In its recent budget, Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government noted Canada’s strong private-sector job growth over the past year.
asserted
government → note → year
But it will take more than one year of improved performance to make up for lost ground.
asserted
it → take → ground
Indeed, due primarily to increases in immigration, Canada’s population has grown rapidly in recent years, meaning substantial job creation is necessary to simply keep pace with population growth.
asserted
creation → grow → growth
And much of the recent employment growth has occurred in the government sector, not private businesses.
asserted
much → occur → sector
Our new study — which compares job creation in Canada and the United States between 2019 and 2024, adjusting for changes in the working-age population — casts doubt on any claims about sustained strong Canadian labour-market performance.
uncertain
which → compare → performance
First, during these five years, the number of employed Canadians per 1,000 working-age people remained essentially unchanged.
asserted
number → employ → people
In the U.S., that number increased by 7.6.
asserted
number → increase → 7.6
The composition of job growth also differed.
asserted
composition → differ → growth
Government-sector employment growth outpaced private-sector growth in nine Canadian provinces (with Alberta the lone exception), while in nearly half of U.S. states, private-sector employment grew more quickly than government-sector employment.
asserted
employment → outpace → employment
And the U.S. gained approximately 5.4 private-sector jobs per 1,000 working-age people, while Canada saw a decline of approximately 15 private-sector jobs per 1,000 working-age people.
asserted
Canada → gain → people
Again, this does not mean the total number of private-sector jobs in Canada fell but rather that private-sector job creation was insufficient to keep pace with our expanding working-age population.
asserted
creation → mean → population
And had Canada matched the U.S. rate of population-adjusted private-sector job creation over these five years, Canada would have had approximately 554,000 more private-sector jobs in 2024 than there actually were that year.
asserted
Canada → match → 2024
Private sector produces resources that sustain government activities
Why focus on private sector jobs?
asserted
that → produce → jobs
Private businesses produce goods and services for consumers, and face competitive pressures to invest, innovate and increase productivity.
asserted
businesses → produce → productivity
These activities are fundamental to increasing incomes and living standards.
asserted
activities → increase → incomes
Therefore, private-sector job creation is an important indicator of the strength and dynamism of a market economy — and on this indicator, Canada is clearly struggling.
asserted
Canada → struggle → indicator
Of course, the private sector also produces resources that sustain government activities and employment.
asserted
that → produce → activities
Our study also shows that this weakness is not confined to one province or region.
asserted
weakness → show → province
In nine of Canada’s 10 provinces, from 2019 to 2024, private-sector employment growth failed to keep pace with growth in the working-age population (Newfoundland and Labrador was the only exception).
asserted
Newfoundland → fail → population
In the U.S., by contrast, 32 of the 50 states generated sufficient private-sector employment growth to keep pace with their working-age populations.
asserted
states → generate → populations
Among economically and geographically similar provinces and U.S. states, Ontario and Quebec underperformed nearly all nearby Great Lakes states.
asserted
Ontario → underperform → states
British Columbia ranked last — by a wide margin — among its western American peers.
asserted
Columbia → rank → peers
And Alberta ranked second last among 14 energy-producing jurisdictions.
asserted
Alberta → rank → jurisdictions
Three of the four Atlantic provinces experienced declines in private sector employment (population-adjusted) compared to three of the six New England states.
asserted
provinces → experience → states
The specific details differ across regions, but the overall picture is consistent.
asserted
picture → differ → regions
This year, we saw improved private-sector job growth in Canada.
asserted
we → see → Canada
But a more comprehensive multi-year view reveals chronic weakness in the private sector’s ability to create jobs compared to the private sector in the U.S.
asserted
view → reveal → U.S.
If the Carney government and policymakers across the country want to build on this year’s improved performance, they must create a policy environment that attracts and sustains investment — and in turn helps increase incomes and living standards from coast to coast.
asserted
that → want → coast