- Published
Is this real or AI?
asserted
this → publish → ?
It is a question increasingly asked underneath social media videos, and often difficult to tell.
asserted
It → ask → videos
But there is a new trend when it comes to digital manipulation.
asserted
it → be → manipulation
Across social media, AI-generated characters are appearing in videos that look remarkably similar to those posted by real people.
asserted
that → generate → people
From musicians to dancers and comedians, content creators are finding their performances cloned by these characters that are designed to look funny, realistic, or hypersexualised.
asserted
that → find → characters
Experts call the practice "reskinning" and say it is made possible by cheap, easy-to-use AI tools.
asserted
it → call → tools
People can discover their work has been copied by seeing a video of a character making the same joke or doing the same dance, even with the same background.
asserted
character → discover → background
Sometimes the AI version has millions more views than the original.
asserted
version → have → original
Some of the accounts identified by BBC Verify appear to be using these AI-generated videos to get views and likes, and to eventually make money.
asserted
Some → identify → money
Others appear to be experimenting with AI to make people laugh or simply for the attention that comes with going viral.
asserted
that → appear → attention
But the practice has angered content creators who say their original work is being stolen.
asserted
work → anger → creators
"A lot [of these accounts] are getting thousands of views, thousands of followers, just for literally doing nothing and stealing the stuff that we've created," says Sophie Lloyd, a UK-based guitarist who tours with US rapper Machine Gun Kelly, who has spent years building a successful online presence.
asserted
who → get → presence
Lloyd says videos of her performances have been repeatedly reskinned by accounts that replaced her with over-sexualised AI-generated characters.
asserted
that → say → characters
One Facebook account published hundreds of short videos of a guitarist called "Mila Vasari" that had each gained thousands of views.
asserted
that → publish → views
BBC Verify found that at least three copied Lloyd's performances and used the exact same music, movements, and even facial expressions.
asserted
three → find → music
BBC Verify did not find any evidence that "Mila Vasari" is a real person.
asserted
Vasari → find → evidence
The videos on the Vasari account also contain visual inconsistencies that suggest AI was used to create them, including distorted fingers playing chords that don't match the music, and guitar strings that fail to move when strummed.
asserted
that → contain → music
The account, which appears to be run from Canada, did not respond to questions about the purpose of these videos.
asserted
which → appear → videos
Its profile links to a page devoted to Vasari on Fanvue, a subscription platform that allows creators to charge for content, including adult material.
asserted
creators → link → material
BBC Verify has found two other accounts fronted by AI-generated guitarists that have reskinned Lloyd's performances and use those avatars to sell and promote adult content.
asserted
that → find → content
But Lloyd is far from alone in having her content manipulated by AI.
asserted
content → have → AI
"I've got so many messages from other artists and creators that have had the same thing happening to them," says Kjetil Krogstad, a Norwegian content creator known for videos showing him happily dancing in a suit while carrying a cup of tea.
asserted
him → get → tea
In March, his followers alerted him to the fact that one of his videos had been reskinned using an AI-generated bunny.
asserted
one → alert → bunny
The post went on to attract millions of views - outperforming Krogstad's original video - before being deleted.
asserted
post → go → video
When Krogstad looked into the account behind the bunny video, he found it promoting courses on how to make money from AI-generated content.
asserted
it → look → content
Dr Tina Kendall, an expert in online culture at Anglia Ruskin University, says that while these videos are sometimes made for fun, often the people behind the accounts copy videos that have already proven popular in the hope of attracting audiences and making money.
"What these tools allow people to do is just automatically take a viral concept that's already existing and to reuse it through these reskinning tools," she says.
asserted
she → say → tools
Kendall sees this as part of a wider online "hustle culture", in which accounts seek to turn users' attention and engagement into money - be it through subscriptions to fan pages featuring adult content, risky cryptocurrency products like meme coins, or monetisation features on social media platforms.
asserted
it → see → platforms
And making these copies "conventionally attractive, white, feminine" characters can help, Kendall says.
asserted
Kendall → make → ?
"That's the kind of stuff that always floats to the top and is successful, it really conforms with these conventional cultural ideals of attractiveness, success, aspiration, beauty.
asserted
it → float → beauty
Dozens of people have taken to social media in recent weeks to call out the AI-generated accounts they found using their content without permission.
asserted
they → take → permission
"I cannot explain how angry I am right now," Grace Roberts, a British car creator, said on Instagram.
asserted
Roberts → explain → Instagram
"Someone not only stole my video, but also changed me into basically the societal norm of what people want to watch, and this is literally my job," she said, showing the original video of herself wearing jeans, smiling and covering her ears at a drag car race next to an AI-generated version with a blonde woman in a short dress.
asserted
herself → steal → dress
"I put the videos side by side and I could see it was my exact facial movements, how my body moved, the exact same background and even the people around me were completely copied," she told BBC Verify.
uncertain
she → put → Verify
"It was just me that had been altered.
asserted
that → alter → ?
"
"I pay for the cars, I build the cars, I pay for the cameras, the filming equipment, and then someone can just hit download on their computer, change it, and then make money off the back of my video," she added.
asserted
she → pay → video
Her concerns are echoed by other content creators who fear these AI-generated accounts could cost them valuable exposure, followers, and potential income.
uncertain
accounts → echo → exposure
American comedian Julia Jasunas, who called out having her jokes stolen online by AI, said in a recent Instagram video: "The thing that is most concerning is these AI bots are going viral and people think that they're real people.
"
asserted
they → call → video
And for context, comedians post their stand-up clips online to get you to come out and see live comedy," she said, adding that comedians spent a long time crafting jokes on stage and honing them into punchy lines.
asserted
comedians → post → lines
Equity, the UK's largest entertainment union, has called for new laws to protect performers against the unauthorised use of their work by AI, arguing that existing copyright legislation is inadequate.
asserted
legislation → call → AI
Identifying those responsible for copying the videos, and stopping them from doing it again, can also prove difficult.
asserted
Identifying → identify → it
…and 8 more, not listed.