You see the promise on airline booking screens, shipping boxes, electronics and grocery aisles: “Carbon neutral.”
asserted
You → see → screens
Those labels rest on the comforting premise that even when companies and countries keep burning fossil fuels, the resulting pollution can be canceled out by simply capturing the carbon and locking it away.
asserted
pollution → rest → it
Recently, along with my colleagues at ProPublica and Drilled, I investigated how the world came to rely so heavily on this premise, particularly in the technology known as carbon capture and storage.
asserted
world → investigate → capture
CCS aims to trap carbon dioxide that would otherwise be warming the atmosphere and pump it thousands of feet below Earth’s surface, where, ideally, it stays put.
asserted
it → aim → surface
The oil industry has long favored the idea.
asserted
industry → favor → idea
At the industry’s prodding, the United Nations has effectively endorsed the idea that the technology can work at a massive scale.
asserted
technology → endorse → scale
Over the last two weeks, world leaders and negotiators met in Antalya, Turkey, for the U.N.’s annual flagship climate summit, where nations hash out global commitments to curb warming.
asserted
nations → meet → warming
A central foundation of these negotiations — and many of those carbon-neutrality labels and climate pledges — is the expectation that we can bury billions of tons of CO2 a year, an operation that would rival today’s entire global oil industry within just a couple of decades.
asserted
that → bury → decades
Yet our reporting found that expectation rests on thin evidence.
asserted
expectation → find → evidence
After three decades of development, only 12 large-scale geologic storage projects have ever been built, and at least seven have underperformed or failed.
asserted
seven → build → development
Last year, the world buried less CO2 underground than a single large power plant emits annually.
asserted
plant → bury → CO2
Why do world leaders keep staking climate policy on a technology that remains unproven?
asserted
that → keep → technology
Because the models they all rely on to guide their approach have already presumed that it will work.
asserted
it → rely → approach
I spoke to more than 100 experts for this series, including several members of the wildly powerful group of people who build and run those models.
asserted
who → speak → models
Their simulations of the economy and environment map out how specific choices, like retiring coal plants or electrifying vehicles, could prevent warming catastrophic enough to submerge cities like Miami.
uncertain
choices → retire → Miami
Which means that if they’re wrong, Miami could pay the price.
uncertain
Miami → mean → price
One chart laid bare to me exactly how wrong they’ve been about CCS.
asserted
they → lay → CCS
It compares one prominent model’s projections for CCS with their projections for solar power, a technology so abundantly tested and proven that you can likely spot a panel out the nearest window:
asserted
you → compare → window
Carbon Capture Capacity Has Never Come Close to Projections
Meanwhile, solar electricity production has grown rapidly, far outpacing projections.
asserted
production → Come → projections
I wanted to understand what could possibly account for such a disparity.
uncertain
what → want → disparity
But the problem is the models are opaque: Unlike most scientists, who trade in public, peer-reviewed studies, modelers aren’t required to document every assumption they build into their influential simulations.
asserted
they → trade → simulations
So I tracked down the leaders of the world’s three most influential climate models — one based in the Netherlands, another in Germany and a third in Austria — and asked.
asserted
I → track → Austria
Here’s what I learned:
asserted
I → ’ → what
Climate models assume it’s easy and efficient to capture carbon.
asserted
it → assume → carbon
It’s not.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Public data is hard to come by, but several analyses have found the real capture rates are far lower than the industry has promised.
asserted
industry → come → ?
Yet the models calculate as much as a 92% success rate.
asserted
models → calculate → rate
When I pointed out this discrepancy to Keywan Riahi, who leads the Austrian model, he insisted that capturing concentrated CO2 from industrial emissions “is not high-tech, this is very easy to do.”
asserted
this → point → emissions
Riahi told me the models assume a high rate of capture because they factor in incentives such as payouts from carbon taxes and large government subsidies.
asserted
they → tell → taxes
Add those incentives, he argues, and the capture rates would increase.
asserted
rates → add → incentives
They don’t account for problems that come up in real-world practice.
asserted
that → account → practice
In project after project, operators have struggled to inject as much carbon into the earth as they say they can.
asserted
they → struggle → earth
For instance, at Chevron’s Gorgon natural gas processing plant in Australia, billed as the largest CCS operation on Earth, clogged wells and pressure spikes have forced operators to release most of their CO2 straight into the air.
asserted
wells → bill → air
As it stands, only the German model, led by Jessica Strefler, assumed there’d be any limit to how much CO2 operators could inject underground at once.
uncertain
operators → stand → CO2
But, she told me, there is no good data to work from, and she pegged the limit based on “expert interviews” with people in the industry.
asserted
she → tell → industry
They assume the Earth is a bottomless geologic landfill.
asserted
Earth → assume → ?
Modelers took that cue from a rosy 2005 U.N. report, which I’d learned had been written at the behest of Saudi Arabia and allied petrostates, that portrayed underground storage space as practically limitless.
asserted
that → take → space
(The U.N.’s climate science body has said it stands by the report.
asserted
it → say → report
Scientists who contributed to the report also defended their work.
asserted
who → contribute → work
Authors and editors from Saudi Aramco, Chevron and Shell joined scientists in writing it; the companies did not respond to requests for comment.)
asserted
companies → join → comment
…and 20 more, not listed.