A man with paranoid schizophrenia who killed three people while experiencing a psychotic episode had been released from custody after a “catalogue of failures” by police and medical professionals, an investigation has found.
asserted
investigation → kill → police
Alexander Lewis-Ranwell was arrested and released twice by police in the 48 hours before he killed Anthony Payne, 80, and the twin brothers Roger and Dick Carter, 84, in their homes in Exeter in 2019.
asserted
he → arrest → 2019
Officers were found to have ignored warnings from a national database as well as a mental health assessor, according to a joint investigation by the Sunday Times and BBC Radio 4’s File On 4 Investigates.
uncertain
Officers → find → Investigates
Numerous failings were found in hours of police video, detention logs and witness testimony.
asserted
failings → find → video
The medical professional who was sent to examine Lewis-Ranwell, 27, did not have expertise in mental health and dismissed his unpredictable behaviour.
There were also failures to record and share key details that would have built up a picture of the severity of Lewis-Ranwell’s mental illness.
asserted
that → send → illness
Officers did not know that by law they had the power to detain him under the Mental Health Act without a medical assessment.
asserted
they → know → assessment
Warnings from Lewis-Ranwell’s mother, that he was having a psychotic episode and should be kept in custody, were also ignored.
asserted
he → have → custody
The families of the three men have called on the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) to open an investigation into Devon and Cornwall police, but they are still waiting for answers and an apology.
asserted
they → call → answers
The watchdog has said that the force should investigate itself, but they have heard nothing for two years.
asserted
they → say → years
Two days before the murders took place, Lewis-Ranwell was arrested after breaking into a farm.
asserted
Ranwell → take → farm
After his release he was arrested a second time for attacking a farmer with a 1.2-metre (4ft) logging saw.
asserted
he → arrest → saw
Despite exhibiting disturbing behaviour in custody – police bodycam footage shows him semi-naked, hissing, spitting and punching at the hatch window to his cell, while ranting about paedophiles and seeing animals – he was released again.
asserted
he → exhibit → animals
Following a rampage that lasted hours and in which he threatened multiple people, he killed the three men, bludgeoning Payne with a hammer and killing the twins with a spade.
asserted
he → follow → spade
A trial at Exeter crown court in December 2019 found Lewis-Ranwell not guilty by reason of insanity.
asserted
Ranwell → find → insanity
He was given a hospital restriction order, where he will stay until agencies are confident he could be released back into the community.
uncertain
he → give → community
One psychiatrist who studied the case told the court he believed Lewis-Ranwell, a former public schoolboy from Croyde, north Devon, was “one of the illest people” he had come across.
asserted
he → study → people
Last month an inquest found failings by police led to his release after a doctor missed “clear signs of delusion and disordered thinking”.
asserted
doctor → find → delusion
Amanda Taylor told the Sunday Times that her family was still seeking justice for her uncles the Carter brothers and that they want the IOPC to revisit the case.
asserted
IOPC → tell → case
“All I want is for just one of the agencies involved to stand up and say: ‘We are so sorry.
asserted
We → want → agencies
Serious mistakes were made.
asserted
mistakes → make → ?
We recognise the devastating consequences of those failures and we will do everything in our power to make sure this never happens again,’” she said.
asserted
she → recognise → power
Lewis-Ranwell’s case is one of several where failures from the police and mental health services to manage risk have resulted in tragedy.
asserted
failures → manage → tragedy
A review by the Care Quality Commission of the treatment of Valdo Calocane, who has paranoid schizophrenia and killed three people in Nottingham in 2023, concluded that a “series of errors and misjudgments” led to him being discharged, despite repeatedly not taking medication and showing signs of aggression.
asserted
him → have → aggression
The report concluded that there are “systemic issues with community mental health care which, without immediate action, will continue to pose an inherent risk to patient and public safety”.
asserted
which → conclude → safety
NHS England has since strengthened guidance around community mental health support for people with severe mental illnesses who face high risk or struggle to engage with services.
asserted
who → strengthen → services
Noting that there are an estimated 100 to 120 mental health-related killings in the UK every year, Julian Hendy, of the victims’ charity Hundred Families, said: “In my view, had the lessons in the Lewis-Ranwell case been learnt earlier, and effective action taken, there is a real chance that the Nottingham attacks could well have been prevented.
uncertain
attacks → note → case
Services aren’t learning and totally innocent people are losing their lives as a result.”
asserted
people → learn → result
A police spokesperson said the force was addressing “areas of learning” and would reflect on the recommendations of the inquest jury, adding: “Our thoughts, as always, remain with the loved ones of Anthony Payne and Dick and Roger Carter.”
The IOPC said the family had a right to ask for a review of the internal investigation and that it had not yet received a request.
asserted
it → say → request