Photo via Daily Mail

Revealed: SNP Government's plot to dismiss NHS whistleblower's fears over deaths of patients

Read the original at Daily Mail ↗
Cite

Rodger, H. (2026, November 21). Revealed: SNP Government's plot to dismiss NHS whistleblower's fears over deaths of patients. Daily Mail. https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16311647/SNP-Governments-plot-dismiss-NHS-whistleblowers-fears-deaths-patients.html?ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490&ito=1490

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Daily Mail · collected 2026-11-21 · by Hannah Rodger

Quick Summary

The Mail on Sunday reports that Scottish National Party (SNP) government officials and NHS Grampian plotted to dismiss a whistleblower’s concerns over patient deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. Emails reveal a civil servant colluded with NHS Grampian to downplay Dr. Mohammed Habib’s calls for a public inquiry into surgical malpractice that led to patient deaths. The article exposes that government staff and the Chief Medical Officer were involved in these communications, despite officials claiming ignorance of Dr. Habib’s concerns.
Written by AI on 2026-11-21, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Health Secretary Angela Constance ordered an independent review on November 19, 2026, after revelations that the Scottish Government and NHS Grampian had plotted to dismiss concerns raised by whistleblower Dr. Mohammed Habib. Emails uncovered by The Mail on Sunday revealed that Scottish Government officials and NHS Grampian colluded to downplay Dr. Habib's warnings about avoidable patient deaths during liver and pancreatic surgeries at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI). Dr. Habib had previously disclosed a 2022 report documenting the avoidable deaths of 19 patients and warned of further harm due to malpractice and inaction. In response to these disclosures, Constance announced an urgent review into how patient safety concerns were handled, stating that Dr. Habib’s concerns were "deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness."

Written for “Independent Review Ordered For NHS Grampian” on 2026-11-22, grounded in this article and the 1 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

2 outlets covered “Independent Review Ordered For NHS Grampian”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Daily MailThis outlet21 Nov

The Mail on Sunday reports that Scottish National Party (SNP) government officials and NHS Grampian plotted to dismiss a whistleblower’s concerns over patient deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. Emails reveal a civil servant colluded with NHS Grampian to downplay Dr. Mohammed Habib’s calls for a public inquiry into surgical malpractice that led to patient deaths. The article exposes that government staff and the…

Revealed: SNP Government's plot to dismiss NHS whistleblower's fears over deaths of patients (this article)
Evening Standard21 Nov

Health Secretary Angela Constance ordered an independent review after revelations by Dr Mohammed Habib, who reported that 19 out of 31 deaths in liver and pancreatic surgeries at NHS Grampian were avoidable. Dr Habib had previously raised concerns about patient safety over several years, including contacting the police and the Lord Advocate. The review will investigate how these concerns were handled by the health…

Independent review ordered after NHS Grampian revelations →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly right and hedges 6% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 2 of 28 claims Outlet record 67/100
“The articles describe different whistleblower incidents in distinct healthcare systems and locations, with different individuals and institutions involved.”
Evening Standard
Hedges 1 of 40 claims Outlet record 64/100
Daily Mail
Leans right further left than this Hedges 2 of 39 claims Outlet record 69/100
“Article A discusses the reaction of the First Minister and MSPs to a report on avoidable deaths at NHS Grampian, while Article B specifically focuses on the government's alleged attempt to dismiss the concerns of a whistleblower, Dr. Habib, through email communications. These describe different aspects of the broader scandal, not the same specific incident.”
Daily Mail
Leans strongly left further left than this Hedges 8 of 50 claims Outlet record 69/100
“The articles describe related events involving the same whistleblower and hospital, but they report on different occurrences: one involves government officials' emails and plots, while the other reports on a police investigation being launched.”

