They had jokingly called it 'The Cave of Death' as they made their way to the Y Mountain outside Provo in Utah for a late-night adventure.
asserted
they → call → adventure
Jennifer Lynn Galbraith, 21, her boyfriend J. Blake Donner, 24, Scott McDonald, 28, Ariel Singer, 18 and Joseph Ferguson, 26, had set off in the middle of the night to explore a small underground crevice.
asserted
Galbraith → set → crevice
Laughing and joking along the way, the group of friends had no reason to think the adventure would be anything other than another story to tell afterwards.
asserted
adventure → laugh → story
But by the following morning, four of the five friends would be missing, sparking a desperate search to find them.
asserted
four → follow → them
They arrived at the cave also known as Gollum Cave in the early hours of August 18, 2005, but they were far from prepared for the risky expedition.
asserted
they → arrive → expedition
At around 4.30am, four of the friends began crawling into the cave, while Joseph chose to stay behind.
asserted
Joseph → begin → cave
But unbeknownst to him, it would be the last time he would ever see his friends again.
asserted
he → see → friends
The narrow crevice was about to become a fatal trap.
asserted
crevice → become → ?
A rescuer climbs out of the mouth of a small cave in Utah where four friends were found dead
asserted
friends → climb → Utah
Dressed in shorts and sandals, and with only one flashlight between them, Jennifer, Blake, Scott and Ariel squeezed through the narrow entrance before following a wet passage that stretched around 50ft into the cave.
asserted
that → dress → cave
Eventually, they reached a cavern containing a pool of water, beneath which lay a narrow tunnel leading to a second chamber.
asserted
tunnel → reach → chamber
To get through, the four friends had to pull themselves along a submerged passage measuring roughly 15ft long and barely 20 inches wide.
asserted
friends → get → passage
One by one, they swam through the underwater tunnel and reached an air pocket on the other side.
But they would never make it back out.
asserted
they → swim → it
What happened next remains unclear, but rescuers believe the group ran into trouble when they attempted to navigate the submerged passage again to return to the first cavern.
uncertain
they → happen → cavern
The conditions inside the cave made an already dangerous situation even more treacherous.
asserted
situation → make → cave
With little to no airflow, the confined chambers offered a limited supply of oxygen, while the dark, narrow underwater passage left little room for error.
asserted
passage → confine → error
Blake Donner was 24 years old when he perished in the cave
Jennifer Lynn Galbraith, 21, had set off on the expedition with four others, including her boyfriend Blake
Search and rescue personnel from Provo, Orem and Utah County wait at the mouth of a small cave, top left, above the Seven Peaks area of Provo, Utah, to bring the bodies out of four people, ages 18 to 28, on Thursday, Aug. 18, 2005
An air hose was used by rescuers due to the low oxygen level in the cave
asserted
hose → perish → cave
When their bodies were eventually discovered, all four were reportedly facing the same direction, suggesting they had been trying to make their way back through the tunnel.
uncertain
they → discover → tunnel
Lt. Dave Bennett of the Utah County Search and Rescue team said at the time that the position of the bodies indicated they had encountered difficulties while attempting to return to the first cavern.
asserted
they → say → cavern
One body was found on the floor of the tunnel, while the other two were discovered floating.
asserted
two → find → tunnel
A fourth body was also recovered.
asserted
body → recover → ?
Some searchers speculated that the first victim found, a woman, may have blocked the narrow passage as the others tried to escape.
uncertain
others → speculate → passage
Their cause of death was recorded as drowning.
asserted
cause → record → drowning
Police detective Hiatt Bean later said: 'That [cavern] that they went into was just so small.
asserted
they → say → that
To have four people in there, they had to have been very lightheaded when they started heading back.'
asserted
they → have → people
Back outside the cave, Joseph had initially waited for his friends to return.
asserted
friends → wait → cave
But after around 45 minutes passed without any sign of them, he grew increasingly concerned and called the police.
Rescue teams rushed to the scene and began pumping water out of the cave.
They also pumped oxygen back into the confined space in the hopes that the four friends might still be alive.
uncertain
friends → pass → hopes
As the water level gradually dropped, rescuers were eventually able to enter the cave and begin searching for the missing hikers.
asserted
rescuers → drop → hikers
Around four hours after the alarm was first raised, they discovered the first body inside the underwater tunnel.
asserted
they → raise → tunnel
It later emerged that some members of the group had explored the cave before.
asserted
members → emerge → cave
A woman is comforted by an emergency worker after the bodies of four friends were found inside the cave
asserted
bodies → comfort → cave
The entrance of a cave is blocked by a no trespassing sign with a message written on it from a friend of the four people who died there
Flowers, the names of the victims and date of the accident are scratched into cement and rocks that now block the entrance of a cave near Provo, Utah, Friday, August 2005
Their friend Steve Hundley, who had not joined the expedition because he was working an early shift, recalled having dinner with the group before they set off.
He said one of the women spoke about the time she passed out from the cold while crossing the cave, although she had managed to make it out safely.
asserted
she → block → it
Steve also revealed that the group had jokingly referred to the crevice as 'The Cave of Death.'
asserted
group → reveal → Death
Others who had explored the cave warned that the cave's underwater tunnel was particularly dangerous because people could easily become disoriented and panic in the cramped, pitch-dark conditions.
uncertain
people → explore → conditions
Experts also described a rope running through the submerged passage, with one secured to a rock near the entrance and the other tied to a log in the second chamber.
asserted
Experts → describe → chamber
The rope was intended to help explorers pull themselves through the narrow tunnel.
asserted
explorers → intend → tunnel
But if someone lost their grip, the situation could quickly become more dangerous.
uncertain
situation → lose → grip
Sediment stirred up from the cave floor could also cloud the otherwise clear water, making it even harder to see or find a way out.
uncertain
it → stir → way
Following the tragedy, the mouth of the cave was closed with rocks and fresh concrete, while family and friends laid flowers outside.
asserted
family → follow → flowers
Emergency workers warned of the dangers of cave exploration.
asserted
workers → warn → exploration
…and 9 more, not listed.