While serving a federal prison sentence for his involvement in the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes got a tattoo showing a defiant Donald Trump after the Butler, Pennsylvania shooting.
asserted
Rhodes → serve → shooting
It marked an extreme display of loyalty to the Republican president but that allegiance has now entirely vanished.
asserted
allegiance → mark → president
Speaking at a yellow table outside an Irving, Texas gastropub, Rhodes delivered a scathing reassessment of the leader he once sought to keep in office.
asserted
he → speak → office
"I am absolutely done with Trump," Rhodes said, labeling him not only a traitor but "one of the very worst in our nation's history.
asserted
Rhodes → do → history
His rejection shows how support for the president has frayed even among his most fervent past defenders.
asserted
support → show → defenders
Six years ago, Rhodes was convicted of seditious conspiracy after attempting to block the transfer of power following the 2020 election, attributing Trump’s loss to Democrat Joe Biden to widespread fraud.
asserted
Rhodes → convict → fraud
Following recent historic Democratic electoral victories in Texas, however, Rhodes pointed to a different cause of his complete reversal.
asserted
Rhodes → follow → reversal
"The lion’s share is because Trump pissed off his own base," Rhodes said.
asserted
Rhodes → piss → base
Dressed in a black cowboy hat, he wore an eye patch over his left eye—the result of a previous firearms accident—leaving a single blue iris visible.
asserted
he → dress → iris
Nearby, attendees gathered with drinks during his Christian Warriors After-Party, held alongside a three-day event titled "Christ is King: America After Trump."
asserted
Christ → gather → Trump
Several visitors stopped to greet him, inquire about joining the Oath Keepers, or sign up for training sessions in community defense and disaster response.
asserted
visitors → stop → defense
Rhodes’ split from Trump
Rhodes traced the initial fracture in his loyalty to Trump's clemency decisions.
asserted
split → trace → decisions
While the president granted full pardons to hundreds incarcerated over the Jan. 6 Capitol assault, he merely commuted Rhodes’ prison sentence.
asserted
he → grant → sentence
"That was the first inkling," Rhodes stated.
asserted
Rhodes → state → ?
Further policy decisions deepened the rift.
asserted
decisions → deepen → rift
Rhodes condemned Trump's military actions involving Iran as a betrayal of his commitments to end overseas military conflicts.
asserted
Rhodes → condemn → conflicts
He also expressed anger when Trump brushed aside calls to publish government files connected to Jeffrey Epstein, dismissing those making the demands as "PAST supporters."
asserted
Trump → express → supporters
Ultimately, Rhodes concluded that the administration had abandoned its core campaign pledge.
asserted
administration → conclude → pledge
"We elected him to end the corruption in Washington, D.C. ‘Drain the swamp.’
asserted
We → elect → swamp
Unfortunately his administration has been one of the most corrupt administrations in U.S. history," Rhodes said, adding, "The pardons are pay-for-play and everything is pay-for-play."
asserted
everything → say → play
The White House didn’t respond to AP’s requests for comment about Rhodes' remarks.
asserted
House → respond → remarks
Sam Jackson, an associate professor at the University at Albany who researches anti-government movement dynamics, noted that such reversals fit a broader ideological pattern.
asserted
reversals → research → pattern
"They went from seeing Donald Trump as their ally in this fight against the conspiracy, to actually being co-opted by the conspiracy," Jackson said, adding that the shift "points to deeper consistency in that understanding of the world as driven by hidden, evil actors."
A graduate of Yale Law School who previously worked for former U.S. Rep. Ron Paul of Texas, Rhodes established the Oath Keepers in 2009.
asserted
Rhodes → go → 2009
The group aimed to recruit military and law enforcement personnel to refuse orders they deemed unconstitutional, including gun confiscation or searches conducted without a warrant.
asserted
they → aim → warrant
Rhodes eventually aligned his organization with Trump’s political agenda.
asserted
Rhodes → align → agenda
After the 2020 election, the Oath Keepers mobilized behind efforts to prevent the certification of the results.
asserted
Keepers → mobilize → results
According to federal prosecutors, members assembled weapons caches, conducted tactical exercises, and traveled to Washington, where a number of them joined the breach of the Capitol building.
uncertain
number → accord → building
Though Rhodes never entered the Capitol building, he was sentenced to 18 years in prison—among the longest handed down in connection with Jan. 6—after claiming in court that he was a victim of unfair prosecution and "illegality."
During sentencing, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta highlighted the risk Rhodes posed: "You are smart, you are charismatic and compelling and frankly that’s what makes you dangerous," the judge said.
asserted
judge → enter → risk
"The moment you are released, whenever that may be, you will be ready to take up arms against your government.
uncertain
you → release → government
Watching from prison when Trump was shot
While serving his sentence, Rhodes watched Trump launch his political comeback.
asserted
Trump → watch → comeback
He recalled seeing the Butler assassination attempt on a jail TV alongside fellow prisoners.
asserted
He → recall → prisoners
Watching Trump raise his fist and shout "fight," Rhodes initially believed divine intervention had protected the candidate.
asserted
intervention → watch → candidate
Following his victory in the 2024 presidential election, Trump issued broad pardons to hundreds of individuals prosecuted for Jan. 6 offenses, including those convicted of assaulting police officers.
asserted
Trump → follow → officers
Rhodes, however, received only a commutation, leaving his criminal record intact at the time.
asserted
Rhodes → receive → time
"He let us out of prison.
asserted
He → let → prison
I didn’t get a pardon though," Rhodes said.
asserted
Rhodes → get → pardon
Earlier this year, the Department of Justice vacated Rhodes’ conviction, restoring his legal standing.
asserted
Department → vacate → standing
He is now focused on reviving the Oath Keepers, which once claimed tens of thousands of members nationwide.
asserted
which → focus → members
Upon regaining his rights, Rhodes prioritized obtaining firearms.
asserted
Rhodes → regain → firearms
Though he did not register to vote before the latest election, he insisted he had no intention of participating.
asserted
he → register → intention
…and 2 more, not listed.