"The View" co-host Ana Navarro appeared surprised when co-host Sunny Hostin disagreed with her argument that Democratic California Gov. Gavin Newsom should have notified the victims' families before ending the death sentences of 548 inmates in his state.
asserted
Newsom → appear → state
"I don’t like the way it went through.
asserted
it → like → way
And I think that before he announced that, he needed to get the approval and agreement of the families of the victims, because the people that he’s commuted the sentences for are people who are on death row.
asserted
who → think → row
They’re people who committed murder, and I tend to be against blanket pardon to begin with," Navarro said.
asserted
Navarro → ’re → pardon
Newsom commuted the death sentences of all of California's death-row inmates in early November, effectively ending capital punishment in the state years after issuing an executive moratorium on executions.
"I think these are things you have to take on a case-by-case basis, and I think it’s disrespectful to the victims’ families," Navarro said.
asserted
Navarro → commute → families
"You can disagree or agree with the death penalty, but to me, if your loved one has been murdered, you have the right to be told that this is happening, before you read about it."
asserted
you → disagree → it
Hostin said, "I disagree with that."
"That the victim's family should have been told?" Navarro asked in response.
asserted
Navarro → say → response
"Yes," Hostin repeated.
asserted
Hostin → repeat → ?
I think that God gives life."
asserted
God → think → life
Hostin said those cases were under Newsom's purview as governor.
asserted
cases → say → governor
She argued that the system is "broken," and no one should have to pay the ultimate price for a broken system.
asserted
one → argue → system
"One innocent person being put to death is not worth the entire system," she said.
asserted
she → put → death
"And if you look at the system, it's not a deterrent.
asserted
it → look → system
That the statistics show that more than half of death row exonerees are Black, even though Black people just make up 13.6% of the U.S. population.
asserted
people → show → population
"And nearly 60% of the people that are found to have been wrongfully convicted of murder by the Innocence Project are African Americans, and so the system is broken," Hostin continued.
asserted
Hostin → find → Project
"And you should not pay the ultimate price for a system that is broken."
asserted
that → pay → system
Co-host Alyssa Farah Griffin sided with Navarro, arguing the move was a betrayal of the families.
asserted
move → side → families
"It was a betrayal of the families to not notify them beforehand," Griffin said.
asserted
Griffin → notify → them
"People can agree or disagree on the death penalty.
asserted
People → agree → penalty
It's actually come up as a ballot initiative in California twice in the last decade.
asserted
It → come → decade
And California voters actually voted to keep capital punishment in place.
"
asserted
voters → vote → place
I think (Newsom) has the purview to do this, but then to not notify families, that gets in the way of their grief," she added.
asserted
she → think → grief
"There's no greater trauma than having a loved one murdered in a brutal way and thinking it's been adjudicated in the court, and there's a certain outcome in finding out in a newspaper, basically, that that's not happening."
asserted
that → be → newspaper
Griffin also said it could be a political move by Newsom.
uncertain
it → say → Newsom
"This should have been handled better," she said.
asserted
she → handle → ?
"And I think there's a political side to this too.
asserted
I → think → this
He wants to run for president.
asserted
He → want → president
He wants to seem more progressive.
asserted
He → want → ?
Kamala Harris may run for president.
uncertain
Harris → run → president
He's gonna be like, ‘She was a prosecutor who put people in jail.’
asserted
who → go → jail
So, I don't like it.
asserted
I → like → it
He should have notified the families."
asserted
He → notify → families
Co-host Sara Haines agreed, arguing that undoing all the death sentences treated each case the same.
asserted
undoing → agree → case
"I think the point is that if you want to change something going forward, put it on a ballot, and clearly California doesn't want it taken off," she said.
asserted
she → think → ballot
"At that point, I think he should have looked case-by-case, because to not reach out to these families, they get nothing back.
asserted
they → think → nothing
"Any closure they get is small.
asserted
they → get → ?
But some of these people deeply found something in this conviction and this determination.
asserted
some → find → conviction
And to just undo it in one blanket swipe is to treat them all the same."
asserted
undo → undo → them
When reached for comment, the governor's office referred Fox News Digital to a letter Newsom issued explaining his decision.
asserted
Newsom → reach → decision
In part, Newsom wrote, "This decision is among the most difficult of my career, not because I doubt its necessity for our state but because I know its announcement may surface excruciating memories for victims' families.
uncertain
announcement → write → families
…and 10 more, not listed.