This article was written by Jason Foster and published on Sport & State, a new media company founded by Clay Travis that is built around sports, culture, original voices, and live conversation.
asserted
that → write → sports
* *
Labor negotiations often come with theater as both sides make big pronouncements, trade barbs and insults, threaten to walk, and have dramatic give and take before they ultimately settle on a deal.
But sometimes, before that final agreement, there’s also deception, as one side or the other backs off a big ask late in the process to seem as though they’re making a significant sacrifice, when in reality that big ask was never the true goal but something used to make the real prize more digestible when unveiled.
asserted
prize → come → reality
With that in mind, here’s a thought exercise:
asserted
exercise → ’ → mind
As we head toward a certain MLB lockout and some very contentious collective bargaining negotiations, what if the owners aren’t really after a salary cap?
asserted
owners → head → cap
Obviously, the owners want a salary cap.
asserted
owners → want → cap
Commissioner Rob Manfred even said Wednesday that he “can’t imagine” the owners approving any proposal without a cap and floor.
asserted
owners → say → cap
It’s what you’d expect him to say, especially four months before there’s any serious threat to the 2027 season.
asserted
him → ’ → season
But the message has been clear for a while: They really mean it this time!
asserted
They → mean → it
Here’s the thing, though: The owners know they won’t get a cap, at least not without some drastic development, given the players union’s solidarity going back decades.
asserted
they → ’ → solidarity
It’s a thought worth considering.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Rob Manfred says that MLB will not “compromise” on the issue of a salary cap and floor https://t.co/pLUrHDpIT6
— SNY (@SNYtv) November 18, 2026
The MLB Players Association has been adamantly against a cap for decades, despite being the only major North American league without one.
asserted
Association → say → one
It’s always been a non-starter, no matter what carrots the owners may float (shorter season, higher minimum salary, etc.).
uncertain
owners → float → carrots
And despite both sides indicating that they’d potentially sacrifice an entire season to win the negotiations, I don’t think either is actually willing to do that.
asserted
either → indicate → that
There’s way too much immediate money to be lost for both sides if MLB went dark for a year, not to mention the long-term effects of a sports public that would learn to live without baseball.
asserted
that → ’ → baseball
That’s why I think there’s a decent chance the owners back off a cap just in time to play something at least close to a full season.
asserted
owners → ’ → season
But what might “Plan B” look like?
uncertain
B → look → what
It’s hard to say.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
But there’s likely no one big thing that would replace a cap, but perhaps a combination of things that could be included with, for example, a higher minimum salary and a quicker path to free agency.
uncertain
that → ’ → agency
A possible package could include …
(I have no inside knowledge here; I’m just spitballing.)
• A reworked luxury tax with harsher penalties: Maybe the new plan actually has teeth and sends a lot more money to smaller-market teams when the Dodgers, Mets or Yankees exceed the limit.
uncertain
Dodgers → include → limit
Maybe the owners have come up with a plan to distribute TV money so smaller markets benefit in a meaningful way while still allowing the big markets to keep some of their revenue.
asserted
markets → come → revenue
• Expanded playoffs: They’ve already proposed a version of expanded playoffs, but maybe they want to expand the field to 14 teams and expand the LDS to a best-of-seven.
asserted
they → expand → seven
(I actually have a good plan for a 14-team playoff.)
asserted
I → have → playoff
This has been bandied about for a while, but maybe they have an actual desire and plan to do it.
asserted
they → bandy → it
Teams switch leagues and everything’s about geography.
asserted
everything → switch → geography
Maybe they even drop leagues entirely in favor of conferences.
asserted
they → drop → conferences
Maybe the plan reduces teams’ travel to the point of saving a ton of money.
asserted
plan → reduce → money
• Some kind of mid-season tournament, ala the NBA: Maybe owners want a 150-game season and a weeklong tournament in July.
asserted
owners → want → July
Maybe it replaces the All-Star Game.
asserted
it → replace → Game
Or maybe it’s in addition to the All-Star Game.
asserted
it → ’ → Game
Either way, it’s more TV and more money.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Maybe the ultimate result doesn’t look anything like this.
asserted
result → look → this
Maybe the owners back off a cap (like usual) and they just continue to make do under a system that’s just a marginal improvement over what they have now.
asserted
they → back → what
Or maybe there is no Plan B and a salary cap/floor really is the only play this time.
asserted
floor → be → ?
If so, we could be in for a much darker and colder winter than usual — and a baseball-less spring that’s noticeably less joyful.
uncertain
that → ’ → winter