A proposed law requiring internet service providers in Kenya to monitor subscribers’ data consumption and introduce identifiable meter numbers has drawn opposition from industry and civil society groups, amid concerns about affordability, privacy and the handling of personal information.
asserted
law → propose → information
The Kenya Information and Communications (Amendment) Bill, 2025, sponsored by Aldai MP Marianne Jebet Kitany, seeks to make consumption-based internet billing mandatory.
asserted
billing → sponsor → Kitany
It would require providers to assign each customer a unique meter number, monitor usage, convert it into readable details and issue invoices based on consumption.
asserted
It → require → consumption
The Bill’s stated objective is to protect consumers from unfair billing and ensure they pay for the internet they use.
asserted
they → state → internet
But the Communications Authority of Kenya (CA), telecommunications companies and civil society organisations have questioned whether mandatory metering is necessary and whether the proposed framework provides adequate safeguards for subscribers’ information.
asserted
framework → question → information
The debate has intensified as the National Assembly’s Departmental Committee on Communication, Information and Innovation considers the legislation.
asserted
Committee → intensify → legislation
The regulator has urged legislators not to make metered billing compulsory, while Telkom Kenya has warned of potential consequences for privacy, affordability and investment.
asserted
Kenya → urge → privacy
Privacy at risk
The Bill would require internet service providers to operate systems that monitor customer usage, convert consumption into readable details and generate invoices.
asserted
that → require → invoices
Providers would also have to submit information about their billing systems, including subscriber meter numbers, to the regulator at least once every financial year.
asserted
Providers → have → regulator
The proposed provisions do not expressly require providers to record the content of private messages or the websites subscribers visit.
asserted
subscribers → propose → messages
However, civil society organisations have questioned what usage information would be collected and how identifiable records would be stored, accessed and shared.
asserted
records → question → ?
The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) Kenya has questioned the necessity of mandatory metering, arguing that the regulator already has powers to address billing complaints and protect consumers.
asserted
regulator → question → consumers
Demas Kiprono of ICJ Kenya has argued that the proposed system raises questions about whether the collection of identifiable usage information is necessary and proportionate to the Bill’s stated consumer-protection objective.
asserted
collection → argue → objective
The concerns relate to the potential consequences of linking individual subscribers to records of their internet use.
asserted
concerns → relate → use
Critics say the legislation should specify who could access such information, how long it could be retained and the circumstances in which it could be disclosed.
uncertain
it → say → which
Kenya’s Data Protection Act, 2019, already provides a framework for processing personal information.
asserted
Act → provide → information
Opponents of the Bill say Parliament should make clear how those protections would apply to the proposed metering system.
asserted
apply → say → system
Questions about telecommunications data have also featured in court proceedings involving university student David Ooga Mokaya.
asserted
Questions → feature → Mokaya
He was arrested in November 2024 over a social media post concerning President William Ruto and charged with publishing false information.
asserted
He → arrest → information
On February 19 this year, Senior Principal Magistrate Caroline Nyaguthii acquitted him under Section 215 of the Criminal Procedure Code, finding that the prosecution had not proved its case beyond reasonable doubt.
asserted
prosecution → acquit → doubt
After his acquittal, Mokaya filed a petition at the High Court seeking protection of his personal information.
asserted
Mokaya → file → information
He argued that information, including call data records, subscriber details, location data and metadata had been supplied to investigators without his consent.
asserted
information → argue → consent
The allegations form part of the separate civil proceedings and should not be treated as a final judicial finding.
asserted
allegations → form → finding
On February 25, Justice Bahati Mwamuye issued interim conservatory orders restraining the respondents and interested parties from transferring, sharing or disclosing Mokaya’s personal data without his written consent, a valid court order or an express provision of written law permitting disclosure.
asserted
Mwamuye → issue → disclosure
The orders were issued pending further proceedings in the case.
asserted
orders → issue → case
They do not establish that the proposed internet metering system would be used for surveillance.
asserted
system → establish → surveillance
They do, however, illustrate the legal questions that can arise over the collection and disclosure of telecoms data.
asserted
that → illustrate → data
Mandatory consumption-based billing could also affect how households and businesses budget for connectivity.
uncertain
households → base → connectivity
In a submission to parliament on November 3, the Communications Authority cautioned against making metered billing compulsory across the sector.
asserted
billing → caution → sector
It said the approach could have unintended consequences for affordability, digital inclusion and consumer choice, particularly among low-income households, students, small businesses and communities in underserved areas.
uncertain
approach → say → areas
The regulator noted that background applications, software updates, streaming and cloud services can consume data without users closely monitoring their usage.
asserted
users → note → usage
Instead of prescribing one billing model, the Authority proposed usage alerts when subscribers reach 50, 80 and 100 percent of their data allowance, free real-time usage dashboards and monthly spending caps.
asserted
subscribers → prescribe → allowance
It also recommended independent certification and periodic audits of metering systems, clearer itemised bills and stronger procedures for resolving billing disputes.
asserted
It → recommend → disputes
The Authority’s position is that consumer protection can be strengthened through regulations and licensing requirements without requiring every provider to adopt consumption-based pricing.
asserted
protection → strengthen → pricing
The financial impact of a change would depend on providers’ pricing and individual patterns of internet use.
asserted
impact → depend → use
Customers who consume relatively little data could benefit from paying according to usage, while those who rely on large or continuous data allowances could face different costs.
uncertain
who → consume → costs
The Bill does not set the retail prices providers would charge.
asserted
providers → set → prices
Business concerns
Telecommunications companies have questioned whether the proposed changes could impose additional costs on providers and affect investment in broadband services.
uncertain
changes → question → services
Telkom Kenya Chief Executive Officer Mugo Kibati told the parliamentary committee on November 10 that mobile internet accounts for about 96 percent of data subscriptions and is already billed by volume.
asserted
internet → tell → volume
The proposed changes would therefore mainly affect fixed broadband services, which account for the remaining share, he said.
asserted
he → propose → share
…and 16 more, not listed.