Photo via Dawn

SMOKERS’ CORNER: The Migration Paradox

Read the original at Dawn ↗
Cite

Paracha, N. F. (2026, November 22). SMOKERS’ CORNER: The Migration Paradox. Dawn. https://www.dawn.com/news/2045727/smokers-corner-the-migration-paradox

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Dawn · collected 2026-11-22 · by Nadeem F. Paracha

Quick Summary

The article discusses the paradoxical trend of South Asian immigrants in Western countries becoming more religious than their counterparts back home. This phenomenon contrasts with earlier cultural stereotypes that suggested Western exposure would lead to the adoption of Western values and a decline in religious practice. Instead, immigrants often develop stricter religious identities due to a desire to preserve their cultural identity in a foreign environment where they might feel isolated. This trend is explained through Terror Management Theory, which posits that individuals cling more tightly to their core beliefs when faced with cultural displacement and anxiety.
Written by AI on 2026-11-22, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

In the 1970s, it was commonly believed that South Asians migrating to Western countries would adopt Western values and become less religious. Early Indian and Pakistani movies portrayed returnees as enlightened and secular. However, by the mid-1970s, these portrayals shifted to depicting migrants as hippies who had abandoned traditional values. Contrary to these expectations, many South Asians abroad have actually become more religious than their relatives in South Asia. This trend is evident in stricter mosque and temple attendance, more rigorous food rules, and a greater adherence to dogmatic religious practices in Western countries compared to their countries of origin. This phenomenon highlights the paradoxical impact of migration on cultural and religious identity.

Written for “Migration and Religious Practice” on 2026-11-22, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.
Why this leaning score
The article's own words the score was based on. Each is quoted verbatim and was checked against the article text before being stored, so you can find it in the original.
Reading Leans right (beta estimate) Confidence medium
Leaning: leans right for article 171169 (medium confidence, 3 verified quotes) · logged 2026-11-22

Compared with similar articles

Nothing to compare against. No article is close enough to this one for the pipeline to have linked or judged the pair.

Story

Migration and Religious Practice
Politics · 1 article(s) covering the same event.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
55
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
13%
7 of 55 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans right
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
66/100
Dawn's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-22 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Dawn · 3546 article(s) · 6 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 6 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Nadeem F. Paracha
10 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
In his book Religions of Immigrants from India and Pakistan, the American sociologist Raymond B. Williams posits that religious outlets abroad become the main places where immigrants reinstate their otherwise unsure presence.
2026-11-22 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: The Migration Paradox
Someday a real rain will come and wash all this scum off the streets.”
2026-11-15 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: The Lure of Fascist Fantasies
What many mistook for widespread support may simply have been what political scientists refer to as “manufactured popularity.”
2026-11-01 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: THE MYTH OF PTI’S POPULARITY
This radical route culminated in the violent events of May 2023, and November 2024, where party supporters targeted state and military installations.
2026-10-25 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: WHY POLITICAL RADICALISM EATS ITSELF
Despite a major Pakistani military offensive (2015–2017) that displaced the TTP, Pakistan maintained the belief that the TTA were ‘good Taliban’ who would remain allies once in power.
2026-10-18 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: IN CASE OF EMERGENCY
I will not delve into the numerous anomalies highlighted by sceptics, including those raised by active pilots and aviation experts.
2026-10-11 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: False Flags and Credibility
However, the assumption that Yassin’s movement would remain a benign social organisation focused solely on rivalling the PLO proved to be a miscalculation.
2026-10-04 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: THE MAKING OF HAMAS
Last week, when Polish foreign minister Radosaw Sikorski claimed that Poland could swiftly defeat Russia in a direct conflict, political commentators across the United States and Europe met his remarks with mild mockery.
2026-09-27 · mixed framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: THE AGE OF POLITICAL ABSURDITY
As long as the opposition fails to address the deep-seated ethnic, economic and existential anxieties of Sindhis, the electoral dominance of the PPP in Sindh will endure.
2026-09-20 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: WHY THE PPP DOMINATES SINDH
Their fears and historical experiences explain why plans to create a separate Karachi province will face stiff resistance.
2026-09-06 · assertive framing · SMOKERS’ CORNER: A SEPARATE PROVINCE?
Also by Nadeem F. Paracha
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 10 articles by Nadeem F. Paracha →

Topics

Indian Indians Pakistanis South Asians Western

Subjects

Western NORP · 6× Pakistani NORP · 3× American NORP · 2× Indian NORP · 2× Indians NORP · 2× Pakistanis NORP · 2× South Asian NORP · 2× South Asians NORP · 2× Jeff Greenberg PERSON · 1× Steven Vertovec PERSON · 1×

Narrative

As the British-Pakistani political sociologist Tariq Modood has demonstrated, British citizens from South Asia quickly realised that local councils, politicians and the media in the West do not deal with them as members of an ethnic group, but as ‘British Muslims’, ‘American Hindus’ or ‘Canadian Sikhs.’
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-22
In his book Religions of Immigrants from India and Pakistan, the American sociologist Raymond B. Williams posits that religious outlets abroad become the main places where immigrants reinstate their otherwise unsure presence.
2026-11-22 · Dawn
SMOKERS’ CORNER: The Migration Paradox · assertive framing

Claims (55 extracted, 7 hedged)

