More than 35 years after Elizabeth Bain disappeared, Dateline‘s Keith Morrison and Canadian journalist Diana Swain are revisiting a case that has left her family searching for answers.
asserted
that → disappear → answers
Morrison has spent decades telling some of America’s most compelling true-crime stories.
asserted
Morrison → spend → stories
Now, he’s helping promote Dateline Canada, a spinoff of the long-running NBC true-crime series he fronts that will take a fresh look at the disappearance of the young woman who vanished after heading to the University of Toronto’s Scarborough campus on the hot afternoon of June 19, 1990.
asserted
who → help → June
“The first recollection I had of the case is when I saw the picture of Elizabeth.
asserted
I → have → Elizabeth
Back when we put up (missing persons) posters on poles — pre-social media, pre-Internet.
asserted
we → put → poles
I remember seeing that picture,” Swain said in an interview at a downtown Toronto television studio.
asserted
Swain → remember → studio
Three days after she vanished, Bain’s blood-stained car was found across from a nearby autobody shop.
asserted
car → vanish → shop
But despite an exhaustive search, her body has never been found.
asserted
body → find → search
The disappearance of the 22-year-old promising student remains one of Canada’s most puzzling murder mysteries.
asserted
disappearance → remain → mysteries
Bain’s boyfriend, Robert Baltovich, was arrested five months later and convicted of her murder in 1992.
asserted
boyfriend → arrest → 1992
Prosecutors argued that he concocted false alibis and killed her in a fit of rage after learning she planned to break up with him.
asserted
she → argue → him
Baltovich served eight years in prison — losing his mother to cancer while he was behind bars — before being released on bail in 2000.
asserted
he → serve → 2000
After his conviction was overturned in 2004, a new trial was ordered.
asserted
trial → overturn → 2004
By the time the retrial began in 2008, a key part of the Crown’s original case — testimony from witnesses whose memories had been refreshed through hypnosis — was no longer admissible following a 2007 Supreme Court ruling.
asserted
memories → begin → ruling
Convicted serial killer and Scarborough Rapist Paul Bernardo was also raised as a possible suspect in Bain’s disappearance, although police maintained he wasn’t considered a reasonable suspect at the time.
In a videotaped prison interview in June 2007, Bernardo avoided directly answering Toronto police officers when questioned about Bain’s murder.
“The 800-pound gorilla in the room is — that is a life-25 sentence, you know,” Bernardo said.
asserted
Bernardo → convict → room
Bernardo denied any involvement in Bain’s death and said he had never met her.
asserted
he → deny → her
But Swain, a former CBC News investigative correspondent, says Baltovich’s ordeal with the Canadian court system is illuminating.
asserted
ordeal → say → system
“Evidence that was allowed in his first trial is now, by law, not allowed in Canadian trials anymore,” she said.
asserted
she → allow → trials
“When it came to his second trial the ruling was made that evidence that is gained through hypnosis is no longer admissible in Canadian courts.”
asserted
that → come → courts
“Accepting somebody who had been hypnotized in court seems absurd now, but it didn’t at the time,” Morrison added.
asserted
Morrison → accept → time
Special explores three key dimensions of the Elizabeth Bain case
asserted
Special → explore → case
During his initial trial, Baltovich’s lawyers suggested that the Scarborough Rapist — who had not yet been caught — could be a suspect in Bain’s disappearance and murder.
uncertain
who → suggest → disappearance
But police dismissed those claims because the Scarborough Rapist hadn’t murdered any of his victims in the late 1980s or early 1990s.
uncertain
Rapist → dismiss → 1980s
“During Rob Baltovich’s first trial, his defence lawyers were saying, ‘Why aren’t we considering that the Scarborough Rapist may be the real perpetrator here?’ ” Swain explained.
uncertain
Swain → say → trial
“At the time, no one knew who the Scarborough Rapist was.
asserted
Rapist → know → time
Toronto Police said then, and they’ve maintained this, because the Scarborough Rapist didn’t kill anyone they didn’t think that was a reasonable suspect in Elizabeth Bain’s disappearance.
asserted
that → say → disappearance
Canadians learned the identity of the Scarborough Rapist in 1993, when Bernardo was arrested for the murders of Kristen French and Leslie Mahaffy.
asserted
Bernardo → learn → French
But Baltovich had already been sent to prison in 1992.
asserted
Baltovich → send → 1992
Dateline Canada will reexamine the evidence that led to Baltovich’s conviction.
asserted
that → reexamine → conviction
The episode will also revisit the evidence gathered during the Bain investigation and present previously unreported information surrounding her disappearance.
“There were young women attacked by Paul Bernardo in a part of Scarborough where Elizabeth Bain went missing around the same time.
asserted
Bain → revisit → time
The last attack was the end of May in 1990 and she went missing in the middle of June, mere weeks later.
uncertain
she → go → June
There’s interesting information like that that I think we’re able to show people that illuminates this story,” Swain said.
asserted
Swain → ’ → story
“There’s some details about what was found in Elizabeth Bain’s car and one of them was a cigarette butt that no one else who was in her life was connected to.”
asserted
who → ’ → life
Morrison, who wasn’t involved in the creation of the homegrown spinoff, says he’s “thrilled” the long-running NBC show is expanding its footprint.
asserted
show → involve → footprint
“We’ve done stories from Canada on Dateline,” the Lloydminster-born Morrison said, “but it helps that we have a Canadian telling this story.”
asserted
we → do → story
“The countries are very different,” he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
Morrison, who joined Dateline in 1995 after stints with the CBC and CTV, has explored trauma in people’s lives for more than three decades.
asserted
who → join → decades
As the stepfather of the late Matthew Perry, who died in 2023 following an accidental drug overdose, he’s also dealt with his own personal tragedy.
asserted
he → die → tragedy
“It’s a personal thing with Matthew and it’s a personal thing with other people when they have something terrible happen to them,” he said softly.
asserted
he → ’ → them
Morrison says every victim and every story Dateline examines must be approached on its own terms.
asserted
Dateline → say → terms
…and 15 more, not listed.