Downing Street told reporters on Thursday that Andy Burnham was 'negotiating from a position of strength' as talks on his Brexit reset entered the final straight.
asserted
talks → tell → straight
So it was hard not to give a hollow laugh yesterday morning as UK officials scrambled to try to counter a brutal EU briefing explaining that the whole deal will be in jeopardy unless the Prime Minister agrees to subsidise European students studying at British universities.
asserted
Minister → give → universities
Britain, they explained, has six months to cough up a sum estimated at almost £500 million a year – or the whole deal is off.
asserted
deal → explain → million
A cheer had erupted late on Thursday night as the teams negotiating the three separate strands of the deal reached what they thought was a final agreement.
But, as so often in Brussels, it turned out that the EU had one more trick up its sleeve.
asserted
EU → erupt → sleeve
When Downing Street officials denied the claim, saying the deal was 'done', their EU counterparts got in touch with reporters again to insist: 'No, we meant what we said.'
uncertain
we → deny → what
In other walks of life this might be seen as a ransom demand.
uncertain
this → see → demand
Theresa May experienced the same many times during her tortuous negotiations with Brussels, most famously when she was forced to cave in to EU demands to agree the bloc's extortionate request for a £40 billion 'divorce payment' before it would even start to discuss future trade terms.
uncertain
it → experience → terms
European Council President Antonio Costa, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, and British Prime Minister Andy Burnham meet in Brussels on November 20
Mr Burnham greets Ms der Leyen in Brussels with a kiss on the check ahead of the EU-UK Summit at the EU Council
One veteran British official said: 'This is what the EU does.
asserted
EU → meet → what
You get warm words in public, hardball in private.
asserted
You → get → words
And the PM has walked right into it.'
asserted
PM → walk → it
Even the caterers at the EU's sprawling headquarters in Brussels got in on the act, serving the PM fish and chips for lunch as he prepared to sign a deal that confirms European trawlers will retain access to British fishing grounds until 2038 – a concession that was the price for the EU agreeing to hold talks at all.
asserted
EU → sprawl → talks
Negotiations have reached fever pitch in recent days, but the deal itself has been the subject of discussions with Brussels ever since Labour came to power in 2024.
asserted
Labour → reach → 2024
The genesis of the food and farming agreement was contained in Labour's 2024 manifesto and the framework was agreed by Keir Starmer last year.
asserted
framework → contain → Starmer
But Labour has made a string of key concessions along the way, particularly on the EU's demand to revive a form of free movement for the young.
asserted
Labour → make → young
When Brussels originally floated the idea of a 'youth mobility scheme', Labour rejected it, saying it was 'synonymous with freedom of movement'.
asserted
it → float → movement
But, with Brussels insisting it was the price for co-operation, Sir Keir backed down last year.
asserted
Keir → insist → operation
At the time, the Government said the scheme would be capped at 50,000 people a year and suggested they would only be allowed to stay for 12 months.
uncertain
they → say → months
But Brussels kept pressing for more – and got it.
asserted
Brussels → keep → it
The time limit was extended to three years.
asserted
limit → extend → years
And an effort to hold the cap at 80,000 was finally abandoned on Thursday afternoon as Mr Burnham pushed to get the deal over the line.
asserted
Burnham → hold → line
The final figure of 100,000 is double the number Labour deemed acceptable a year ago.
asserted
Labour → deem → 100,000
And all this in a week when the PM has insisted the Government is focused on finding jobs for the 1 million British youngsters currently not earning or learning – who will now face renewed competition from abroad.
asserted
who → insist → competition
Even this concession was not enough to secure a guarantee that Britain will be exempted from
the EU's protectionist Made In Europe scheme, which threatens ruin for British sectors such as cars and steel.
asserted
which → secure → cars
A last-minute push by France to exclude the UK from having any input at all into future food and farming laws that will apply here threatened to derail the process on Thursday evening.
asserted
that → exclude → evening
One insider claimed the French had eventually 'climbed down from the Himalayas' – but the final agreement leaves the UK unable to block new laws it is opposed to.
asserted
it → claim → laws
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds said the UK would have 'experts in the room' when laws are formulated, with 'the ability to have our say'.
asserted
laws → say → say
But, he conceded: 'We won't have a vote because we're not members of the EU.'
asserted
we → concede → EU
Mr Burnham suggested he had taken up the issue personally with Emmanuel Macron – and bridled at suggestions the arrangement was a democratic 'fig leaf'.
uncertain
arrangement → suggest → suggestions
Only time will tell whether the British officials 'in the room' will be leading discussions or making the tea.
asserted
officials → tell → tea
What is clear is that Parliament will no longer have any say over a sector which generates roughly two new EU laws a day.
asserted
which → have → laws
Mr Burnham also looks certain to give way to EU demands to subsidise university tuition fees – an idea rejected by Sir Keir last year.
asserted
Burnham → look → Keir
Brussels initially suggested cutting EU fees to around £13,000 a year to cover university costs.
uncertain
Brussels → suggest → costs
When British officials finally came back and agreed this week, the EU said it now wanted its students to pay the same as their British counterparts, just under £10,000.
asserted
students → come → counterparts
Exasperated British officials said no, but will surely capitulate next year rather than risk the EU putting the whole deal on ice, leaving the British taxpayer with a bill estimated at £485 million a year.
asserted
officials → say → million
The same goes for British payments into the EU's cohesion funds.
asserted
same → go → funds
UK officials denied any payments would be agreed, but when the final deal was published it included a commitment to a 'UK financial contribution to reducing economic disparities' within the EU.
asserted
it → deny → EU
Some politicians might have been given pause for thought by the bruising reality of negotiating with Brussels.
uncertain
politicians → give → Brussels
EU Council president Antonio Costa pointedly told him that while he would be 'welcome' to rejoin the EU, there would be no special treatment for the UK.
But the PM ploughed on regardless, saying he wanted to spend the next year 'brainstorming' ideas for closer relations with Brussels.
asserted
he → tell → Brussels
Good luck, as they say, with that.
asserted
they → say → that
REVEALED: Details of Andy Burnham's much-disputed EU plan, and what isn't yet agreed
asserted
what → reveal → plan