Wait times, cost, and assisted suicide: Critics’ case against Democrats’ Medicare for All push
Democrats are set to take power in January with a concrete Medicare for All timeline, so the wait times, costs and care decisions seen elsewhere are a preview of trade-offs that critics say Americans could face.
uncertain
Americans → assist → that
One Canadian cancer patient says she was offered assisted suicide before she was even seen by an oncologist.
asserted
she → say → oncologist
Following Democrats' win on Nov. 3, many members of the party have started pushing for completely upending America's health care system and replacing it with their Medicare for All (MFA) plan.
asserted
members → follow → plan
On Wednesday, the Associated Press reported that Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., has a plan to implement MFA once Democrats take power in January.
asserted
Democrats → report → January
Sanders, who is expected to become chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee at that time, told the outlet that he would propose to implement MFA over four years.
asserted
he → expect → years
In the first year, Sanders told the outlet, the Medicare eligibility age would be lowered from 65 to 55, and coverage would be expanded to cover dental, vision, and hearing, and health care would be guaranteed for children through the age of 18.
asserted
care → tell → 18
This is where the American people are," Sanders told the outlet.
asserted
Sanders → tell → outlet
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., who is expected to become House speaker in January, said Tuesday that Democrats are preparing to lower the Medicare eligibility age, add vision, hearing, and dental coverage, and ensure all children are covered, the AP reported.
asserted
AP → expect → coverage
Conservative critics point to flaws and side effects inherent in other countries' systems to argue against adopting such a policy in America.
asserted
critics → point → America
Long wait times for health care in Canada and England may increase death rate
uncertain
times → increase → rate
Canada's Fraser Institute, a right-leaning think tank, on Tuesday released its 2026 report on wait times in the country, which has universal health care.
asserted
which → lean → care
The report surveyed physicians across the country and found that Canadians faced a median wait of 30.7 weeks between a referral from their general practitioner and receipt of treatment, an increase from 28.6 weeks in 2025.
asserted
Canadians → survey → 2025
Wait times did decrease in a few areas, including Manitoba, Quebec, and Prince Edward Island, but they increased elsewhere, the report said.
asserted
report → decrease → Manitoba
The shortest wait times were found in Ontario, where patients waited 22.1 weeks for treatment, or more than five months.
asserted
patients → find → treatment
Fraser found that the longest wait times were in New Brunswick, where patients waited more than a year (64.4 weeks) to receive treatment.
asserted
patients → find → treatment
The institute's methodology considered emergent, urgent, and elective wait times for cardiovascular surgery, while the specialties of internal medicine, medical oncology, neurosurgery, and radiation oncology may also include non-elective wait times.
uncertain
specialties → consider → times
SecondStreet.org, a Canadian free-market public policy think tank, released a report in November 2025 using government data that found more than 23,000 patients in Canada died over the previous year while waiting for care.
asserted
patients → release → care
"What's really sad is that behind many of these figures are stories of patients suffering during their final years – grandparents who dealt with chronic pain while waiting for hip operations, people leaving children behind as they die waiting for heart operations, so much suffering," SecondStreet.org President Colin Craig said at the time.
asserted
Craig → suffer → time
"It doesn't have to be this way.
asserted
It → have → ?
If we copied better-performing European public health systems, we could greatly reduce patient suffering."
uncertain
we → copy → suffering
England's National Health Service (NHS) also reports long waits.
asserted
Service → report → waits
Last week, The Independent reported that figures from England's National Health Service showed an estimated 116,353 people waiting more than a year to start routine treatment.
asserted
figures → report → treatment
The report also said that an estimated 65.8% of patients in September began hospital treatment within 18 weeks of referral.
asserted
% → say → referral
The Royal College of Emergency Medicine's annual report on England, released in June, found that there were 15,860 excess deaths in England in 2025 associated with long waits in emergency departments.
asserted
report → release → departments
Instead, "NHS" is an umbrella term for four separate health systems run independently by England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.
asserted
NHS → run → England
When it comes to cancer, 70.7% of patients in England began treatment within 62 days of an urgent referral in September, according to Cancer Research UK, a leading cancer charity.
uncertain
% → come → UK
The organization also noted that 91.5% of people started treatment within 31 days of receiving a doctor's treatment plan.
asserted
% → note → plan
Wait times for MRIs are so long in Canada, which had 432 MRI units as of a 2022-2023 national survey, that imaging centers in the Buffalo, New York, area market to Canadian patients crossing the border to get medically necessary tests.
asserted
centers → have → tests
Heritage warns of more government control
The Heritage Foundation wrote in an undated essay that cites 2019 data, "The Truth About Government-Controlled Health Care," which said 43.3% of legal U.S. residents are enrolled in or heavily subsidized by Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program, and Affordable Care Act (colloquially called "Obamacare") exchange plans.
asserted
% → warn → Medicare
These programs have already resulted in "health care that is too costly, and health insurance programs, in both the public and the private sector, that patients often find too bureaucratic, complex, and confusing," Heritage wrote.
asserted
Heritage → result → public
Heritage also wrote that under a government-run system, government officials, not doctors or patients, would make major decisions about who gets care.
asserted
who → write → care
Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., another Democrat who has been pushing MFA, posted on X Tuesday that MFA "would lower costs from $5.3 trillion to $4 trillion," but those numbers are based on a "pre-print" non-peer-reviewed study from Yale’s School of Public Health and the University of Maryland, meaning that independent experts in the same field have not formally evaluated its methods or conclusions.
asserted
experts → push → methods
Khanna cited the analysis in an Aug. 14 statement that put the purported lower costs between $5.28 trillion and $4.24 trillion.
asserted
that → cite → trillion
In December 2020, the Congressional Budget Office published a report analyzing five illustrative single-payer options and found that federal subsidies for health care would increase by $1.5 trillion to $3 trillion in 2030.
asserted
subsidies → publish → 2030
"Set up to die," says patient offered assisted suicide in Canada
asserted
patient → Set → Canada
On Saturday, Fox News reported that a woman who had moved to Canada for its publicly funded health care ended up returning to the U.S. after she said she was offered medically assisted death before cancer treatment.
asserted
she → report → treatment
"Canada has been slowly sliding into an entire dystopian situation.
asserted
Canada → slide → situation
The way they've expanded the MAID [Medical Assistance In Dying] system is frightening.
asserted
they → expand → system
It was never supposed to be used this way, to be offered so easily and so upfront when a person gets sick.
asserted
person → suppose → ?
I think it's evil," Donovan James, whose wife, Kristin Logan, has cancer, told Fox.
asserted
wife → think → Fox
…and 11 more, not listed.