Claims extracted
24
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
8%
2 of 24 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
69/100
Daily Mail's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Education
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Teachers can now use AI chatbots like ChatGPT to mark vital exam coursework in guidance denounced as 'nothing short of scandalous' by educationalists.
asserted
Teachers → use → educationalists
While students are warned they face strict penalties for using AI to create it, they say JCQ (the Joint Council for Qualifications), which oversees UK exam boards, has 'quietly' ruled teachers can use AI to mark it.
asserted
teachers → warn → it
But Dr Will Van Reyk from top girls' school St Paul's in London, where AI marking is banned, said the recently released guidance is 'preposterous' and 'crosses a red line that should never be crossed'.
asserted
that → ban → line
And he warned exam regulator Ofqual, whose advice JCQ follows, was 'losing its grip' for 'being happy for teachers to use AI for marking' when they were 'so worried about students misusing it'.
asserted
students → warn → it
'It basically gives the green light for teachers to put coursework into AI with the small caveat a human oversees the final mark but why are they even allowing that when AI can't do the marking and has no place in marking?
asserted
AI → give → marking
'
Incredibly there are no current restrictions on which AI tools teachers can use and neither have teachers been trained to use them, Dr Van Reyk said.
asserted
Reyk → be → them
These are not even specialist chatbots - what they would feed students' coursework into are just standard bots like ChatGPT or Microsoft Copilot.
asserted
feed → feed → ChatGPT
There is absolutely no evidence that a mainstream AI chatbot can be used for marking.
asserted
chatbot → be → marking
It is nothing short of scandalous that this is being allowed.
asserted
this → allow → ?
It could lead to all sorts of dodgy marks.
uncertain
It → lead → marks
A teacher pictured in a classroom helping a student who has a laptop on his desk
A hand holding a mobile phone displaying the ChatGPT logo on its screen
Querying why teaching unions had not 'flagged this as a concern', he also accused Education Secretary Lucy Powell of 'publicly contradicting what was in the guidance'.
'She told Parliament that she doesn't believe AI has a place in marking but in the guidance it says teachers can use it when there is absolutely no evidence that is fair or that it works,' said Dr Van Reyk, Director of Innovation at the school whose alumnae include Jennifer Saunders, Susanna Reid and Rachel Weisz.
asserted
alumnae → picture → Saunders
He insisted: 'There should be a total red line in never allowing AI to mark children's work on a number of grounds but fundamentally because it totally undermines the student-teacher relationship.
'You end up with a vicious cycle that if the teacher is using AI for marking then how can you look the kids in the eye and say - 'don't use it for your work'.
asserted
you → insist → work
Dr Van Reyk, also co-founder of Pedagogue which teaches responsible AI use, says the latest advice is 'buried' in a 55-page document from JCQ on AI use in Assessments.
asserted
advice → teach → Assessments
While it almost entirely concentrates on how students should acknowledge their use of AI and gives teachers guidelines to spot AI produced work, it does not set any standards for teachers, he warned.
asserted
he → concentrate → teachers
'The kids and parents do not know if that coursework went through AI and that is allowed in the current system.
'
asserted
that → know → system
For me that means coursework at both ends is totally invalid now because you've got kids writing the coursework with AI and teachers allowed to mark it with AI, albeit not as the final marker.'
asserted
teachers → mean → marker
Dr Will Van Reyk from top girls' school St Paul's in London said the new guidance is 'preposterous'
asserted
guidance → say → London
People hold placards and a banner during a protest held by civic action group PauseAI UK outside Downing Street
Dr Van Reyk said there were ways to use AI sensibly but 'what we see in these official documents is one of the worst examples of how AI can be used in education - for marking - where effectively you are putting the kids' marks into a lottery!'
A JCQ spokesperson said its guidance was 'consistent with the regulator's position and is clear that AI must not take over the marking of students' work'.
asserted
AI → hold → work
They said: 'AI must not be used as the primary or sole means of marking.
asserted
AI → say → marking
The guidance reflects the requirements and guidance set out by the regulator and will continue to be updated in line with any further guidance published by them.
asserted
guidance → reflect → them
Meanwhile an Ofqual spokesperson said: 'We have been clear with awarding organisations that AI may not be used as the sole marker in any assessment that is part of a regulated qualification, and that expert human involvement, oversight and accountability must remain in place.'
A DFE spokesperson said: 'AI must never replace a teacher's professional judgement when marking a student's work and assessments must be undertaken by the teacher.
'
uncertain
AI → say → teacher
Used safely and appropriately, AI has the potential to reduce teacher workload, but it cannot be used as the sole or primary mechanism for determining a student's mark.
asserted
it → use → mark
We are working closely with regulators and the sector to ensure that the use of new technology does not compromise the fairness and reliability of qualifications.'
asserted
use → work → qualifications
AI teachers set to be unleashed in UK classrooms as early as this summer
READ MORE: Teachers paying AI robots to write pupils' end-of-year school reports
asserted
Teachers → set → reports