The Trump administration has made fighting fraud and rooting out government waste a top priority, even offering cash rewards to Americans who expose wrongdoing.
asserted
who → make → wrongdoing
Yet investors in a failed Obama-era solar plant are questioning why Trump's own Justice Department is fighting to squash their fraud lawsuit over a $275 million federal grant — a case they say could recover up to $1 billion for taxpayers.
uncertain
they → fail → taxpayers
The investors allege that companies tied to Spanish construction giant ACS misled federal officials into approving the grant by claiming the troubled solar plant was ready for use, even though it had suffered major construction problems and was shut down for months following a molten-salt-tank failure.
asserted
it → allege → failure
The lawsuit centers on the beleaguered Crescent Dunes solar plant, a billion-dollar, government-backed project that began operating in Nevada in 2015 but was later plagued by engineering failures, repeated shutdowns and two bankruptcies before being sold for just $7 million in July.
asserted
that → center → July
The plant was built around an emerging solar technology that used thousands of mirrors to concentrate sunlight onto a towering receiver, heating molten salt that could be stored and used to generate electricity even after sunset.
uncertain
that → build → sunset
In 2020, a group of private investors who had put $90 million into the project and suffered substantial losses filed a whistleblower lawsuit, alleging the companies had misled the federal government to secure the enormous grant.
asserted
companies → put → grant
But in November 2024, just two days after Trump's reelection, Biden's Justice Department moved to shut down the lawsuit, arguing that pursuing the case would burden federal agencies.
asserted
pursuing → move → agencies
The incoming Trump administration could have reconsidered that position in early 2025.
uncertain
administration → reconsider → 2025
Instead, its Justice Department defended the Biden-era dismissal in an April filing with a federal appeals court.
asserted
Department → defend → court
CMB, an investment group headed by Pat Hogan, is appealing the dismissal.
asserted
CMB → head → dismissal
Hogan is also urging Trump’s Justice Department to ask the court to reopen the case.
asserted
Hogan → urge → case
"It makes no sense," Hogan told Fox News Digital in a video interview.
asserted
Hogan → make → interview
Hogan said he had contacted Trump's Justice Department seeking help reviving the case but had received no commitment.
asserted
he → say → commitment
"The real problem here is, why isn't the government asking for this?" he said.
asserted
he → ask → this
"All in all, I would say this has just been a fleecing of the federal government by a foreign entity.
asserted
this → say → entity
And we have the opportunity to fix it, and they're doing nothing.
asserted
they → have → nothing
Hogan argues that allowing the lawsuit to proceed could potentially net hundreds of millions of dollars for taxpayers.
uncertain
lawsuit → argue → taxpayers
Under the False Claims Act, which CMB used to bring its lawsuit, companies found liable can face damages of up to three times the government's proven losses, plus additional penalties.
uncertain
companies → use → losses
"This could be a billion dollars," Hogan said.
uncertain
Hogan → say → ?
Tonopah Solar Energy, the plant's former owner and one of the defendants, has rejected CMB's allegations as baseless in court filings.
asserted
Energy → reject → filings
Other companies named in the lawsuit have also backed the Justice Department's effort to dismiss the case.
asserted
companies → name → case
In an April 2026 court filing, Trump's Justice Department defended the Biden administration's decision, making the same argument that continuing the lawsuit would drain government resources and that federal law gave it broad authority to shut down the case.
asserted
law → defend → case
In court filings reviewed by Fox News Digital, neither administration put a dollar figure on the cost of continuing the lawsuit.
asserted
administration → review → lawsuit
The decision has left Hogan and his investors questioning why the government shut down the case — and what Treasury officials knew about the plant's serious problems when they approved the $275 million grant.
asserted
they → leave → grant
What CMB alleges happened
At the heart of the lawsuit is a dispute over whether Crescent Dunes was properly completed — and whether its owner, Tonopah Solar Energy, was entitled to collect the $275 million Treasury grant.
asserted
owner → allege → grant
The grant was part of a $26 billion program within the Obama administration's broader $90 billion green-energy push, launched under the 2009 economic stimulus package to create jobs and turbocharge its green energy agenda.
asserted
grant → launch → agenda
Known as Section 1603, the program paid developers about 30% of their qualifying construction costs once their facilities were "placed in service" — meaning ready and available for their intended use.
asserted
facilities → know → use
Treasury considered several factors in determining whether a plant met that standard, including whether it had passed critical tests, begun generating electricity and come under its owner's control.
asserted
it → consider → control
Crescent Dunes began generating electricity in 2015, but CMB alleges it had produced no more than 32% of its expected output through June 2016.
asserted
it → begin → June
Then, in October 2016, a failure involving the plant's hot molten-salt storage tank shut it down for months.
asserted
failure → involve → months
In December, while Crescent Dunes was still shut down, its builder, Cobra Thermosolar Plants, formally handed the plant over to its owner, Tonopah Solar Energy, under an arrangement known as "provisional acceptance."
asserted
builder → shut → acceptance
But first, they changed the construction contract to allow the handover despite major defects and unfinished repairs.
asserted
they → change → defects
That agreement came just days before the year-end deadline for solar plants to be ready for use to qualify for the Treasury grants.
asserted
plants → come → grants
In a later court filing, CMB alleged that more than 9,000 defects had been identified and grouped into roughly 500 outstanding construction items, including seven major deficiencies.
asserted
defects → allege → deficiencies
The investors argue the problems showed the plant was not ready to be handed over.
asserted
plant → argue → ?
The December agreement itself acknowledged that repairs to the failed hot molten-salt storage tank were still needed.
asserted
repairs → acknowledge → tank
The tank was central to the plant's operation, storing heat from the sun so electricity could be generated even after sunset.
uncertain
electricity → store → sunset
CMB alleges the companies used the revised agreement to make Crescent Dunes appear ready for use and secure the Treasury grant, even though major problems remained unresolved.
asserted
problems → allege → grant
What Washington knew - and when
Records reviewed by Fox News Digital show Treasury had questioned whether Crescent Dunes was ready for use months before approving the grant payment.
asserted
Dunes → know → payment
In September 2016, Treasury questioned a claim by Tonopah Solar Energy that Crescent Dunes had been ready for use since February of that year.
uncertain
Dunes → question → year
…and 73 more, not listed.