Camilla Cavendish is an award-winning journalist, broadcaster, and policy expert.
asserted
Cavendish → win → ?
She writes a weekly OpEd column for The Financial Times where she is a Contributing Editor.
asserted
she → write → Times
Camilla is the author of Generation Maybe: Why We’re Having Fewer Children and What It Means For Us All.
asserted
It → have → Us
In this week’s conversation, Yascha Mounk and Camilla Cavendish discuss why plummeting fertility rates are more concerning than overpopulation; how dating apps, the “romance famine,” and the rise of intensive parenting are keeping people from having the children they want; and what governments and employers can do to close the “heartache gap.”
asserted
governments → discuss → gap
I’m really excited to talk to you again and to talk to you about your new book.
asserted
I → ’m → book
To take a step back, I am quite worried about the decline in fertility around the world.
asserted
I → take → world
I think smart listeners of this podcast are starting to get and understand that this is an actual problem, but I’m struck by the extent to which the default assumption of a lot of people still is the opposite, which is that we have too many people in the world, humans are bad for the world, everybody’s going to starve, and we’re going to use too many resources.
asserted
we → think → resources
Before we get into the really interesting things that you found about why there’s been a decline in fertility and so on, why should we worry about that?
asserted
we → get → that
Why shouldn’t we be grateful that the world population is not exploding and so on and so forth?
asserted
population → explode → ?
Well, Yascha, this is exactly where I started because I also think we do have too many people in the world at the moment.
asserted
we → start → moment
I wrestled with that when I realised that this was the defining trend of our time.
asserted
this → wrestle → time
The answer is that we’re going to hit peak humans much sooner than the forecasters have expected.
asserted
forecasters → go → humans
By 2060, possibly sooner, the human population on the planet is going to stabilize and then it’s going to start falling really quite fast.
uncertain
it → go → planet
We see that already in Europe, we see it in most of the OECD, and it’s actually exponential.
asserted
it → see → OECD
A little gentle downward trend is something we could argue the planet really needs, and climate change will be helped by that.
uncertain
change → argue → that
Imagine that in South Korea today, where the birth rate has just gone up very slightly from 0.7 to 0.8, for every 100 South Koreans today, they’re going to have around 12 grandchildren.
asserted
they → imagine → grandchildren
That describes the magnitude of the effect.
asserted
That → describe → effect
Even if you were to think it was a good thing, you have to consider the rapid transition and how we need to adapt to that.
asserted
we → think → that
Obviously, in these industrial societies with very low fertility rates, of which there are more and more, it’s going to create huge problems.
asserted
it → be → problems
I guess the other point is that even worldwide, a lot of projections now show that the world population is about to peak in a number of decades and then will start to decline.
asserted
population → guess → decades
When you look at some of the regions that still have a lot more fertility than others, where there is still rapid population growth, they’re actually declining in fertility faster than regions like Latin America did at a similar stage of economic development.
asserted
regions → look → development
The other thing that I just find striking is that predictions of fertility have been overly generous all along.
asserted
predictions → find → fertility
In each country, at every juncture, we thought there were going to end up being more people than there used to be, and then fertility fell faster than it did.
asserted
it → think → juncture
This is why it’s so fascinating.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Demography is difficult because we are always looking backwards.
asserted
we → look → ?
You can only tell how many people are in any cohort once every woman in that cohort has reached around 45.
asserted
woman → tell → 45
Demographers are always looking in the rear-view mirror anyway, but as you said, they’ve got it significantly wrong.
asserted
it → look → mirror
I think what has stunned people is the global extent of this.
asserted
stunned → think → this
As we know, China’s working-age population peaked some time ago.
asserted
population → know → ?
It can’t make up those numbers through immigration, even if it wanted to, because it’s too big.
asserted
it → make → immigration
Yes, it’s automating its way out of that, but it still doesn’t have much of a welfare state, and it’s going to have a rapidly aging population, which is going to create real problems for its economy and potentially its military prowess as well further down the line.
Mounk
asserted
which → automate → line
You see that countries which a lot of people might think still have this rapid population growth are below replacement rate.
uncertain
lot → see → rate
That is true now, I believe, of Mexico; it’s true, I believe, of Thailand; it’s true of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
asserted
it → believe → Iran
Countries that historically you would associate with places where people, for either economic reasons or for religious reasons, have a lot of children are below the replacement rate.
asserted
people → associate → rate
Talk us a little bit through some of the main problems that this actually poses to societies.
asserted
this → talk → societies
There was a really fascinating poll in France recently where voters were asked how many working people they thought there were per pensioner in the country.
asserted
they → be → country
On the center-right, which is the part of the spectrum that is most open to pension reform, they said it’s about four to one.
asserted
it → say → one
The actual answer, I believe, is 1.7 or 1.8 to 1.
asserted
I → believe → 1
Obviously there are things like the sustainability of a pension system, but is that just it?
asserted
that → be → system
Is it just that we need kids so that they can pay for us when we’re old, or is it other things where we should be worrying?
asserted
we → need → us
…and 369 more, not listed.