- Sign up for DC Insider - delivering the hottest dish in DC every Thursday
Young MAGA supporters have turned on President Donald Trump after accusing him of betraying the America First movement, with some even becoming first-time Democratic voters or just choosing to sit on their hands.
asserted
some → sign → hands
Members of the Clemson College Republicans in South Carolina told New York Magazine they were so disgusted with the Republican Party that they were willing to cross party lines or stay home this midterm election rather than support candidates backed by Trump.
asserted
they → tell → Trump
Steven Pittman, 25, said he had never voted for candidates from different parties before but was so disillusioned that he cast his ballot for Democrat Annie Andrews in the Senate race and Republican Alan Wilson for governor.
asserted
he → say → governor
Both candidates won.
asserted
candidates → win → ?
'I was never someone who would vote split ticket ever in my entire life and then these past midterms I was just so disgusted,' he said.
asserted
he → vote → life
Other students said they would also have voted for Andrews had they been eligible to vote in South Carolina.
asserted
they → say → Carolina
Jackson Heaberlin, a former member of the club, delivered one of the harshest assessments of the party, saying Trump's endorsement of Darline Graham had helped convince young Republicans that the GOP was beyond saving.
asserted
GOP → deliver → saving
Members of the Clemson College Republicans in South Carolina told New York Magazine they were so disgusted with the Republican Party that they were willing to cross party lines or stay home rather than support candidates backed by Trump
'
asserted
they → tell → Trump
When Darline Graham won her primary, it felt as though the GOP — they were like your evil father,' one student said
The students' frustration extended to Vice President JD Vance, who blamed the party's midterm performance on the Iran war
'When Darline Graham won her primary, it felt as though the GOP — they were like your evil father,' Heaberlin said.
asserted
Heaberlin → win → father
Heaberlin mocked the party as being stuck in 'boomerworld,' where Trump's word was final and Republicans could put forward 'the worst candidate ever' without facing any real challenge.
uncertain
Republicans → mock → challenge
The students' anger was not driven by a newfound enthusiasm for Democrats or their policies.
asserted
anger → drive → Democrats
They described their votes as a way to punish Republicans for abandoning the movement they believed they had supported in 2024.
asserted
they → describe → 2024
Club co-chair Jane Kihne, 22, who interned at the White House last summer, said the result was deliberate.
asserted
result → intern → House
'It was literally to punish the GOP,' she said.
asserted
she → punish → GOP
Their biggest grievance was Trump's decision to go to war with Iran, which they viewed as a betrayal of his promise to keep America out of foreign conflicts.
asserted
they → go → conflicts
They believed the president had abandoned the anti-war message that helped build his America First coalition and had returned to the kind of foreign policy associated with the Republican establishment.
asserted
that → believe → establishment
Their biggest grievance was Trump's decision to go to war with Iran, which they viewed as a betrayal of his promise to keep America out of foreign conflicts
The students were also furious that Trump had not gone far enough on immigration.
asserted
Trump → go → immigration
Rather than believing his deportation campaign had been too aggressive, they argued that it had fallen far short of what they were promised
One student did, however, welcome Trump's decision to replace outgoing chief of staff Susie Wiles with hard-line immigration adviser Stephen Miller, describing the appointment as 'definitely a step in the right direction'
The students were also furious that Trump had not gone far enough on immigration.
Rather than believing his deportation campaign had been too aggressive, they argued that it had fallen far short of what they were promised.
They wanted mass deportations on a much larger scale and more action against companies hiring undocumented immigrants.
asserted
They → believe → immigrants
Kihne dismissed highly publicized immigration raids as 'smoke-and-mirrors' and argued that the administration should have taken the fight directly to corporations.
asserted
administration → dismiss → corporations
She called immigration the GOP's 'one winning issue.'
Emerson Cooke, another club member, said the group had wanted at least 10 million deportations.
asserted
group → call → deportations
They were also opposed to the H-1B visa program, arguing that foreign workers were taking jobs that should be available to young Americans.
asserted
that → argue → Americans
The students' frustration extended to Vice President JD Vance, who blamed the party's midterm performance on the Iran war.
asserted
who → extend → war
Pittman questioned why Vance had not challenged Trump before the election, arguing that the vice president had stayed silent rather than standing up for the movement's anti-war promises.
asserted
president → question → promises
Another student dismissed Vance as a 'Peter Thiel acolyte,' before Pittman delivered an even more cutting assessment.
'He's a skin suit,' he said.
asserted
he → dismiss → assessment
The criticism comes as Vance is widely viewed as a potential heir to Trump's political movement, but the students appeared unconvinced that he could carry it forward.
uncertain
he → come → it
Despite their anger at the president, the group was not calling for a move toward the Democratic Party.
asserted
group → call → Party
They remained hostile to many of its positions and saw their votes as a protest against Republicans rather than an endorsement of the opposition.
asserted
They → remain → opposition
Kihne did, however, welcome Trump's decision to replace outgoing chief of staff Susie Wiles with hard-line immigration adviser Stephen Miller, describing the appointment as 'definitely a step in the right direction.'
The episode highlights the challenge facing Republicans as they try to hold on to younger voters who were drawn to Trump's promises to put America first, crack down on immigration and avoid foreign wars.
For the Clemson students, the problem was not that Trump had gone too far.
asserted
Trump → welcome → students
They believe he failed to deliver on the promises that brought them into the movement in the first place.
asserted
that → believe → place
An October Harvard Youth Poll found that young Republicans were significantly less enthusiastic about voting in November's midterms.
asserted
Republicans → find → midterms
The survey found that 50 percent of young Republicans who identified as MAGA were certain to vote, compared with just 29 percent of non-MAGA Republicans.
asserted
who → find → Republicans
But 63 percent of young likely voters said their congressional vote would be a way to oppose President Donald Trump and his policies, while just 14 percent said they would be voting in support of him.
asserted
they → say → him