Story

Independent Review Ordered For NHS Grampian
Health · 2 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
36
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
6%
2 of 36 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans strongly right
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
69/100
Daily Mail's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Health
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-21 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Daily Mail · 12423 article(s) · 26 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 26 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Hannah Rodger
17 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
‘The SNP Scottish Government was more interested in a coverup than the truth, just so it could protect its own reputation.
Prosecutor Eilidh Robertson told the court: ‘Mrs Whiting sat up and MacKinnon demanded she lie down or he would really hurt her.
The Scottish Government has been urged to explain why it has spent nearly £300million outsourcing work that its army of civil servants could mostly do themselves.
The IT firm – based in Bangalore – will control the software that people use to apply for benefits, track their applications and make sure their details are up to date. The move comes after the Scottish Government was allowed to set up Social Security Scotland to deal with benefits.
In January, the 55-year-old’s videos became so popular on YouTube that Google, which owns the site, ‘monetised’ her account, meaning she would get paid every time viewers watched her films.
A decision has yet to be made on whether to approve Rosebank – an oil field off the coast of Shetland – which would produce oil mainly for export, as opposed to Jackdaw which will produce a lot of gas for use in the UK.
The First Minister announced he would introduce a bill by next summer to make ‘harassment and abuse based on misogyny a specific criminal offence’ during his speech to SNP conference. But in May 2025 the nationalists scrapped the same legislation as it would have included protections for transgender women, who are biologically male, claiming they did so as there was not enough time to redraft the law following the Supreme Court judgment on the definition of a ‘woman’ in the Equality Act.
Ms Badenoch added that Mr Flynn and Ms Goodlad ‘would not be my ministers’ if they were members of her party.
Among them is Carmichael John Williamson, known as John, who was last week found guilty of raping a teenager and a woman in Shetland.
Veteran instructor Ian Haggis died in the plane crash The plane came down in a field near Drymen, Stirlingshire Nothing is known about the trainee pilot, other than it was a boy aged 16 who may have been taking a flying lesson during the half-term holidays.
Also by Hannah Rodger
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 17 articles by Hannah Rodger →

Topics

Health NHS Grampian SNP Scottish The Mail on Sunday

Subjects

Habib PERSON · 9× NHS Grampian ORG · 6× Scottish NORP · 3× ARI ORG · 2× Angela Constance PERSON · 2× Health ORG · 2× Holyrood ORG · 2× John Swinney PERSON · 2× SNP ORG · 2× The Mail on Sunday ORG · 2×

Narrative

Health secretary Angela Constance has now ordered a review Dr Habib also revealed a previously unpublished 2022 report which documented the ‘avoidable’ deaths of 19 people at ARI, and warned there had been more deaths and patients harmed in the years since due to malpractice and inaction. First Minister John Swinney and Ms Constance have both denied all knowledge of Dr Habib’s letters to government, which he sent in 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-21
‘The SNP Scottish Government was more interested in a coverup than the truth, just so it could protect its own reputation.

Claims (36 extracted, 2 hedged)

