Now that Quebecor has made its improbable offer to buy a much larger rival, Telus, in a deal worth about $31 billion that requires federal approval, Ottawa must decide whether that combination would benefit Canada as much as a megamerger of Telus and Bell Canada.
asserted
combination → make → Telus
The first of those deals would shrink the current four-member telecom oligopoly to just three players: Quebecor, the Bell Canada arm of BCE Inc., and Rogers Communications Inc.
asserted
first → shrink → Inc.
The second would also reduce competition but create one of the world’s biggest telecoms.
asserted
second → reduce → telecoms
For years, Ottawa has tried to nurture more competition in the telecom sector.
asserted
Ottawa → try → sector
But its reaction to last Monday’s announcement by Quebecor of its Telus bid was not “Does this diminish affordability for an essential service in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis?”
asserted
this → diminish → crisis
Instead, the question was, “How could a telecom merger advance national security and Canada’s global influence?”
uncertain
merger → advance → security
Bay Street has caught the drift.
asserted
Street → catch → drift
“We could see Bell getting involved,” analyst Maher Yaghi of Scotiabank said in a report this week.
uncertain
Yaghi → see → report
So can Telus, which said, “all options are on the table” when asked about a deal with other telecoms.
asserted
options → say → telecoms
This week, Prime Minister Mark Carney suggested he would not stand in the way of a reduction in the number of Canada’s major telecoms.
uncertain
he → suggest → telecoms
“Depending on the market structure, the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition with fewer players under certain circumstances,” Carney said while attending a summit of world leaders in Shenzhen, China.
asserted
Carney → depend → Shenzhen
Carney noted that the telecom industry needs a great deal of investment capital to build out its network.
asserted
industry → note → network
That argues against Quebecor’s proposal of a debt-financed acquisition of Telus.
asserted
That → argue → Telus
Telus said of a potential merger with Quebecor that “a highly levered combined company would be less able to invest in its business.”
asserted
company → say → business
The debt could be a deal-breaker for the Carney government, which could withhold approval of a Quebecor-Telus combination it believes would be undercapitalized.
uncertain
it → withhold → combination
That is a significant change in federal policy, which encouraged competition to put a cap on price inflation.
asserted
which → encourage → inflation
Just three years ago, Ottawa made approval of the 2023 merger of Rogers and Shaw Communications conditional on the sale of Shaw’s Freedom Mobile service to Quebecor.
asserted
approval → make → Quebecor
Quebecor, a newcomer to telecom, effectively replaced Shaw as the fourth member of the oligopoly.
asserted
Quebecor → replace → oligopoly
Carney said “at the same time that we recognize that there needs to be significant investment in, broadly speaking, telecom services.”
asserted
we → say → services
Carney said “at the same time that we recognize that there needs to be significant investment in, broadly speaking, telecom services.”
asserted
we → say → services
Mélanie Joly, the industry minister, must approve any new telecom combinations, and has promised a rigorous examination of a proposed merger’s impact on affordability.
asserted
Joly → approve → affordability
But Joly’s initial response to news of the deal was to emphasize “sovereignty,” and to observe that Quebecor’s proposal comes at a time of “great geopolitical and technological change.
asserted
proposal → emphasize → change
“Accordingly, the government of Canada is updating its policies and frameworks to reflect the need for sovereign connectivity.”
asserted
government → update → connectivity
The Carney government has not been shy about using Canada’s natural resources, manufacturing capacity, and aerospace technology to promote Canada as a reliable trade and security partner.
asserted
government → use → partner
Only a combination of Telus and Bell would create the juggernaut Ottawa requires to achieve its goal of “sovereign connectivity” — in artificial intelligence, quantum computing, defence preparedness, satellites, and undersea cables.
asserted
Ottawa → create → intelligence
Can Quebecor afford a $31-billion Telus takeover?
asserted
Quebecor → afford → takeover
It appears that investors in both Quebecor and Telus want no part of each other.
asserted
investors → appear → other
Quebecor’s share value plunged by about 24 per cent in the days after the firm announced its Telus bid.
asserted
firm → plunge → bid
And while Telus shares have gained about 24 per cent in value at the time of writing, to about $15, that’s still far short of Quebecor’s $19.45 per share offer.
asserted
that → gain → offer
Either Telus investors don’t think Quebecor can pull off a takeover of their company or they don’t want it to.
asserted
it → think → company
After decades of amassing technological infrastructure and a combined customer base of incomparable size, they have the makings of a national champion.
asserted
they → amass → champion
Only BCE and Telus have the heft to, say, build a network of Low Earth orbit (LEO) satellites to compete with Elon Musk’s Starlink service, which is encroaching on Canada.
asserted
which → have → Canada
Bell is reported to have held preliminary discussions this week with Telus about next steps after Quebecor’s bid.
asserted
Bell → report → bid
Together, BCE and Telus generate an average annual $43.2 billion in revenues, compared with $24.2 billion by a Quebecor-Telus combination.
asserted
BCE → generate → combination
Current combined assets of Bell and Telus are $140 billion to Quebecor-Telus’ $72 billion.
asserted
assets → combine → Telus
So, if Ottawa is prepared to sacrifice affordability on the altar of national security, if should go all the way and create a telecom of global size and capability, able to protect our “sovereign connectivity” and that of our allies.
asserted
if → sacrifice → allies
That might not be an attractive tradeoff for Canadian consumers.
But in a world that Carney describes as “ruptured,” it might seem to him an imperative.
uncertain
it → describe → him