Mayor Mamdani doubled down Friday on the city’s plan to close Rikers Island, building instead a totally inadequate 4,100 borough-based jail cells for a city with a population of 8.5 million and almost 500,000 reported crimes a year.
asserted
Mamdani → double → million
His plan to reduce the city’s jail population contains all the usual progressive talking points that have been bandied about for the past 10 years: Speed up case processing, more alternative-to-incarceration programs, easier access to bail.
He acts as if none of these has been tried before, when in fact every one of them has.
asserted
one → reduce → them
But missing from the mayor’s press release is any analysis of who is on Rikers today
asserted
who → miss → Rikers
About 1,100 of them are city-sentenced prisoners, parole violators or state-sentenced prisoners awaiting transfer to state prison.
asserted
1,100 → sentence → prison
There’s not much the city can do to release them earlier.
asserted
city → ’ → them
That means if the borough-based jails were today’s reality, we’d have about 3,000 available beds for the 5,606 defendants awaiting trial.
asserted
we → mean → trial
Of those awaiting trial today, 1,433 are charged with murder; 2,625 are charged with a violent felony offense (such as attempted murder, robbery, burglary, rape, weapons possession or assault).
asserted
2,625 → await → murder
That’s 4,058 inmates — enough to fill every one of the 4,100 “neighborhood jail” beds the city is building.
asserted
city → ’ → beds
But with only 3,000 of those beds available, about 1,000 defendants charged with murder or violent felonies will have to be released.
asserted
defendants → charge → murder
And that leaves no room at all in the new jails for the current population of 1,282 non-violent felon inmates (car thieves, pocketbook snatchers, commercial burglars, drug dealers and fraudsters), and 269 misdemeanor inmates (like shoplifters and petty thieves).
asserted
that → leave → shoplifters
Every one of them would need to be released so that the city can accommodate accused murderers, violent felons and non pre-trial detainees in those 4,100 jail beds.
asserted
city → need → beds
Under the bail reform laws passed in 2019 and amended since, a “non-violent” felon or misdemeanor defendant can only have bail set if they’ve committed a crime while out on probation or parole, or have two or more prior felony convictions, or harmed someone while on release for a pending charge of harming someone else.
asserted
they → pass → someone
Even then, they’ve had to be unlucky enough to have been arraigned before one of the few NYC judges who sets bail at all.
asserted
who → have → bail
That is the pool of people Mamdani is looking to put back out on the streets.
asserted
Mamdani → look → streets
Caught up in the anti-Rikers hysteria of 10 years ago, he and his allies believed the hype and ignored the consequences.
Under the 2019 bail reform, the city released thousands of career “non-violent” criminals from jail — and non-violent crime went up.
asserted
crime → catch → jail
When COVID hit, the city released hundreds of violent criminals from jail — and violent crime went up.
asserted
crime → hit → jail
Now Mamdani and his allies are pushing a severely broken city court system to speed up cases in order to reduce the jail population by 800 beds.
asserted
Mamdani → push → beds
Consider: Since 2019, the number of criminal cases pending in NYC rose by 13,253 cases, or 41%.
asserted
number → consider → cases
The entire rest of New York state rose by only 862 cases.
asserted
rest → rise → cases
Speedy-trial dismissals rose 620% in NYC, from 8,282 to 59,572, since 2019; outside NYC, the rise was 75%.
asserted
rise → rise → NYC
The courts have had 10 years to fix that.
asserted
courts → have → that
They haven’t.
asserted
They → have → ?
The mayor’s press release called his plan “The First Comprehensive Plan to Close Rikers Island.”
asserted
release → call → Island
Advertisement
Please: I have a file cabinet full of such plans from Judge Jonathan Lippmann, Mayor Bill DeBlasio and Mayor Eric Adams.
asserted
I → have → Lippmann
Mamdani’s report looks like a cut-and-paste version of any one of those.
asserted
report → look → those
You want to build your community jails?
asserted
You → want → jails
But you’d better build a 5,000-bed backup on Rikers Island for when this plan fails.
asserted
plan → build → Island
Advertisement
Jim Quinn is a retired career prosecutor in the Queens District ¬Attorney’s Office, where he served for 42 years.
asserted
he → serve → years