Scottish Government officials plotted with NHS Grampian to dismiss desperate pleas from a whistleblower for help to stop patients dying during surgery. asserted
patients → plot → surgery
Bombshell emails obtained by The Mail on Sunday show a civil servant colluding with the scandal-hit health board over how to respond to Dr Mohammed Habib’s calls for a public inquiry into deaths at ‘slaughterhouse’ hospital Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI). asserted
emails → obtain → hospital
Holyrood civil servants told a senior NHS Grampian boss they were not planning to respond to Dr Habib’s concerns about malpractice ‘in any detail’, asked the medical chief if their approach was acceptable and even requested he fact-check the reply. Just hours after The Mail on Sunday confronted the government about the emails, Health Secretary Angela Constance announced a ‘review’ of how concerns, including Dr Habib’s, were handled. asserted
concerns → tell → Habib
The shocking revelations come after the whistleblowing surgeon, who still works for NHS Grampian, last week demanded his employer face a corporate homicide investigation over the needless deaths of patients during liver and pancreatic surgery. asserted
employer → come → surgery
Some patients bled to death in the operating theatre because of mistakes by surgeons. asserted
patients → bleed → surgeons
Dr Habib (right), with his lawyer Aamer Anwar, said he had exhausted all avenues to raise concerns. asserted
he → say → concerns
Health secretary Angela Constance has now ordered a review Dr Habib also revealed a previously unpublished 2022 report which documented the ‘avoidable’ deaths of 19 people at ARI, and warned there had been more deaths and patients harmed in the years since due to malpractice and inaction. First Minister John Swinney and Ms Constance have both denied all knowledge of Dr Habib’s letters to government, which he sent in 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026. asserted
he → order → 2023
But emails show government staff discussing the whistleblower’s concerns with NHS Grampian in 2023 – the day before the government replied to Dr Habib, asking for advice on how to respond. asserted
government → show → advice
The officials stated his messages had ‘come to’ the First Minister and health secretary. asserted
messages → state → Minister
Chief Medical Officer Sir Gregor Smith was copied in to all the emails. asserted
Smith → copy → emails
Scottish Tory health spokesman Miles Briggs said: ‘The SNP has repeatedly tried to claim ministers were unaware of the crisis at NHS Grampian, but this fresh evidence shows senior civil servants, policy officials and the Chief Medical Officer were all involved in minimising serious allegations. ‘ uncertain
servants → say → allegations
John Swinney must now explain exactly what he knew, when they knew it, and why concerns seem to have been dismissed rather than properly investigated. asserted
concerns → explain → it
‘The SNP Scottish Government was more interested in a coverup than the truth, just so it could protect its own reputation. uncertain
it → protect → reputation
The Scottish public deserve full transparency from the First Minister.’ asserted
public → deserve → Minister
Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour health spokeswoman, said: ‘If these extremely serious safety concerns within our NHS were put on the desks of ministers three years ago, then how is it possible that they have only just found out about those concerns in the last week? asserted
they → say → week
‘People died unnecessarily. asserted
People → die → ?
Safety concerns appear to have been brushed aside, and there has been a conspiracy to silence complainers and to cover up the truth. asserted
concerns → appear → truth
The families deserve answers now.’ asserted
families → deserve → answers
Dr Habib contacted the First Minister and health secretary four times between 2023 and 2026 about his fears that patients were continuing to die during surgery at ARI. asserted
patients → contact → ARI
His first contact was on June 14, 2023, where he begged health secretary Michael Matheson and First Minister Humza Yousaf to open a public inquiry into the scandal. asserted
he → beg → scandal
Emails show Holyrood officials discussing Dr Habib’s concerns about NHS Grampian with Nick Fluck – the health board’s Medical Director. asserted
officials → show → Fluck
One message sent on July 13, 2023 from an unnamed civil servant to Mr Fluck stated Dr Habib’s letter ‘has come to the FM and Cab Sec here’ and said: ‘I plan to keep our contribution to the response very high level. asserted
I → send → response
From the clinical point of view basically just saying that we are aware of the issue, and that you have been keeping CMO [Chief Medical Officer] regularly up to date with progress etc. asserted
you → say → progress
I don’t plan to go into any detail in it. asserted
I → plan → it
So please let me know if you have any concerns about that approach. asserted
you → let → approach
Mr Fluck responded four minutes later saying: ‘Approach sounds good’. asserted
Approach → respond → ?
Just half an hour later the unnamed government official sent Mr Fluck part of the response to Dr Habib, asking him whether ‘you think there are any actual factual inaccuracies in it’ before it is sent to the Government’s ‘policy team’. asserted
it → send → team
Humza Yousaf was contacted in 2023 by Dr Habib but has refused to say if he saw his emails The desperate surgeon received a response from a civil servant on July 14, stating they were unable to handle whistleblowing concerns, and directing Dr Habib to a variety of other sources. asserted
they → contact → sources
Dr Habib told The Mail on Sunday: ‘They have known for a decade that patients were dying who shouldn’t have. asserted
who → tell → decade
I tried my very best as a surgeon to keep calling it out, because this was always about the right to life. asserted
this → try → life
‘I believe full disclosure of every email, and meetings of minutes needs to take place now; this would reveal what actually took place.’ asserted
what → believe → place
His lawyer Aamer Anwar added: ‘This evidence raises a variety of difficult and obvious questions for the government: why did they seek approval from the health board on how to respond to Dr Habib, when it was this same health board at the centre of the allegations being made by Dr Habib? ' asserted
it → add → Habib
And how can it be that the CMO, his deputies, and policy officials at the Scottish government all knew about Dr Habib’s request, yet ministers knew nothing about it? asserted
ministers → know → it
‘The concerns of Dr Habib were not a fantasy - they were backed up by the 2022 report. asserted
they → back → report
‘Humza Yousaf and Gregor Smith must now provide a full account of what they knew about Dr Habib’s letters.’ asserted
they → provide → letters
The Scottish Government did not respond to any questions about the emails or why officials discussed Dr Habib's concerns with NHS Grampian. asserted
officials → respond → Grampian
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support