Rogers is pushing back at rival cable companies that have complained to the federal regulator about the controversial streaming of its Monday Night Hockey package in Canada.
asserted
that → push → Canada
In a preliminary letter to the CRTC posted on Friday, Rogers takes pointed issue with a number of the claims made in the joint complaint filed by Cogeco, Eastlink and SaskTel earlier this month.
uncertain
Rogers → post → Cogeco
And with that, more gloves have been dropped in what has become one of the hottest off-ice stories of this NHL season.
asserted
what → drop → season
Earlier this month, the three rivals accused the telecommunications giant — which owns national NHL rights in Canada — of operating in an anti-competitive manner in the way it distributes its Sportsnet+ streaming service.
asserted
it → accuse → service
The complaint was reflective of the fiery response from hockey fans, many of whom felt they were being coerced into paying $12.99 per month to watch the Monday night package by legal means.
asserted
they → feel → means
On Friday, Rogers made it’s own assertion, dismissively ridiculing its rivals action to the federal broadcast regulator.
asserted
Rogers → make → regulator
“It is difficult to conceive of a more baseless undue preference complaint,” the Rogers letter to the CRTC says.
asserted
letter → conceive → CRTC
“There is no differential treatment nor any question of exclusive or preferential access, and nothing for the Commission to remedy.
asserted
Commission → be → access
“The Commission should not be drawn into a manufactured regulatory dispute founded on allegations that are without merit and plainly contradicted by the facts.”
asserted
that → draw → facts
The letter that was posted Friday was the initial response of Rogers, which began its 12-year, $11-billion rights deal with the NHL this season.
asserted
which → post → NHL
The rebuttal from Rogers was expected, of course.
asserted
rebuttal → expect → course
What likely wasn’t that the ongoing reaction to the streaming initiative would carry on as long and as noisily as it has.
asserted
it → stream → initiative
At issue with its complaining competitors was the claim that Rogers is offering the Monday night package for free to its own subscribers while imposing the $12.99 monthly surcharge to other cable companies.
uncertain
Rogers → complain → companies
The argument from the complainants was that Rogers handling of the practice was anti-competitive.
“Rogers’ anti-competitive practice forms part of an overt, systemic strategy of market foreclosure designed to starve competing service providers of ‘must-have’ programming and systematically undermine retail competition across Canada’s broadcasting sector,” the complaint reads.
asserted
complaint → form → sector
“Without swift, decisive, and binding regulatory intervention by the Commission, this predatory siphoning of must-have live sports content — chief among it Monday night NHL hockey (‘Monday Night Hockey‘) — will inflict immediate and irreversible structural damage on the Canadian broadcasting ecosystem.”
asserted
siphoning → inflict → ecosystem
For its part, Rogers would argue that it is simply doing business.
asserted
it → argue → business
With the record rights deal, the bills have come due, in other words.
asserted
bills → come → words
In fact, from the outset, Rogers has claimed its rivals had options in terms of pricing Monday Night Hockey.
asserted
rivals → claim → Hockey
Why does Rogers feel the complaint as baseless?
asserted
Rogers → feel → complaint
In its preliminary letter to the regulator, Rogers maintains that it has implored its rivals to negotiate (presumably on the price of the package) and that none of the three providers have yet to get a response to those overtures.
asserted
none → maintain → overtures
“RMI (Rogers Media) has repeatedly sought to negotiate the distribution rights with each of the Complainant(s), yet not one has engaged,” the letter reads.
asserted
letter → seek → Complainant(s
“The Complainants have not been denied access to SN+ Streaming Content, nor have they been offered less favourable terms than RCCI (Rogers cable) … they have not even attempted to negotiate those terms.”
asserted
they → deny → terms
And for the kicker, Rogers rather pointedly implores the regulator to essentially ignore the complaints.
asserted
Rogers → implore → complaints
“Rather than initiate a public process in response (to a complaint) that lacks any legal or regulatory foundation and appears designed to generate headlines, the Commission should direct the Complainants to do what they should have done in the first place: Negotiate with RMI.”
asserted
they → initiate → RMI
What have hockey fans been saying?
asserted
fans → say → What
Predictably, those Canadian hockey fans who are not Rogers subscribers have been outraged at having to cough up more cash for the Monday night package.
asserted
who → have → package
In fact, the Sportsnet+ controversy has been one of the big stories of this NHL season in Canada as viewers spew their enough-is-enough outrage.
asserted
viewers → spew → outrage
The rivals fighting Rogers at the CRTC level have seemingly tapped into that anger.
asserted
rivals → fight → anger
“What begins today as a handful of regular-season NHL games and playoff rounds will inevitably escalate to the Stanley Cup final and the season finale of hit TV shows, creating an unchecked slippery slope that starves independent (cable companies) of of vital content and dismantles the integrity of Canada’s entire broadcasting system,” the initial complaint by the three rivals says.
asserted
complaint → begin → rivals
It certainly doesn’t help that the Monday night package includes 13 Maple Leafs games (though given their current form, that isn’t exactly an endorsement for new subscribers.
asserted
that → help → subscribers
Industry observers see Rogers and Sportsnet as pushing the envelope, perhaps to see what the breaking point might be for fans.
uncertain
point → see → fans
“What Rogers is doing right now is trying to find the equilibrium point, the sweet spot,” Michael Naraine, an associate professor of sport management at Brock University, told the Toronto Sun in our earlier reporting of this story.
asserted
Naraine → do → story
“At what point do Leafs fans say, ‘This is too much?’
asserted
This → say → ?
At what point are people going to stop consuming?”
asserted
people → go → ?