The health board at the centre of a row over avoidable patient deaths faces going ‘bust’ as damages claims for negligence are forecast to top £100million.
uncertain
claims → face → 100million
Lawyers are lining up to pursue ‘potentially devastating’ compensation claims against NHS Grampian following allegations that patients died unnecessarily after receiving treatment at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI).
uncertain
patients → line → Infirmary
The warnings follow explosive claims by whistleblower surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib, who says repeated warnings about patient deaths and surgical outcomes were not adequately acted upon for years.
uncertain
warnings → follow → years
His lawyer, Aamer Anwar, has compared the hospital to a ‘slaughterhouse’ amid an ongoing Police Scotland investigation.
asserted
lawyer → compare → investigation
Warnings of financial turmoil came as a former NHS official claimed the scandal could accelerate the demise of the embattled health board.
uncertain
scandal → come → board
The row escalated as former First Minister and ex-Health Secretary Humza Yousaf told the Mail he would be willing to co-operate with ‘any review that takes place’, after Dr Habib said he had written to Mr Yousaf to warn him about the needless deaths.
asserted
he → escalate → deaths
Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay said: ‘NHS Grampian is already shortchanged by the SNP Government and now faces potentially devastating compensations demands.
asserted
Grampian → say → demands
‘Any compensation bill would be met by Scotland’s hard-pressed taxpayers.
asserted
bill → meet → taxpayers
Whistleblower surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib says repeated warnings about patient deaths and surgical outcomes were not adequately acted upon for years
‘
asserted
warnings → say → years
John Swinney’s government and the NHS board must be up front about any likely legal costs and guarantee that this won’t have any impact on the delivery of healthcare for people in north-east Scotland.
asserted
this → guarantee → Scotland
NHS Grampian is already under direct intervention from the Scottish Government, faces a projected underlying deficit of £76million, and remains under intense scrutiny following a damning review by Healthcare Improvement Scotland.
asserted
Grampian → face → Scotland
A former NHS source said: ‘Damages at the level currently being quoted would place unbearable strain on the health board’s already stretched finances, and the political reality is that central government would have to step in to cover the costs.
‘
asserted
government → say → costs
However, SNP reforms of the NHS might well lead to the abolition of NHS Grampian before it can be sued — and this row might hasten its demise.’
uncertain
row → lead → demise
The SNP Government is planning to reduce the number of health boards from 14 to two.
asserted
Government → plan → two
The source added: ‘There have been clear signs of a poor working relationship between clinicians and the board going back at least a decade.
‘There has been a long history of dysfunction.’
asserted
source → add → dysfunction
Another former NHS insider noted: ‘Technically, the board could go “bust”, but central government, and therefore the taxpayer, would end up with the bill.’
uncertain
government → note → bill
An unpublished 2022 review commissioned by NHS Grampian, carried out by external experts Professor Stephen Wigmore and Professor Giles Toogood, examined 45 cases flagged by whistleblowers.
asserted
review → commission → whistleblowers
It found 31 of the patients had died, with 19 deaths considered the result of avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention.
asserted
deaths → find → surgery
Reviewing outcomes from 2015 to 2021, the experts concluded that mortality rates for major liver and pancreatic surgery were far above accepted standards.
asserted
rates → review → standards
Overall mortality following major liver resections between 2017 and 2020 was 12 per cent after 30 days and 18 per cent after 90 days, compared with an expected rate of 2.2 per cent.
asserted
mortality → follow → cent
Lawyers believe the financial consequences could be enormous.
uncertain
consequences → believe → ?
Patrick McGuire, a senior partner with Thompsons Solicitors Scotland – who has represented families affected by the Queen Elizabeth Hospital scandal in Glasgow and victims of disgraced Dundee surgeon Sam Eljamel – said claims could ultimately exceed £100million.
uncertain
claims → represent → 100million
He said: ‘What has been laid bare by Dr Habib in his explosive and courageous press conference is the stuff of nightmare, more suited to some Dickensian sick house rather than a hospital in 21st-century Scotland.’
asserted
laid → say → Scotland
Mr McGuire added: ‘It’s already clear that compensation payments will exceed ten million pounds.
asserted
payments → add → pounds
‘By the time the full extent of the scandal is known, I fully expect the compensation levels to exceed one hundred million pounds.’
asserted
levels → know → pounds
Trish McFadden, a partner at Digby Brown and a clinical negligence specialist, added: ‘The reports coming out about NHS Grampian are understandably shocking to all patients in that area.
asserted
reports → add → area
‘In this day and age, people should trust when they go to hospital they will receive the best care and treatment.
asserted
they → trust → care
‘There will no doubt be many people questioning what their legal rights are if they were affected by the issues outlined in the recent review from HIS, and it’s important they seek independent legal advice to be sure.’
asserted
they → question → advice
Aberdeen Royal Infirmary is at the centre of the controversy
Speaking to the BBC, Derek Appleton, 60, described how he nearly died during surgery at ARI to remove 60 per cent of his liver.
asserted
he → speak → liver
He lost 11 litres of blood, suffered a cardiac arrest, and was placed into an induced coma.
asserted
He → lose → coma
‘Technically I died; not one single person in theatre thought I was going to come out alive,’ he said, adding: ‘I am not the same person that went into the Aberdeen Royal.’
asserted
that → die → Royal
The operation he underwent is no longer carried out in the hospital, with patients now transferred to Edinburgh.
Meanwhile, the political row over the allegations continued to deepen.
asserted
row → undergo → allegations
Health Secretary Angela Constance said Thursday was the first time she had seen Dr Habib’s ‘correspondence’ – and insisted she had confidence in NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight.
asserted
she → say → Knight
She said the ‘history of some of the very distressing issues pre-dates her appointment’.
asserted
history → say → appointment
Scotland’s Patient Safety Commissioner, Karen Titchener, voiced concern that the full picture may still not have emerged, telling BBC Radio Scotland: ‘I’m not feeling confident about it.’
She also described it as ‘totally unacceptable’ that the Health Secretary had not been aware of the issues raised in the reports.
uncertain
Secretary → voice → reports
Dr Habib said he repeatedly wrote to Mr Yousaf and other ministers about his concerns over patient safety and surgical deaths at ARI.
asserted
he → say → ARI
Asked about the correspondence, Mr Yousaf’s office did not dispute that contact had taken place but declined to say when he first became aware of the issues or whether he had been informed of the findings of the Wigmore-Toogood review.
asserted
he → ask → review
A spokesman for Mr Yousaf said: ‘Humza supports full transparency about what happened at NHS Grampian and will cooperate fully with any review that takes place.
asserted
that → say → place
‘Humza has made it clear that he supports minutes from the period in question being released.’
asserted
minutes → make → question