It is no great revelation to observers of Queensland politics that Miles, still seemingly bruised from his election loss two years ago, has struggled to find his feet as opposition leader.
asserted
Miles → bruise → leader
Many wondered why he wanted to stay on after the party’s drubbing in 2024.
asserted
he → wonder → 2024
Some of Labor’s factional whisperers were telling anyone who would listen that the former premier’s leadership would come to an end in the weeks before Christmas.
asserted
leadership → tell → Christmas
However, the week in parliament has ended with a revitalised opposition and a wounded LNP government.
asserted
week → end → opposition
A government that has for so long seemed untouchable.
asserted
that → seem → ?
A government that has now been left battling the perception that it is overseeing a broken health system.
asserted
it → leave → system
And a government – now in office for more than two years – finally forced to take responsibility for systems it had promised to repair; seemingly no longer able to legitimately blame the former Labor government for the litany of mistakes that led to the deaths of seven people in the care of Queensland’s health system.
asserted
that → force → system
By the end of the week, parliament heard six people had died waiting for an ambulance in the last three weeks.
asserted
people → hear → weeks
One man had waited seven hours, another three.
asserted
another → wait → ?
All were triaged as urgently in need of attention.
asserted
All → triage → attention
Another man had taken his own life in the emergency department of the Prince Charles hospital after self-admitting for mental health treatment.
asserted
man → take → treatment
It took staff three hours to find him.
asserted
It → take → him
The health minister, Tim Nicholls, is a professional, a 20-year veteran, with the bearing of a well-paid barrister, who led the LNP to an election in 2017.
asserted
who → pay → 2017
But he struggled to cope with the parliamentary barrage.
asserted
he → struggle → barrage
In response to a question from Labor’s Joe Kelly, a former nurse, about how many ambulances had been ramped on 3 November, the night a man died while waiting for one in Townsville, Nicholls first criticised the question’s “pettiness”.
asserted
Nicholls → ramp → pettiness
Are they going to ask me what the level of fuel was in the back of the ambulances?” he responded.
asserted
he → go → ambulances
“There was no ramping overnight at the Townsville University hospital that night,” he finished.
asserted
he → be → hospital
“I am very pleased to be able to correct the record for the purposes of the house,” he said, two questions later.
asserted
he → correct → house
“There were at that time four ambulances, as I understand it, on the ramp waiting to off-load.
asserted
I → be → ramp
Nicholls threw the blame at the federal government, at the former Labor state government and its “decade of decline”, a phrase repeated endlessly by government MPs, at overwhelmed hospitals full of “forgotten Australians”, a term used to refer to retirees warehoused in public hospitals for lack of a federally funded retirement home to put them in.
asserted
Nicholls → throw → them
Endlessly, Labor hounded him: would he meet the families of the dead?
asserted
he → hound → dead
For a government built on a small-target strategy based on responding to the grief of victims of crime – predicated on the fact that any indecisive response to a tragedy would be an inherently unconvincing one – this was a completely different emotional battle.
asserted
this → build → tragedy
By Wednesday, Nicholls was attending an emergency meeting with the premier, David Crisafulli, the health department director general, David Rosengren, and the ambulance service commissioner, Craig Emery.
asserted
Nicholls → attend → premier
The next day, after another bruising question time, he called a press conference.
asserted
he → call → conference
Bearing his well-worn years-old folder labelled “LABOR’S HOSPITAL FAILURES”, he insisted that he was taking responsibility – for making sure his subordinates were doing their jobs.
asserted
subordinates → bear → jobs
“I think people would expect that, as the minister, I hold the DG and the commissioner responsible for the services that they deliver, and I seek answers to questions,” he said.
asserted
he → think → questions
“So I sought advice from the commissioner about the steps that they were taking, what was being done to address the need, what was the root cause of the problem.”
asserted
cause → seek → problem
Nicholls said the community could have confidence in the triple-zero system and paramedics, promising to reinvest whatever it was he needed to, on advice from his department.
uncertain
he → say → department
“Like all Queenslanders, I do have questions regarding the delivery of services because one death that’s unexpected in the community is one too many,” he said.
asserted
he → regard → community
But the issue is there are simply not enough beds.”
asserted
issue → be → ?
After 10 minutes, with many more questions unasked, he abruptly walked off, looking more like a traditional Queensland health minister than any in the LNP cabinet have this term.
asserted
he → unaske → cabinet
Then Miles stepped up to the microphone.
asserted
Miles → step → microphone
After days of leadership speculation in newspapers – which has been deliberately and mischievously fanned by the government – the former health minister was on much more solid ground.
asserted
minister → fan → ground
“I have never before seen so many preventable deaths of Queenslanders left waiting hours for an ambulance to arrive, only to die before it does,” Miles said.
asserted
Miles → see → Queenslanders
“It is only getting worse and worse.
asserted
It → get → ?
Miles retains significant goodwill from most Labor MPs, but the polls have become hard for most to ignore.
asserted
most → retain → MPs
Some think he’s simply failed to land enough punches.
asserted
he → think → punches
Others that he hasn’t thrown nearly enough.
asserted
he → throw → enough
It remains to be seen whether Miles’s decision to come out swinging was the act of an opposition leader with nothing to lose, deciding to fight at five minutes to midnight in his political career.
asserted
decision → remain → career
After two years in which the opposition has rarely felt relevant, this week Queensland politics finally felt like a fair fight.
asserted
politics → feel → fight