the city and three officials retaliated against him for exercising his First Amendment rights following a dispute over the appointment of a permanent police chief, KPTV reported.
asserted
KPTV → award → chief
Sean Lundry, who served with the Sandy Police Department, was passed over for the top position in January 2024 before being placed on administrative leave, investigated and dismissed later that year.
asserted
who → serve → leave
He argued that city officials targeted him after he questioned the recruitment process and publicly criticised the leadership.
asserted
he → argue → leadership
The jury delivered its verdict on Friday, finding the city of Sandy, City Manager Tyler Deems, Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati and former Mayor Stan Pulliam liable for First Amendment retaliation, according to KPTV.
uncertain
city → deliver → KPTV
The compensation included $850,000 in economic damages, while the jury awarded punitive damages of $25,000 against Deems, $10,000 against Aprati and $50,000 against Pulliam.
asserted
jury → include → Pulliam
Jurors did not award any noneconomic damages.
asserted
Jurors → award → damages
The jury rejected two of his due process claims and a separate claim involving retaliation under Oregon's whistleblower law.
uncertain
jury → reject → law
It also left a wrongful discharge question unanswered under the instructions provided on the verdict form.
asserted
It → leave → form
Who is Sean Lundry and why was he fired?
asserted
he → fire → ?
Lundry joined the Sandy Police Department in 2015 and was serving as interim police chief when he applied to lead the department permanently.
asserted
he → join → department
In January 2024, the city informed him that it had selected another applicant, Gary Jensen, subject to a background check.
asserted
it → inform → check
The appointment decision prompted questions about how the recruitment had been conducted.
asserted
recruitment → prompt → questions
According to facts agreed upon by both parties before the trial, Lundry encouraged people to submit public records requests and raise concerns with city officials about the selection process.
uncertain
Lundry → accord → process
The city had initially declined to release comment cards used during the recruitment exercise.
asserted
city → decline → exercise
Those records were eventually made public after the Clackamas County District Attorney's Office instructed officials to disclose them.
asserted
Office → make → them
Lundry also questioned the use of approximately $30,000 from the police department's budget to pay a consultant involved in the hiring process.
asserted
Lundry → question → process
The city disputed claims that the expenditure was improper.
uncertain
expenditure → dispute → claims
His criticism extended to social media.
asserted
criticism → extend → media
In a Facebook post cited in his lawsuit, Lundry said he would never accept the permanent chief's position “with the current mayor, council, and appointed leadership”.
asserted
he → cite → mayor
His legal team argued that his public comments and involvement in the records requests amounted to protected speech under the First Amendment.
asserted
comments → argue → Amendment
Investigation preceded his dismissal from the department
On February 23, 2024, Deems placed Lundry on paid administrative leave and referred to an allegation that he had destroyed public records for a criminal investigation.
asserted
he → precede → investigation
The accusation originated from an anonymous comment card submitted during the police chief recruitment process.
asserted
accusation → originate → process
Oregon State Police examined the allegation.
asserted
Police → examine → allegation
According to the parties' pretrial agreement, the Clackamas County District Attorney's Office concluded on April 15 that there was no evidence Lundry had unlawfully destroyed public records.
uncertain
Lundry → accord → records
The city also launched an internal investigation into the records allegation and separate complaints involving alleged bullying, harassment and workplace threats.
asserted
city → launch → bullying
Deems informed Lundry on May 22 that the investigation had produced findings and that the city intended to terminate his employment.
uncertain
city → inform → employment
A formal dismissal notice followed in June 2024.
asserted
notice → follow → June
Lundry's lawsuit argued that the reasons given for his removal were “purely pretextual” and that officials had attempted to undermine his credibility.
asserted
officials → argue → credibility
Sandy officials rejected the accusation, maintaining that the dismissal was based on workplace conduct rather than his criticism of the hiring process.
asserted
dismissal → reject → process
In its trial memorandum, the city's legal team accused Lundry of intimidating subordinates and disrupting the department.
asserted
team → accuse → department
It also argued that his comments concerned an employment dispute rather than an issue of public interest protected by the First Amendment.
asserted
comments → argue → Amendment
The city raised another issue during the proceedings involving a recording Lundry had made of an in-person conversation with Deems without the city manager's knowledge.
asserted
Lundry → raise → knowledge
Officials said they would have dismissed him had they known about the recording while he was still employed.
asserted
he → say → recording
However, both sides agreed that the city discovered it during the lawsuit, after Lundry had already been fired.
asserted
Lundry → agree → lawsuit
Following the verdict, Lundry's attorney Chris Heywood said the outcome represented a significant result because the case had centred on the former police chief's right to speak out.
asserted
case → follow → right
“This was always a free speech case to us, and we presented it that way,” Heywood said, according to KPTV.
uncertain
Heywood → present → KPTV
“So prevailing on claim three, the free speech claim, is a terrific outcome.”
uncertain
prevailing → prevail → claim
Heywood also described the decision as a vindication for his client, saying Lundry had consistently maintained that the city removed him because of his actions involving protected speech.
asserted
city → describe → speech
“He'll never get his life back.
asserted
He → get → life
He'll never get his career back,” the attorney said.
asserted
attorney → get → career