With their cavernous post-industrial venues, teeth-grinding four-by-four beats and bouncers that look like Blade Runner extras, Berlin’s nightclubs trade on a reputation for bleakness.
asserted
nightclubs → grind → bleakness
A recent event at one of the city’s most legendary clubland institutions, however, has proven too dystopian even for seasoned techno-heads.
asserted
event → prove → heads
On 11 November, the Kraftwerk Berlin arts complex had its central hall transformed into what visitors described as something resembling a war room, with maps and aerial footage projected on to concrete walls, drones hanging from the ceiling, and guards in flak jackets patrolling the premises with sniffer dogs.
asserted
visitors → have → dogs
Those who flocked to the venue – which hosts the experimental music festival Atonal and is part of the same complex as the techno club Tresor – had come for the launch of Clarity, an AI targeting system developed by the German arms startup Helsing.
asserted
which → flock → startup
Kraftwerk Berlin this week apologised for a “serious error of judgment” and vowed to revise its commercial rental department’s booking policy, after outrage over the event rippled through Berlin’s music scene.
asserted
outrage → apologise → scene
The row has raised uncomfortable questions about the commercialisation of the German capital’s famed nightlife, and the culture sector’s traditional pacifism at a time of growing security threats.
asserted
row → raise → threats
The Munich-based Helsing was founded in 2021 and counts the Swedish tech entrepreneur and Spotify co-founder Daniel Ek among its investors and board co-chairs.
asserted
Helsing → base → investors
On its website, it describes Clarity as an agentic intelligence platform designed to use drone, satellite and sensor data to lock on to targets.
asserted
it → describe → targets
It claims that human operators remain responsible for approving any strikes.
uncertain
operators → claim → strikes
Helsing says Clarity is “developed and built in Europe under European control”.
asserted
Clarity → say → control
The market leader for battlefield software is Palantir’s Maven, the system that has powered US military strikes on Iran this year.
asserted
that → power → Iran
European governments have been scrambling for alternatives to US-developed systems.
asserted
governments → scramble → systems
France’s domestic intelligence service has already announced it is dropping Palantir for a homegrown rival.
asserted
it → announce → rival
But European governments’ boosting of their arms industries is also clashing with an anti-militaristic cultural consensus – nowhere more so than in the former cold war pressure cooker of Berlin, where nightclubs became spaces to dance away the anxieties of the arms race.
asserted
nightclubs → clash → race
“The fact there is a war in Europe and that Ukraine needs German support should not mean that we switch off all our critical faculties,” said Michail Stangl, a Berlin-based music curator and DJ.
asserted
Stangl → be → faculties
“We are already seeing how AI-driven targeting systems are being used in Gaza, and it’s hard to imagine that once a company like Helsing develops a successful arms system, it would not sell it on to authoritarian regimes, domestic police, or organisations like Frontex to be used against migrants.”
asserted
it → see → migrants
Speaking to the German broadcaster RBB at its launch event, a Helsing spokesperson said none of its military systems were designed to identify persons, and that Clarity was built to seek out objects such as radar systems, launch pads and ships.
asserted
Clarity → speak → systems
It also said Clarity’s agents specialised in “looking for patterns of behaviour”, which could be interpreted as relating to human activity.
uncertain
which → say → activity
Helsing did not respond to a request for comment.
asserted
Helsing → respond → comment
The Clarity launch event was condemned in the strongest terms by Tresor, a nightclub and record label that acted as a bridge between post-Wall Berlin and Detroit’s electronic music scene in the 1990s.
asserted
that → condemn → 1990s
“It has no place in the spaces our community has built,” it said in a statement.
asserted
it → have → statement
Hegemann has called the booking “unacceptable”, saying it was done by “a staff member at the company responsible for Kraftwerk’s commercial rental business”, without him being consulted.
asserted
him → call → business
Given his central role at the arts complex, and the level of planning usually required for such a high-security event, this has surprised some Berlin clubland insiders.
asserted
this → give → insiders
That Berlin’s former underground music venues are rented out for commercial purposes is no longer a deviation from the norm.
asserted
rented → rent → norm
As recently as 19 October, Kraftwerk Berlin hosted an investment summit organised by the German government and featuring a podium discussion between the chancellor, Friedrich Merz, and the chip manufacturer Nvidia’s then chief executive, Jensen Huang.
asserted
Berlin → host → chancellor
In a Q&A released after the Clarity row, Kraftwerk Berlin said it had declined a proposed Palantir-sponsored event in 2022 after consulting its cultural teams.
asserted
it → release → teams
Defenders of such commercial usages point out that many of Berlin’s nightclubs are struggling with rising rents and plummeting bar revenues.
asserted
many → point → rents
The total assets of its operating company, Schaltraum Berlin, were reported in June as having a value of €4.3m (£3.6m).
asserted
assets → operate → 4.3