Till the early 1970s, it was often believed that South Asians who travelled to Western countries for studies or migrated there, often adopted ‘Western values.’ asserted
who → believe → values
In early Indian and Pakistani movies, Pakistanis and Indians returning from the West were often portrayed as enlightened, rational people who scoffed at the superstitious beliefs of their countrymen and women. asserted
who → return → countrymen
By the mid-1970s, though, the portrayal of West-returned Pakistanis and Indians changed. asserted
portrayal → return → Pakistanis
They began being portrayed as stupid, dope-smoking, guitar-slinging hippies. asserted
They → begin → hippies
But in the decades that followed, reality turned out very differently. asserted
reality → follow → decades
Instead of becoming less religious or adopting ‘immoral’ lifestyles, many South Asians living abroad actually became much more religious than their relatives back home. asserted
Asians → become → relatives
Anyone travelling between major South Asian cities and the suburbs of Western cities can see this contrast. asserted
Anyone → travel → contrast
In South Asia, religion is a natural part of everyday life, heard in the call to prayer or seen at local temples. asserted
religion → hear → temples
People do not have to work hard to keep it alive. asserted
People → have → it
Abroad, however, mosque and temple attendance becomes stricter, food rules become more rigid, and dogmatic religious rules often replace the relaxed, mixed traditions practised back home. asserted
rules → become → traditions
According to the American anthropologist Steven Vertovec, moving to a new country rarely weakens religious belief. uncertain
moving → accord → belief
Instead, it often makes people more conscious of their faith. asserted
people → make → faith
This change happens because of a deep desire to protect one’s culture, and the political reality of living as a minority in a foreign land. asserted
change → happen → land
Leaving South Asia means leaving behind extended families, friends, familiar streets and unspoken social rules. asserted
Leaving → leave → families
In Western countries, society focuses heavily on individual independence and small nuclear families, which can make newcomers feel lonely. asserted
newcomers → focus → independence
Religion fills this void. asserted
Religion → fill → void
South Asian immigrant communities in the secular West have often developed stricter religious identities than their counterparts back home. asserted
communities → develop → counterparts
What explains this paradox? asserted
What → explain → paradox
According to the Terror Management Theory developed by psychologists Jeff Greenberg, Sheldon Solomon and Tom Pyszczynski, when people feel anxious because their familiar world has disappeared, they hold on tighter to their core beliefs to feel secure. uncertain
they → accord → beliefs
The mosque, temple or the gurdwara in a Western country offers this, more than they do in the homeland of the immigrants. asserted
they → offer → immigrants
In his book Religions of Immigrants from India and Pakistan, the American sociologist Raymond B. Williams posits that religious outlets abroad become the main places where immigrants reinstate their otherwise unsure presence. asserted
immigrants → posit → presence
Inside these spaces, they are no longer treated as outsiders. asserted
they → treat → outsiders
According to multiple surveys by the Pew Research Centre, daily prayers and rituals act as emotional anchors that connect immigrants to their ‘heritage.’ uncertain
that → accord → heritage
Back in South Asia, a person’s identity is naturally supported by local languages, movies, food and festivals. asserted
identity → support → languages
One does not need to visit a temple to feel Indian, or a mosque to feel Pakistani as such, because the whole society reinforces that identity. asserted
society → need → identity
Abroad, however, the pressure to blend in is strong, indicated by the fear shown in 1970s Urdu and Hindi movies about ‘Westernised’ youth. asserted
pressure → blend → youth
Worried that their children will forget their roots, immigrant parents use special religious classes outside the curriculum in secular Western countries. asserted
parents → forget → countries
The British scholar Pnina Werbner, in her studies of British Pakistanis, talks about a “cultural freeze.” asserted
scholar → talk → freeze
While people in South Asia continue to debate, modernise and change their views over time, immigrant communities often freeze the religious and social rules of the exact decade they left. asserted
they → continue → decade
A family that left Lahore or Ahmedabad in the 1980s might strictly follow conservative rules that their own cousins back home are likely to have moved away from. uncertain
cousins → leave → that
The Pakistani-American historian Ayesha Jalal and the French scholar Olivier Roy point out that the blended traditions of South Asia do not travel well. asserted
traditions → point → Asia
According to Roy’s idea of “deculturation”, when religion is separated from its home soil, what survives is a simpler, literalist and stricter version of it. uncertain
survives → accord → it
Becoming more religious abroad is also driven by politics, shaped by political tensions brought over from South Asia. asserted
Becoming → become → Asia
In many Western countries, especially under multicultural policies, governments organise immigrant groups by their religion rather than their language or region. asserted
governments → organise → religion
As the British-Pakistani political sociologist Tariq Modood has demonstrated, British citizens from South Asia quickly realised that local councils, politicians and the media in the West do not deal with them as members of an ethnic group, but as ‘British Muslims’, ‘American Hindus’ or ‘Canadian Sikhs.’ asserted
councils → demonstrate → Muslims
Due to the fact that the government recognises general religious labels, people have a strong reason to organise around their faith if they want a political voice. asserted
they → recognise → voice
At the same time, rising prejudice, Islamophobia and anti-immigrant attitudes trigger what American sociologists Alejandro Portes and Rubén Rumbaut call “reactive religion.” asserted
sociologists → rise → what
According to their research, when a minority group feels judged, turning toward religion becomes a way to defend themselves. uncertain
turning → accord → themselves
Wearing visible religious symbols such as a hijab, a turban or a tilak becomes a public statement of strength — at least to the wearers. asserted
Wearing → wear → wearers
This is made even stronger by what the Irish political scientist Benedict Anderson terms as “long-distance nationalism.” asserted
scientist → make → nationalism
…and 15 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support