As Canada seeks to become less dependent on the United States, Prime Minister Mark Carney has chosen to pursue new opportunities with China.
asserted
Carney → seek → China
The potential rewards are obvious, but what about the dangers of drawing closer to Beijing?
asserted
rewards → draw → Beijing
Michael Kovrig, one of the “two Michaels” wrongly detained in China, spoke with the Star to offer his theory on why Canada is doing this, what a win for us would look like, and what our government must do to protect Canadian interests — and Canadians.
asserted
government → detain → interests
You personally have an interesting vantage point, I’m sure more than you wish you did.
asserted
you → have → point
But on top of your own awful experience in China, you’re also now in Europe, working with our allies there and representing Canadian interests and viewpoints.
asserted
you → ’re → interests
Europe is also struggling to calibrate its relationship with China.
asserted
Europe → struggle → China
I’ll have specific things to ask you about Canada and China, but to the extent one can snappily summarize an entire planet, what do you feel is happening right now with Canada, Europe, the U.S. and China?
asserted
you → have → Canada
What’s the frame you put around all of this?
asserted
you → ’ → this
Because it’s a lot.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Many dynamics are playing out in one story about geopolitical power.
asserted
dynamics → play → power
The liberal international order the United States and its allies built after the Second World War is under unprecedented strain.
asserted
States → build → strain
America under President Donald Trump has grown weary of underwriting that order and is turning its leverage on its own allies to extract more benefits for itself, while taking a transactional approach to dealing with the two rival great powers.
asserted
America → grow → powers
Russia’s Vladimir Putin is demanding a sphere of influence in Europe and trying to wreck the current system and break NATO.
asserted
Putin → demand → NATO
Under Xi Jinping, China’s ruling Communist Party wants to divide the West, dominate East Asia, and make other countries so economically dependent that they defer to Beijing and enable it to steadily reshape the system along more authoritarian lines.
asserted
they → rule → lines
That dynamic will play out before the cameras at the APEC summit in Shenzhen as Trump, Xi and Putin sit down in a distorted remake of the Yalta conference: three strongmen who think they alone should decide how to run the world.
asserted
they → play → world
For small and middle powers that’s a much tougher world to survive in.
asserted
that → ’ → powers
To counterbalance the big three, these countries need to work together.
asserted
countries → counterbalance → three
Countries like Canada face a volatile America, an aggressive Russia and a coercive China all at once, even as their economies face a second China Shock in the form of an export flood of state-supported manufactured goods, which is hollowing out industries, even in Germany.
asserted
which → face → Germany
As I’ve chronicled on my Substack, without U.S. leadership, these countries have been unable to mount an effective response.
asserted
countries → chronicle → response
Instead their leaders have been going to visit Xi one by one, seeking tariff relief and a way to show Trump they have options.
asserted
they → go → options
Carney’s meeting with Xi, which added pork and seafood to the deal he made in January, is the latest example.
asserted
he → add → January
Each trip is defensible — our farmers and fishers need markets.
asserted
farmers → need → markets
But one by one, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is picking off these countries and coercing them into accepting terms that are increasingly unbalanced, and that give Beijing evermore leverage against them.
asserted
that → pick → them
China spent decades becoming an economic powerhouse, and now the CCP’s turning that into geopolitical leverage to get what it wants.
asserted
it → spend → what
My read is that the PM is trying to do three things at once: manage Trump, bargain with Xi and make Canada’s economy more resilient and diversified.
asserted
economy → try → Xi
Washington has the greatest capacity to do economic harm, so with Trump, Carney has focused on damage control.
asserted
Carney → have → control
Beijing sees an opportunity to drive a wedge, and so has become more willing to offer some pain relief by removing its punitive tariffs on Canadian agri-food in exchange for Canada opening to imports of its state-supported electric vehicles, steel and aluminum.
asserted
Canada → see → vehicles
Ottawa is trying to use each relationship for leverage with the other.
asserted
Ottawa → try → other
Carney said Monday that if we can’t keep an integrated North American auto sector, there will be “other options” — including China.
asserted
we → say → China
He called that “action, reaction.”
asserted
He → call → that
Trump adviser Peter Navarro called it “offensive in the extreme.”
asserted
Navarro → call → extreme
It’s a risky gambit and the open question is whether it helps or hurts Canada in ongoing negotiations with both capitals.
asserted
it → ’ → capitals
Meanwhile, the Chinese aren’t really playing for short-term trade concessions: their goals are political silence and acquiescence, and entrenching economic dependence and creating leverage for future coercion.
asserted
goals → play → coercion
That puts Beijing and Washington at cross-purposes, and it’s going to become increasingly hard to satisfy the demands of both at once.
asserted
it → put → both
When push comes to shove, Ottawa will have to make painful choices.
asserted
Ottawa → come → choices
I think I understand what Carney is trying to do.
asserted
Carney → think → what
We’re clearly pursuing ties with other countries and blocs — the European Union being an obvious example of this.
asserted
Union → pursue → this
If you want to rapidly diminish one’s economic dependence on the U.S., China is hard to ignore.
asserted
China → want → U.S.
China has an economic scale that is undeniably attractive for us, in the circumstances.
asserted
that → have → circumstances
There’s also undeniable risks in dealing with China, which is something I hardly need to explain to you.
asserted
I → ’ → you
…and 29 more, not listed.