A mathematician at Anthropic is contending that the San Francisco-based artificial intelligence (AI) company’s software has helped crack one of the most important unsolved problems in mathematics.
asserted
software → contend → mathematics
Levent Alpöge, a Turkish American mathematician, on Friday posted a note on his personal website saying that Claude, the AI software, had helped prove the Riemann hypothesis.
asserted
Claude → post → hypothesis
He says that Claude helped develop a solution to the problem during the course of about six weeks.
asserted
Claude → say → weeks
If Alpöge’s claim is ultimately confirmed, the proof could mark another breakthrough in the use of AI for complicated math problems – even as mathematicians express uneasiness around extremely lucrative private companies dishing out millions of dollars for the technology to solve problems.
uncertain
mathematicians → confirm → problems
“Claude and I have had a great time together with such breadth in recent months, but this time Claude far outpaced me near the finish line,” Alpöge wrote, while anthropomorphizing the AI software.
asserted
Alpöge → have → software
“No, Claude flew, and danced, and sparkled near that finish line.”
asserted
Claude → fly → line
Alpöge linked to computer code – written in a language called Lean – that he maintained could verify the findings.
uncertain
he → link → findings
Mathematicians subsequently began working to see if Alpöge’s proof could be confirmed.
uncertain
proof → begin → ?
Alpöge’s note was published just one day after Anthropic went public on the Nasdaq stock market index.
asserted
Anthropic → publish → index
He acknowledged that, writing: “The precise timing is horrible.
asserted
timing → acknowledge → that
If I could have, I’d have finished this all much earlier.”
uncertain
I → have → this
The Riemann hypothesis is a nearly 170-year-old math problem named after Bernhard Riemann, a German mathematician who proposed it in 1859.
asserted
who → name → 1859
The hypothesis deals with prime numbers – whole numbers greater than 1 that can only be divided by themselves and 1.
asserted
that → deal → themselves
Riemann questioned how often prime numbers appear and how they are distributed along the number line.
asserted
they → question → line
And he developed a formula for estimating how many prime numbers exist under a specific number.
asserted
numbers → develop → number
The Riemann hypothesis is one of the seven Millennium prize math problems selected in 200 by the Clay Mathematics Institute.
asserted
hypothesis → select → Institute
The institute has offered $1m for each problem solved.
asserted
institute → offer → problem
Mathematicians have been attempting to solve this problem for years.
asserted
Mathematicians → attempt → years
The New York Times reported that on Friday, an independent mathematician in Italy released an incomplete proof of the Riemann hypothesis that he said he had been working on for almost 12 years.
asserted
he → report → years
That mathematician, Alessandro Masullo, said he did not use AI because he did not fully trust the system.
asserted
he → say → system
Other mathematicians have expressed discomfort with relying on AI to solve math problems.
asserted
mathematicians → express → problems
In September, Anthropic competitor OpenAI claimed that a non-public version of its AI tools helped solve part of another Millennium prize problem.
asserted
version → claim → problem
But it was solved in a way that struck mathematicians and observers in a way many found strange: a near-trillion-dollar private company spent $15m to employ 10,000 AI systems to solve the problem.
asserted
company → solve → problem
Alpöge was working on that separate problem for Anthropic when OpenAI made its announcement.
asserted
OpenAI → work → announcement
University of Warwick mathematician James Robinson told the Guardian in September that “it’s frustrating to see these big tech companies burning this fuel up just so that they can show off about how great their latest model is”.
asserted
model → tell → fuel
He added: “It seems like immature playground boasting writ large, underpinned by billions of dollars and the potential for significant environmental damage in an age when climate change is probably the biggest challenge we face.”
asserted
we → add → age