THE interior minister’s call for a referendum on creating new provinces, followed by the information minister’s press conference, seemingly puts the cart before the horse.
asserted
call → create → horse
Consider a citizen told that a new province will bring government closer to their home.
asserted
province → consider → home
What does that mean to them?
asserted
that → mean → them
Will their land dispute be heard more expeditiously or decided more justly?
asserted
dispute → hear → ?
Who will collect their taxes, and how will those revenues be spent?
asserted
revenues → collect → taxes
What does this vision of new provinces look and feel like?
asserted
vision → look → provinces
What will the new administrative arrangements cost, and who will pay?
asserted
who → cost → What
So far, the answers to these questions seem to vary depending on each province.
asserted
answers → seem → province
Without defining what new provinces would actually mean for everyday citizens, a binary question posed nationally can’t provide meaningful insight into the change Pakistanis want.
asserted
Pakistanis → define → change
When developers market a new housing scheme, they show prospective buyers what they intend to build.
asserted
they → market → what
Here, it seems, citizens may be asked to buy into something before knowing what they are buying.
uncertain
they → seem → what
Citizens may be asked to buy into something before knowing what they are buying.
uncertain
they → ask → what
The Constitution already prescribes how provincial boundaries may be altered.
uncertain
boundaries → prescribe → ?
Under Articles 238 and 239, a constitutional amendment requires a two-thirds majority of the total membership of each House of Parliament.
asserted
amendment → require → Parliament
Article 239(4) further requires any bill altering a province’s limits to secure a two-thirds majority of that provincial assembly’s total membership before presidential assent.
asserted
Article → require → assent
A national majority through referendum may favour a change whose costs fall chiefly on the people of one particular province.
uncertain
costs → favour → province
This safeguard gives the people most directly affected, through their elected representatives, a decisive voice.
asserted
safeguard → give → voice
Article 48(6) permits a referendum on a matter of national importance, following approval by a joint sitting of parliament, while Article 48(7) provides for legislation governing its procedure.
asserted
Article → permit → procedure
Yet neither parliamentary approval for a referendum nor its result can substitute for the legislative majorities mandated by Article 239.
asserted
approval → substitute → Article
The question remains: can a referendum, by itself, effect the extensive constitutional changes that creating new provinces would entail?
asserted
creating → remain → provinces
The case for a new province should begin with the grievances arising from existing arrangements.
asserted
case → begin → arrangements
If citizens travel hours to reach hospitals or government offices, publish the travel times and service gaps.
asserted
citizens → travel → times
If districts complain of unequal investment, disclose what was allocated and spent.
asserted
what → complain → investment
If communities seek greater control over decisions affecting them, identify the powers they require.
asserted
they → seek → powers
Article 140A already obliges provinces to devolve political, administrative and financial responsibility and authority to elected local governments.
asserted
140A → oblige → governments
Proponents must therefore demonstrate what a new province could achieve that meaningful devolution and stronger district administration cannot.
uncertain
devolution → demonstrate → what
Every proposal should be accompanied by an administrative map and five- and 10-year financial projections.
asserted
proposal → accompany → map
Which districts and divisions would be regrouped?
asserted
districts → regroup → ?
Where would headquarters be located?
asserted
headquarters → locate → ?
How many officials would be required, and what would their offices cost?
asserted
offices → require → what
Who would collect provincial revenues, and within which jurisdictions?
asserted
Who → collect → jurisdictions
How would water resources and gas allocations be determined?
asserted
resources → determine → ?
Do we have answers ready for these vital questions?
asserted
answers → have → questions
The judicial implications deserve equal attention.
asserted
implications → deserve → attention
What high court facilities, district courts and subordinate courts would need to be established or reorganised?
asserted
facilities → need → ?
What would buildings, judges, staff and operations cost?
asserted
buildings → cost → What
Where would litigants go, and what would become of pending cases?
asserted
what → go → cases
Surely, access to justice must be among the measures by which any promise of bringing government closer to citizens is judged.
asserted
promise → bring → citizens
Financial projections must establish what each administration could realistically raise, the federal transfers it would require, and the consequences for National and Provincial Finance Commission arrangements.
uncertain
it → establish → arrangements
Water entitlements, mineral and energy revenues, public assets, debts and pension liabilities cannot be left unresolved.
asserted
entitlements → leave → ?
…and 8 more, not listed.